US President George W. Bush on Wednesday cited a teaching hospital in Najaf as perhaps the top example of a successful rebuilding project in Iraq. Since the US-led attack against local militias leveled large portions of Najaf in August last year, however, the hospital has been most notable as a place where claims of success have fallen far short of reality.
During two visits to the hospital by reporters for the New York Times over the past year, the most recent in late summer, work on refurbishing it had been limited to largely cosmetic work like new ceilings and lighting and fresh paint. Critical medical equipment was missing and the upper floors remained a chaotic mess.
Numerous Iraqis at the site said the hospital had not been ruined by the militia that occupied it during last year's fighting, but instead by looters who entered after the US military left it unguarded after the battle.
US officials in charge of the project said US$2 million had been spent on the first phase of a planned two-phase, US$12 million renovation. So it is possible that work on the second phase has addressed some of the problems at the site.
While Bush cited the modest security improvements in Najaf, 145km south of Baghdad, and in the northern city of Mosul, he did not point out the often highly sectarian nature of local security forces that now patrol the cities.
Only last Sunday, Ayad Allawi, the former Iraqi prime minister who asked the US military to roust the militia from Najaf in 2003, was pelted with sticks and stones during his visit to the Imam Ali mosque in Najaf. Local security forces did nothing to stop the attack, almost certainly because they, like the mob outside the mosque, were loyal to the rebellious Shiite cleric Muqtada al-Sadr. It was al-Sadr's militia that the US battled in Najaf last year.
The hospital, named after al-Sadr's father, is an example of the slow pace of rebuilding. Wayne White, a former State Department official whose responsibilities included Iraq from 2003 to this year, and who is now at the Middle East Institute, a research organization, said the US mission in Iraq was often undermined by that slow pace.
"Not only does it run far behind Iraqi expectations, but in some areas we have not even recovered to what Iraq was before the invasion," White said.
He noted that some industries, including those involving metals and chemical production, still had not recovered from the invasion and the aftermath of looting, either.
A major problem with assessing the progress in Iraq is that it is too dangerous to allow visitors to visit the projects freely, said Rick Barton of the Center for Strategic and International Studies in Washington.
"I bet if we could get around and see these places that they would not be the story that he's telling," he said.
"And I think he'd be shocked to see the story he's being fed," he added.
Not all the accounts that Bush offered of reconstruction were positive. He conceded problems with "the infiltration of militia groups into some Iraqi security forces, especially the Iraqi police." And he did not assert that all had gone smoothly with the rebuilding effort.
"Like most of Iraq, the reconstruction in Najaf has proceeded with fits and starts since liberation -- it's been uneven," Bush said.
Visits to the cities Bush highlighted suggest that residents in Najaf feel safer and that Mosul's police force is more effective than when it collapsed in the face of the insurgency late last year. But the improvements have often produced little more than an assurance that the police, who still must be heavily backed by US firepower, will not flee in the face of an attack.