A key UN body has condemned as arbitrary and illegal Australia’s indefinite incarceration of refugees and asylum seekers, issuing critical statements on five separate cases in a year.
However, those unlawfully held remain in indefinite detention, where they have been held for up to nine years without charge.
The Working Group on Arbitrary Detention is a key part of the UN’s Human Rights Council, on which Australia sits after a years-long public and diplomatic campaign for the position. The group is an independent body of human rights experts that assesses cases of alleged arbitrary detention and reports to the council.
Since June last year, the group has published five opinions critical of Australia’s open-ended detention of asylum seekers and refugees.
It has consistently argued that Australia’s indefinite detention of some refugees and asylum seekers is unlawful.
In each of the five published opinions, the group has recommended that Australia immediately release the men held and pay them “compensation and other reparations” for their unlawful detention.
None of the men have been released. The youngest is 29 years old, the oldest 45. They each face detention without charge — in theory, potentially until the end of their lives.
The longest in detention is an Afghan asylum seeker, who has been held in Australian detention centers continuously since 2009.
His claim for protection has been rejected, but he still has appeals before the courts, and his case has been complicated by the Australian government leaking his personal details online, potentially compromising his safety in his home country.
Stateless Western Sahara man Said Imasi has been held without allegation, charge, or trial for more than eight years since he arrived in Australia by airplane as a teenager in 2010.
His case is set to go before the High Court of Australia this year, brought by Human Rights For All.
Others represent complex cases, where Australia’s obligation under international law to offer protection refugees is in conflict with adverse “character assessments,” mental health issues and domestic legal requirements to cancel visas.
In one case, a former child soldier from Sudan’s civil war brought to Australia as a teenage refugee 15 years ago, and who has ongoing and acute mental health issues, has been convicted of 40 criminal offenses and had his visa canceled after two warnings.
The Australian government has canceled his visa on character grounds, but cannot send him to any other country. He faces a potentially indefinite detention.
Also being assessed by the group is the case of a stateless child refugee, revealed by the Guardian Australia last week, who was brought to Australia by boat as a 16-year-old, and who remains in immigration detention after five years and facing a potentially limitless incarceration.
The group has consistently condemned Australia’s reliance on indefinite detention.
In several cases, the open-ended detention has also been criticized by Australia’s own commonwealth ombudsman. In the case of Imasi, the ombudsman has said it has been recommending for six years he be released into the Australian community, but “there appears to be no clear resolution in sight.”
The Australian government has defended its policies, arguing before the UN working group that its detention regime “is administrative in nature and not for punitive purposes,” and had succeeded in stopping the flow of asylum seeker boats to Australia.
“The government is committed to ensuring that all people in administrative immigration detention are treated in a manner consistent with the international legal obligations of Australia,” it said.
The government said detention was “not limited by a set time frame,” but dependent upon factors such as identity, health, character, or security matters.
“Relevant assessments are completed as expeditiously as possible to facilitate the shortest possible time frame for detaining people in immigration detention facilities,” it said.
The indefinite detention of non-citizens is allowed under Australian law. A 2004 high court judgment — Al Kateb versus Godwin — found that it was lawful to indefinitely detain a non-citizen who could not be removed from Australia.
Subsequent governments have appeared anxious not to have the issue revisited by the court — no justices from Al-Kateb remain — and cases involving indefinite detention are often resolved just before they reach the bench.
The director-principal of Human Rights For All, lawyer Alison Battisson, who has brought all six of the indefinite detention cases before the group, said the UN had made a clear statement that Australia’s practice of indefinitely detaining refugees and asylum seekers is unlawful, and must cease.
“Australia’s policies are against international law and are inhumane,” she said. “In a modern society this practice is unacceptable. Despite numerous opinions and reports from the UN and other human rights bodies, Australia has consistently failed to address arbitrary detention.”
“As a signatory to the refugees convention we are obliged to accommodate these people. Where they have criminal records, they have served their time. If they were Australian citizens, they would be returned to the community. Instead, they often face longer periods of open-end administrative detention than their actual prison terms. This serves no one’s interests,” she said.
Battisson said the UN was continuing to monitor all the cases.
The Australian government is also obliged, as a UN member state, to update the group on progress of the cases.
“The Australian government’s lack of response is shameful. It is also insulting to the UN. The working group is currently finalizing its annual report to the Human Rights Council, and Australia should be worried about what this report contains,” Battisson said.
MONEY MATTERS: Xi was to highlight projects such as a new high-speed railway between Belgrade and Budapest, as Serbia is entirely open to Chinese trade and investment Serbian President Aleksandar Vucic yesterday said that “Taiwan is China” as he made a speech welcoming Chinese President Xi Jinping (習近平) to Belgrade, state broadcaster Radio Television of Serbia (RTS) said. “We have a clear and simple position regarding Chinese territorial integrity,” he told a crowd outside the government offices while Xi applauded him. “Yes, Taiwan is China.” Xi landed in Belgrade on Tuesday night on the second leg of his European tour, and was greeted by Vucic and most government ministers. Xi had just completed a two-day trip to France, where he held talks with French President Emmanuel Macron as the
With the midday sun blazing, an experimental orange and white F-16 fighter jet launched with a familiar roar that is a hallmark of US airpower, but the aerial combat that followed was unlike any other: This F-16 was controlled by artificial intelligence (AI), not a human pilot, and riding in the front seat was US Secretary of the Air Force Frank Kendall. AI marks one of the biggest advances in military aviation since the introduction of stealth in the early 1990s, and the US Air Force has aggressively leaned in. Even though the technology is not fully developed, the service is planning
INTERNATIONAL PROBE: Australian and US authorities were helping coordinate the investigation of the case, which follows the 2015 murder of Australian surfers in Mexico Three bodies were found in Mexico’s Baja California state, the FBI said on Friday, days after two Australians and an American went missing during a surfing trip in an area hit by cartel violence. Authorities used a pulley system to hoist what appeared to be lifeless bodies covered in mud from a shaft on a cliff high above the Pacific. “We confirm there were three individuals found deceased in Santo Tomas, Baja California,” a statement from the FBI’s office in San Diego, California, said without providing the identities of the victims. Australian brothers Jake and Callum Robinson and their American friend Jack Carter
CUSTOMS DUTIES: France’s cognac industry was closely watching the talks, fearing that an anti-dumping investigation opened by China is retaliation for trade tensions French President Emmanuel Macron yesterday hosted Chinese President Xi Jinping (習近平) at one of his beloved childhood haunts in the Pyrenees, seeking to press a message to Beijing not to support Russia’s war against Ukraine and to accept fairer trade. The first day of Xi’s state visit to France, his first to Europe since 2019, saw respectful, but sometimes robust exchanges between the two men during a succession of talks on Monday. Macron, joined initially by EU Commission President Ursula von der Leyen, urged Xi not to allow the export of any technology that could be used by Russia in its invasion