A curious monkey with a toothy grin and a knack for pressing a camera button was back in the spotlight on Wednesday as a US federal appeals court heard arguments on whether an animal can hold a copyright to selfies.
A 45-minute hearing before a three-judge panel of the US Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit in San Francisco attracted crowds of law students and curious citizens who often burst into laughter.
The federal judges also chuckled at times at the novelty of the case, which involves a male monkey named Naruto that is unaware of the fuss.
Andrew Dhuey, attorney for British nature photographer David Slater, said “monkey see, monkey sue” is not good law under any federal act.
Slater could not afford the airfare to San Francisco to attend the hearing.
He also cannot afford to replace his broken camera equipment, has no money to pay Dhuey, who has been defending him since 2015, and is currently exploring other ways to earn income.
Slater has long maintained that the “selfies” were the result of his ingenuity in coaxing the monkeys into pressing the shutter release while looking into the lens, after he struggled to get them to keep their eyes open for a wide-angle close up.
“It wasn’t serendipitous monkey behavior,” he said. “It required a lot of knowledge on my behalf, a lot of perseverance, sweat and anguish and all that stuff.”
People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals (PETA) sued Slater and San Francisco-based self-publishing company Blurb, which published the book Wildlife Personalities that includes the monkey selfies, for copyright infringement.
It sought a court order in 2015 allowing it to administer all proceeds from the photographs taken in a wildlife reserve in Sulawesi, Indonesia, to benefit the monkey.
Slater has said the British copyright for the photographs obtained by his company, Wildlife Personalities, should be honored.
PETA attorney David Schwarz argued that Naruto was accustomed to cameras and took the selfies when he saw himself in the reflection of the lens.
A federal judge last year ruled against PETA and Naruto, saying the monkey lacked the right to sue because there was no indication that US Congress intended to extend copyright protection to animals.
Throughout Wednesday’s hearing, Schwarz pushed back, arguing that the case came down to one simple fact: photographs can be copyrighted and Naruto is the author.
The judges grilled him on why PETA has status to represent Naruto and said that “having genuine care for the animal” is not enough to establish “next friend” relationship, which is required to represent it in court.
The judges did not issue a ruling on Wednesday.
An attorney for Blurb also raised the question of whether PETA has even identified the right monkey — something that Slater disputes.
“I know for a fact that [the monkey in the photograph] is a female and it’s the wrong age,” he said. “I’m bewildered at the American court system. Surely it matters that the right monkey is suing me.”
Additional reporting by the Guardian
MONEY MATTERS: Xi was to highlight projects such as a new high-speed railway between Belgrade and Budapest, as Serbia is entirely open to Chinese trade and investment Serbian President Aleksandar Vucic yesterday said that “Taiwan is China” as he made a speech welcoming Chinese President Xi Jinping (習近平) to Belgrade, state broadcaster Radio Television of Serbia (RTS) said. “We have a clear and simple position regarding Chinese territorial integrity,” he told a crowd outside the government offices while Xi applauded him. “Yes, Taiwan is China.” Xi landed in Belgrade on Tuesday night on the second leg of his European tour, and was greeted by Vucic and most government ministers. Xi had just completed a two-day trip to France, where he held talks with French President Emmanuel Macron as the
With the midday sun blazing, an experimental orange and white F-16 fighter jet launched with a familiar roar that is a hallmark of US airpower, but the aerial combat that followed was unlike any other: This F-16 was controlled by artificial intelligence (AI), not a human pilot, and riding in the front seat was US Secretary of the Air Force Frank Kendall. AI marks one of the biggest advances in military aviation since the introduction of stealth in the early 1990s, and the US Air Force has aggressively leaned in. Even though the technology is not fully developed, the service is planning
INTERNATIONAL PROBE: Australian and US authorities were helping coordinate the investigation of the case, which follows the 2015 murder of Australian surfers in Mexico Three bodies were found in Mexico’s Baja California state, the FBI said on Friday, days after two Australians and an American went missing during a surfing trip in an area hit by cartel violence. Authorities used a pulley system to hoist what appeared to be lifeless bodies covered in mud from a shaft on a cliff high above the Pacific. “We confirm there were three individuals found deceased in Santo Tomas, Baja California,” a statement from the FBI’s office in San Diego, California, said without providing the identities of the victims. Australian brothers Jake and Callum Robinson and their American friend Jack Carter
CUSTOMS DUTIES: France’s cognac industry was closely watching the talks, fearing that an anti-dumping investigation opened by China is retaliation for trade tensions French President Emmanuel Macron yesterday hosted Chinese President Xi Jinping (習近平) at one of his beloved childhood haunts in the Pyrenees, seeking to press a message to Beijing not to support Russia’s war against Ukraine and to accept fairer trade. The first day of Xi’s state visit to France, his first to Europe since 2019, saw respectful, but sometimes robust exchanges between the two men during a succession of talks on Monday. Macron, joined initially by EU Commission President Ursula von der Leyen, urged Xi not to allow the export of any technology that could be used by Russia in its invasion