Sun, Aug 01, 2004 page6

• Pope set to hammer at feminism

  • THE GUARDIAN
  • • 
    • 
    • 

  Pope John Paul II yesterday was to call on leaders of the Roman Catholic church to attack feminist ideologies which assert that men and women are fundamentally the same.

  The Vatican is concerned that this belief is eroding what it regards as women's maternal vocation. But a paper on the subject which was due to be published yesterday -- the Vatican's third major pronouncement on women's role in the quarter century of John Paul's papacy -- drew scornful criticism from feminists and academics.

  

  Pope John Paul II is kissed by an unidentified nun during a weekly general audience at the Vatican on Wednesday.

  PHOTO: AP

  According to a leaked extract, the document accuses feminists of "blurring the biological difference between man and woman."

  But it is also understood to break new ground by appealing to governments for help to be given to women so they can cope with their broader modern responsibilities.

  It emerged on Friday that the Vatican itself had taken a further step towards incorporating women into the previously all-male leadership of the Roman Catholic church. A nun, who was not named in Italian media reports, was said to be working as a high-level aide to the Pope's "foreign minister," Archbishop Giovanni Lajolo.

  The statement of doctrine on gender issues represents a first serious attempt by the Vatican to come to grips with a world of working women. But it is clearly intended to prevent any erosion of the church's resolute opposition to gay marriage, the incorporation of women in the priesthood and trends in gender studies the Pope has damned as "misleading conceptions of sexuality."

  The Vatican's sights are trained in particular on the view that, while people's sex is anatomically determined, their gender identity and roles are entirely a product of conditioning. In a letter to bishops on the participation of men and women in the church and the world, the Pope's chief theological spokesman, the German cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, stresses, as the pontiff has done on several occasions, that the book of Genesis is unambiguous on this point.

  The letter was drawn up inside Cardinal Ratzinger's Vatican "ministry," the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith. However, as a statement of doctrine, it would not have been sent for publication without the consent of the Pope.

  The Vatican's letter acknowledges that the emancipation of women, which the pontiff applauded in his earliest pronouncements on the subject, has given them a vastly increased presence in the labor market.

  Recent decades have seen a plunge in birth and fertility rates, particularly in the Roman Catholic heartland of southern Europe, as women struggle to combine jobs with their traditional roles as mothers, homemakers and caregivers.

  Church representatives have argued that this is symptomatic of a breakdown in values, and particularly a greater selfishness among young couples more interested in consumer goods than in creating life.

  Feminists have long held it is a result of the reluctance of men to share household tasks and the failure of governments to provide adequate support for families.

  Cardinal Ratzinger's document appears to have embraced implicitly the feminist view on this point, though in language unlikely to win over many feminists.

  According to a leaked extract in the German tabloid Bild Zeitung, his letter to bishops calls on governments to "create conditions that enable women not to neglect their family duties when they enter into a job."

  Helena Cronin, an evolutionary psychologist at the London School of Economics, said "It's absolutely true that we are different, in a variety of ways. But I have no reason to expect the Pope to be correct about the way in which men and women are different, given his general grasp of science."

  She said that in all mammals, females showed a greater propensity to caring for the young than males did. But she added: "That's not saying that women have no other vocations, or that they should be devoted [to motherhood]."

  The feminist author Natasha Walter questioned whether there were essential differences between men and women at all.

  "We have centuries and centuries of acculturation towards a `vocation' of maternity, and men have only had a couple of generations of acculturation towards active paternity," she said.
• Most Popular

  • 1

    Inter edge Atalanta to stay top

  • 2

    Magnitude 7.0 quake hits Yilan

  • 3

    China using AI vote meddling: report

  • 4

    Morocco held by Mali, ending record wins run

  • 5

    Taiwan prepares to ring in 2026: Watch here