Rule of law remains a distant prospect in China 21 months after its entry into the WTO, and those who expected revolutionary changes were kidding themselves, according to observers.
China has been careful to make only the legal revisions that were explicitly required as a condition of joining the Geneva-based trade body, avoiding a more sweeping transformation of its legal system.
"China has done only the things called for by the WTO," said Ling Bing, a law professor at City University of Hong Kong.
PHOTO: REUTERS
Among the reforms introduced are rules allowing individuals and companies to bring lawsuits to courts if they are not happy about administrative decisions made in WTO-related fields.
WTO membership has also resulted in a slew of law amendments in areas such as intellectual property rights and regulations on particular industries, such as telecommunications and insurance.
But legal reform in a broader sense, going beyond rule-making in the commercial, investment and foreign trade field, has not taken place.
"In more domestic legal areas, civil law, criminal law and administrative law, I haven't seen significant changes as a result of WTO membership," said Ling.
"WTO rules don't govern all aspects of social and economic life in China. My perception is that people had too much of an expectation of WTO membership," he said.
For any society, laws are the most fundamental rules of the game, and overnight change is unlikely to happen.
But in China, this is compounded by the dominance of a communist party seemingly bent on staying in power and loth to implement too far-reaching change, according to analysts.
"The basic principles of China's legal system haven't changed, and they're not going to change with the one-party system," said Jean-Pierre Cabestan, director of the Hong Kong-based French Center for Research on Contemporary China.
"It's going to take time, but it's not just a question of time, it's a question of political system. Here, we're reaching the boundaries of the current political system in China," he said.
China's legal system is saddled with a host of problems, many of them reflecting the fact that there is no tradition of an independent judiciary.
Local judges are hired and paid for by local governments, making for a tight, symbiotic relationship.
This also means that WTO reforms, such as the possibility of court probes into trade-related administrative acts, may be hard to implement, according to observers.
China was relatively active in pursuing legal reform in the first year after its entry into the WTO, while this year has seen a slowdown, according to Leila Chouk-roune, a lecturer on international law at the Sorbonne University in Paris.
Not all of it was the result of any deliberate intention to stall the process.
No one could have foreseen the shutdown of much of society that was caused by the outbreak of Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome (SARS) earlier this year, she said.
Another reason was the transfer of power to a new generation of political leaders, which also entailed an important revamp of China's economic decision-making bodies.
For instance, the Ministry of Foreign Trade, which had overseen the last difficult part of China's WTO entry negotiations, was replaced by a Ministry of Commerce, a super-agency also in charge of domestic trade.
"The year 2003 has been a bit confused," said Choukroune. "It's still confused who is who, and who is doing what."
Beijing’s continued provocations in the Taiwan Strait reveal its intention to unilaterally change the “status quo” in the area, the US Department of State said on Saturday, calling for a peaceful resolution to cross-strait issues. The Coast Guard Administration (CGA) reported that four China Coast Guard patrol vessels entered restricted and prohibited waters near Kinmen County on Friday and again on Saturday. A State Department spokesperson said that Washington was aware of the incidents, and urged all parties to exercise restraint and refrain from unilaterally changing the “status quo.” “Maintaining peace and stability across the Taiwan Strait is in line with our [the
EXTENDED RANGE: Hsiung Sheng missiles, 100 of which might be deployed by the end of the year, could reach Chinese command posts and airport runways, a source said A NT$16.9 billion (US$534.93 million) project to upgrade the military’s missile defense systems would be completed this year, allowing the deployment of at least 100 long-range Hsiung Sheng missiles and providing more deterrence against China, military sources said on Saturday. Hsiung Sheng missiles are an extended-range version of the Hsiung Feng IIE (HF-2E) surface-to-surface cruise missile, and are believed to have a range of up to 1,200km, which would allow them to hit targets well inside China. They went into mass production in 2022, the sources said. The project is part of a special budget for the Ministry of National Defense aimed at
READY TO WORK: Taiwan is eager to cooperate and is hopeful that like-minded states will continue to advocate for its inclusion in regional organizations, Lai said Maintaining the “status quo” in the Taiwan Strait, and peace and stability in the Indo-Pacific region must be a top priority, president-elect William Lai (賴清德) said yesterday after meeting with a delegation of US academics. Leaders of the G7, US President Joe Biden and other international heads of state have voiced concerns about the situation in the Strait, as stability in the region is necessary for a safe, peaceful and prosperous world, Lai said. The vice president, who is to be inaugurated in May, welcomed the delegation and thanked them for their support for Taiwan and issues concerning the Strait. The international community
COOPERATION: Two crewmembers from a Chinese fishing boat that sank off Kinmen were rescued, two were found dead and another two were still missing at press time The Coast Guard Administration (CGA) was yesterday working with Chinese rescuers to find two missing crewmembers from a Chinese fishing boat that sank southwest of Kinmen County yesterday, killing two crew. The joint operation managed to rescue two of the boat’s six crewmembers, but two were already dead when they were pulled from the water, the agency said in a statement. Rescuers are still searching for two others from the Min Long Yu 61222, a boat registered in China’s Fujian Province that capsized and sank 1.03 nautical miles (1.9km) southwest of Dongding Island (東碇), it added. CGA Director-General Chou Mei-wu (周美伍) told a