In a landmark decision, Hong Kong’s highest court yesterday ruled against granting residency to two Philippine domestic workers, dashing the hopes of several hundred thousand other domestic helpers from ever gaining permanent residency in the territory.
Five judges at the Court of Final Appeal ruled unanimously that Evangeline Banao Vallejos and Daniel Domingo would not be allowed to settle permanently in Hong Kong after residing there for more than seven years, a period that would ordinarily qualify foreigners to become permanent residents under the constitution.
The court ruled that domestic workers should not be treated as “ordinarily resident” in the financial hub given contracts that tied them to finite temporary employment.
Photo: Reuters
“The nature of foreign domestic helpers’ residence in Hong Kong is highly restrictive,” the judgment said. “The foreign domestic helper is obliged to return to the country of origin at the end of the contract and is told from the outset that admission is not for the purposes of settlement.”
A lower court had previously ruled that the Philippine pair had the right to seek permanent residency in the territory.
Over the past few years, the controversial legal battle has divided Hong Kongers over whether 286,000 domestic helpers — largely from the Philippines and Indonesia, but also other countries like Nepal, India and Pakistan — should be entitled to residency on a par with other foreigners.
A small group of migrant workers protested the ruling outside the historic red-brick courthouse, denouncing it as institutionalized discrimination.
“Today is a very sad day for migrant workers in Hong Kong,” said Eman Villanueva, the head of Philippine advocacy group United Filipinos in Hong Kong. “It gave its judicial seal to unfair treatment and the social exclusion of foreign domestic helpers in Hong Kong.”
The ruling also bars dependents of domestic workers from seeking residency in Hong Kong.
Critics say that the economic burden that would be caused by such an influx could have been huge, given education, housing, healthcare and welfare costs. One political party estimated that it could cost taxpayers an extra HK$25 billion (US$3.2 billion) per year.
Many Hong Kong families and expatriates consider having a maid essential, with many employing a live-in helper who cooks, cleans and helps with childcare. However, maids are excluded from a minimum wage and other basic services.
Despite the government’s victory, lingering ambiguity over eligibility for permanent residency in Hong Kong as stipulated in the Basic Law, the territory’s mini-constitution, could trigger further legal battles in the future.
Hong Kong, a former British colony that returned to Chinese rule in 1997, has always had an uneasy relationship with immigration and right of residency issues that have sometimes strained its ties with Beijing.
A 1999 case which ruled that China-born children had a right of abode in Hong Kong sparked an outcry over Beijing’s perceived meddling in the territory’s judicial independence.
The government had asked Hong Kong’s highest court to seek Beijing’s clarification on precisely who qualifies for right of abode in a bid to resolve the issue, but the court of final appeal rejected this request.
Chinese President Xi Jinping (習近平) is to visit Russia next month for a summit of the BRICS bloc of developing economies, Chinese Minister of Foreign Affairs Wang Yi (王毅) said on Thursday, a move that comes as Moscow and Beijing seek to counter the West’s global influence. Xi’s visit to Russia would be his second since the Kremlin sent troops into Ukraine in February 2022. China claims to take a neutral position in the conflict, but it has backed the Kremlin’s contentions that Russia’s action was provoked by the West, and it continues to supply key components needed by Moscow for
Japan scrambled fighter jets after Russian aircraft flew around the archipelago for the first time in five years, Tokyo said yesterday. From Thursday morning to afternoon, the Russian Tu-142 aircraft flew from the sea between Japan and South Korea toward the southern Okinawa region, the Japanese Ministry of Defense said in a statement. They then traveled north over the Pacific Ocean and finished their journey off the northern island of Hokkaido, it added. The planes did not enter Japanese airspace, but flew over an area subject to a territorial dispute between Japan and Russia, a ministry official said. “In response, we mobilized Air Self-Defense
CRITICISM: ‘One has to choose the lesser of two evils,’ Pope Francis said, as he criticized Trump’s anti-immigrant policies and Harris’ pro-choice position Pope Francis on Friday accused both former US president Donald Trump and US Vice President Kamala Harris of being “against life” as he returned to Rome from a 12-day tour of the Asia-Pacific region. The 87-year-old pontiff’s comments on the US presidential hopefuls came as he defied health concerns to connect with believers from the jungle of Papua New Guinea to the skyscrapers of Singapore. It was Francis’ longest trip in duration and distance since becoming head of the world’s nearly 1.4 billion Roman Catholics more than 11 years ago. Despite the marathon visit, he held a long and spirited
The pitch is a classic: A young celebrity with no climbing experience spends a year in hard training and scales Mount Everest, succeeding against some — if not all — odds. French YouTuber Ines Benazzouz, known as Inoxtag, brought the story to life with a two-hour-plus documentary about his year preparing for the ultimate challenge. The film, titled Kaizen, proved a smash hit on its release last weekend. Young fans queued around the block to get into a preview screening in Paris, with Inoxtag’s management on Monday saying the film had smashed the box office record for a special cinema