In the fall of 2001, US President George W. Bush justified his decision to treat some captured terrorist suspects as "enemy combatants" without access to lawyers, courts or other long-established legal rights on the grounds that he could not let the US' "enemies use the forums of liberty to destroy liberty itself."
On Monday morning, the Supreme Court upended a good-sized chunk of that logic, and offered a powerful reminder that in the US, even in wartime, no prisoner is ever beneath the law's regard, and no president above its limits.
It was Justice Robert Jackson who first noted 52 years ago this month, in another wartime election summer, that a president is not commander in chief of the country, only of the military. Jackson wrote that in his concurring opinion overturning then-president Harry Truman's seizure of the American steel industry during the Korean War, and Justice David Souter cited those words approvingly in his concurrence on Monday.
The effect of the current court's rulings in two related cases was to place a classic institutional and political check on Bush's effort to keep some citizens and aliens held as the most dangerous "enemy combatants" from ever having their day in any court.
It is precisely the right to some such hearing, the court held, that defines the constitutional separation of powers and by extension the American governing creed.
While Bush will now have to seek explicit congressional authorization in dealing with these terrorist suspects, that should not be an insurmountable task for this president. But it falls to him at a time when he is already facing challenges on many fronts, including the handover of sovereignty in a still-dangerous Iraq, questions about his administration's policies on interrogation of prisoners of war and polls that show slipping public support for his handling the war on terrorism and uncertain prospects for his re-election.
"It is a clear demonstration of how much our system of checks and balances, of separation of powers, continues to be an effective brake on any one branch," said the historian Robert Dallek. "After all, this is not a left-leaning court, or one dominated by justices who are left of center. But ultimately the court has a unique degree of independence from the executive and legislative branches, that even in times of great difficulty it does not lightly give up."
Justice Clarence Thomas dissented from the majority in the case of Yaser Esam Hamdi, an American citizen picked up in Afghanistan and held mostly without access to the outside world ever since.
"The founders intended that the president have primary responsibility -- along with the necessary power -- to protect the national security and to conduct the nation's foreign relations," Thomas wrote. "They did so principally because the structural advantages of a unitary executive are essential in these domains."
The White House chose to emphasize the parts of the majority opinions in the Hamdi case, and another involving foreign detainees at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba, that supported the president's ability to detain "enemy combatants" without trial.
The reaction to the ruling on Capitol Hill broke down along predictably partisan lines. Senator John Kerry of Massachusetts, the presumptive Democratic presidential nominee, praised the decision, saying: "I have argued all along with respect to detainees that it is vital to uphold the Constitution of the United States, to respect civil liberties and civil rights, even as we protect our country. I've suggested many ways you can do that, including judicial review, different kinds of review structures."
By contrast, Senator John Cornyn, a Texas Republican, the chairman of the Judiciary Committee's subcommittee on the constitution, civil rights and property rights, called the decisions "a bit of a disappointment," and added: "I am a little concerned about the new constraints that the Supreme Court has placed on the president as commander in chief. I hope that they don't represent handcuffs."
Some historians were not surprised by the court's decisions. Alonzo Hamby, a scholar of the presidency at Ohio University, noted wryly that "once upon a time, it was not assumed that presidents necessarily had to pay attention to Supreme Court decisions."
In the 1830s, when the Supreme Court declared the government's forced removal of Indian tribes from their lands illegal, president Andrew Jackson famously dismissed the ruling by the chief justice by saying: "John Marshall has made his decision. Now let him enforce it."
Hamby said, "But in the world we live in now, it's literally impossible for a president to ignore a Supreme Court decision, no matter how wrong or dangerous he may think it is."
Chinese President Xi Jinping (習近平) is to visit Russia next month for a summit of the BRICS bloc of developing economies, Chinese Minister of Foreign Affairs Wang Yi (王毅) said on Thursday, a move that comes as Moscow and Beijing seek to counter the West’s global influence. Xi’s visit to Russia would be his second since the Kremlin sent troops into Ukraine in February 2022. China claims to take a neutral position in the conflict, but it has backed the Kremlin’s contentions that Russia’s action was provoked by the West, and it continues to supply key components needed by Moscow for
Japan scrambled fighter jets after Russian aircraft flew around the archipelago for the first time in five years, Tokyo said yesterday. From Thursday morning to afternoon, the Russian Tu-142 aircraft flew from the sea between Japan and South Korea toward the southern Okinawa region, the Japanese Ministry of Defense said in a statement. They then traveled north over the Pacific Ocean and finished their journey off the northern island of Hokkaido, it added. The planes did not enter Japanese airspace, but flew over an area subject to a territorial dispute between Japan and Russia, a ministry official said. “In response, we mobilized Air Self-Defense
CRITICISM: ‘One has to choose the lesser of two evils,’ Pope Francis said, as he criticized Trump’s anti-immigrant policies and Harris’ pro-choice position Pope Francis on Friday accused both former US president Donald Trump and US Vice President Kamala Harris of being “against life” as he returned to Rome from a 12-day tour of the Asia-Pacific region. The 87-year-old pontiff’s comments on the US presidential hopefuls came as he defied health concerns to connect with believers from the jungle of Papua New Guinea to the skyscrapers of Singapore. It was Francis’ longest trip in duration and distance since becoming head of the world’s nearly 1.4 billion Roman Catholics more than 11 years ago. Despite the marathon visit, he held a long and spirited
China would train thousands of foreign law enforcement officers to see the world order “develop in a more fair, reasonable and efficient direction,” its minister for public security has said. “We will [also] send police consultants to countries in need to conduct training to help them quickly and effectively improve their law enforcement capabilities,” Chinese Minister of Public Security Wang Xiaohong (王小洪) told an annual global security forum. Wang made the announcement in the eastern city of Lianyungang on Monday in front of law enforcement representatives from 122 countries, regions and international organizations such as Interpol. The forum is part of ongoing