The Taiwan Jury Association yesterday opposed a plan by the Judicial Yuan to combine the jury system and the lay judge system, saying that introducing an unprecedented fusion of the two systems could be dangerous.
The government should implement a jury system instead of creating a “collage of inherently different systems using pure imagination,” the association said in a statement.
Local Chinese-language media on Sunday reported that the Judicial Yuan had decided to replace its proposal to introduce a lay judge system at the nation’s criminal courts with the combined system.
Photo: Wang Yi-sung, Taipei Times
In the original proposal, which is similar to the lay judge system in Japan, each case would be tried by three professional judges and six lay judges, reports said.
For a defendant to be found guilty, two-thirds, or six judges, including at least one professional judge, must vote in favor of the guilty verdict, they said.
The Judicial Yuan is leaning toward the combined system, which is close to a jury system, to appease jury system advocates, the reports said.
The new proposal divides criminal proceedings into two phases.
The first phase would be presided over by eight lay judges. For a defendant to be found guilty, all eight must unanimously agree on the verdict.
The second phase would be presided over by three professional judges, who would decide whether to second the guilty verdict.
If at least one of them agrees with the verdict, the three would then decide the penalties to be meted out.
If no professional judges agree, the defendant would not be found guilty. In death penalty cases, all 11 judges would have to agree to the verdict.
At a news conference at the Legislative Yuan, association president Wu Ching-chin (吳景欽), an associate professor of law at Aletheia University, said that the combined system is likely “an unprecedented invention.”
It is neither a lay judge system nor a jury system, put together by copying bits and pieces of the criminal justice system in Japan, the US and Germany, he said.
“That is very dangerous, because in a way you are treating defendants as guinea pigs,” he said.
He likened the system to driving a self-assembled car, adding: “We cannot even imagine the consequences.”
The Judicial Yuan on Monday said it has from the beginning planned to introduce a criminal justice system combining the strengths of the lay judge and jury systems.
It is open to advice and hopes to build a criminal justice system that best suits the nation, the Judicial Yuan added.
The Ministry of Foreign Affairs (MOFA) yesterday voiced dissatisfaction with the Comprehensive and Progressive Agreement for Trans- Pacific Partnership (CPTPP), whose latest meeting, concluded earlier the same day, appeared not to address the country’s application. In a statement, MOFA said the CPTPP commission had "once again failed to fairly process Taiwan’s application," attributing the inaction to the bloc’s "succumbing to political pressure," without elaborating. Taiwan submitted its CPTPP application under the name "Separate Customs Territory of Taiwan, Penghu, Kinmen and Matsu" on Sept. 22, 2021 -- less than a week after China
THE GOOD WORD: More than 100 colleges on both sides of the Pacific will work together to bring students to Taiwan so they can learn Mandarin where it is spoken A total of 102 universities from Taiwan and the US are collaborating in a push to promote Taiwan as the first-choice place to learn Mandarin, with seven Mandarin learning centers stood up in the US to train and support teachers, the Foundation for International Cooperation in Higher Education of Taiwan (FICHET) said. At the annual convention of the American Council on the Teaching of Foreign Languages held over the weekend in New Orleans, Louisiana, a Taiwan Pavilion was jointly run by 17 representative teams from the FICHET, the Overseas Community Affairs Council, the Steering Committee for the Test of Proficiency-Huayu, the
A home-style restaurant opened by a Taiwanese woman in Quezon City in Metro Manila has been featured in the first-ever Michelin Guide honoring exceptional restaurants in the Philippines. The restaurant, Fong Wei Wu (豐味屋), was one of 74 eateries to receive a “Michelin Selected” honor in the guide, while one restaurant received two Michelin stars, eight received one star and 25 were awarded a “Bib Gourmand.” The guide, which was limited to restaurants in Metro Manila and Cebu, was published on Oct. 30. In an interview, Feng Wei Wu’s owner and chef, Linda, said that as a restaurateur in her 60s, receiving an
Kaohsiung Mayor Chen Chi-mai (陳其邁) on Monday announced light shows and themed traffic lights to welcome fans of South Korean pop group Twice to the port city. The group is to play Kaohsiung on Saturday as part of its “This Is For” world tour. It would be the group’s first performance in Taiwan since its debut 10 years ago. The all-female group consists of five South Koreans, three Japanese and Tainan’s Chou Tzu-yu (周子瑜), the first Taiwan-born and raised member of a South Korean girl group. To promote the group’s arrival, the city has been holding a series of events, including a pop-up
RSS