Taipei Mayor Ko Wen-je (柯文哲) yesterday accused US author Ethan Gutmann of defamation in a criminal complaint, after Gutmann called him a “liar” on Tuesday.
Gutmann, an investigative writer focusing on human rights, in 2014 published The Slaughter: Mass Killings, Organ Harvesting, and China’s Secret Solution to Its Dissident Problem, in which he describes the systematic harvesting of organs from Falun Gong followers in China.
The book cited an interview with Ko.
Photo: Hsieh Chun-lin, Taipei Times
At a news conference in Taipei on Tuesday, Gutmann said that Ko acted as a “middleman” for Taiwanese who went to China for organ transplants and that by teaching Chinese doctors the extracorporeal membrane oxygenation (ECMO) technique crucial for transplants, he offered a “pervasive incentive.”
When asked whether Ko is a “liar,” Gutmann replied “yes.”
It was not immediately clear to what the question was referring.
After a legal attestation letter was sent on Wednesday, Ko did not receive an apology from Gutmann within 24 hours, Ko campaign spokesperson Lin Kun-feng (林昆鋒) said yesterday, adding that lawyer Lu Cheng-yi (陸正義) would file a complaint with the Taipei District Prosecutors’ Office and sue the author for harming Ko’s reputation.
“Evidence should have been presented to back up the ‘liar’ accusation against Mayor Ko,” Lu said, adding that the comments were intended to smear Ko’s character and that the representing law firm was collecting evidence for further legal action.
Ko, as a politician, has always tolerated criticism on issues of public concern and does not file lawsuits lightly, but being called a liar poses a serious risk to his reputation and integrity, so he would not remain passive this time, Lu said.
“Mr Gutmann is an experienced independent journalist and a Nobel Peace Prize nominee, so Mayor Ko does not understand why Mr Gutmann, who has put years of hard work into investigative journalism, would call him a liar without evidence at an international news conference,” he added.
In an exclusive interview with the Chinese-language Liberty Times (sister newspaper of the Taipei Times) published yesterday, Gutmann said he was shocked earlier this year when a person — whom he could not name — sent him a photograph of Ko attending an ECMO conference in China in 2008.
Several participants in the conference were allegedly involved in organ harvesting, Gutmann said, adding that it felt like “a slap in the face.”
“ECMO is a life-saving device in democratic countries with a transparent medical system, but it is a huge problem in China,” he said.
The technique saves lives in Taiwan, the US, Japan and elsewhere, but in China, it also kills people, as it enables organ transplants, some of which go to foreign medical tourists, Gutmann said.
“You [Ko] may go into China with the best of intentions, you may want to save lives,” Gutmann said. “But when you realize your own work is being perverted … that is the time you leave China, you get away from it and wash your hands.”
“The best and sincere way to wash your hands is to talk about what you’ve seen and why you’ve left,” he added.
Gutmann said his dream is that his book would be circulated in China as samizdat, a Russian expression for copying and passing along banned literature.
Asked to comment on the issue at the Legislative Yuan yesterday, Minister of Health and Welfare Chen Shih-chung (陳時中) said: “I believe in evidence and I think there has been some speculation on the issue, but they should be supported by solid evidence, because after all, the issue touches on ethical problems.”
Questioning a person’s ethics is a serious matter and “you should not make improper inferences from speculation, but let the evidence speak for itself,” Chen said.
Chen was also asked to elaborate on remarks he made on Wednesday, when he said that hospitals would be required to complete an organ transplant registry for patients who have received organs in other countries.
The main purpose was to keep the information transparent and to make it clear where the organs are from, Chen said.
The policy would not retroactively be applied to past cases and no criminal investigations would be launched, but hospitals must fulfil the requirement before the end of the year, he said.
All hospitals in Taiwan should be capable of fully registering such information and if they fail to do so, it might give rise to human rights concerns, he said.
The ministry plans to withhold National Health Insurance funding for drugs in cases with incomplete registration to force hospitals to comply, he added.
FOSSIL CLUES: The bushfires resulted from a positive Indian Ocean dipole event, when the region east of the ocean becomes drier, professor Shen Chuan-chou said The bushfires that swept through Australia last year were connected to a phenomenon known as the Indian Ocean dipole (IOD), which is expected to become more frequent due to climate change, a geologist studying coral fossils said yesterday. National Taiwan University Department of Geosciences professor Shen Chuan-chou (沈川洲) since 2001 has been working with Australian and US researchers to study climate systems in the Indian Ocean. Led by Australian National University Research School of Earth Sciences professor Nerilie Abram, the team published a paper on IOD in the journal Nature on March 9. The bushfires resulted from a positive IOD event, when the
Senior judges yesterday met to discuss the constitutionality of a law that makes adultery a criminal offense, before being ordered by Judicial Yuan President Hsu Tzong-li (許宗力) to set a date for a constitutional interpretation within the next month. The judges met to discuss Article 239 of the Criminal Code on offenses against marriage and family, after 18 judges had called for a constitutional interpretation of the issue. Taipei District Court Judge Lin Meng-huang (林孟皇) said that while he had previously tried adultery cases and never questioned the law, his feelings changed when trying a case last year involving baseball star Wang
Instead of hating the Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT), help change it, KMT Chairman Johnny Chiang (江啟臣) said, as he urged young people to join efforts to reform the party. As the nation marked Youth Day on Sunday, Chiang said in a Facebook post that he wanted to remind people that “the KMT used to be very young.” Now, when people think of the KMT, they equate it with older people, he wrote. “Even if [the KMT] is a 100-year-old party, it must maintain a young mentality, and understand what young people want and what they want the KMT to do,” Chiang wrote.
TOO TIRED: Investigators found that the pilot’s lack of alertness could be attributed to a lack of sleep the previous night, when he had slept with his child It was a copilot’s inappropriate operation of the aircraft and the pilot’s insufficient alertness that led to a hard landing of a China Airlines cargo flight on Dec. 13, 2018, the Taiwan Transportation Safety Board said yesterday. Flight CI6844, a Boeing 747-409 which departed from Hong Kong International Airport, landed on the pre-threshold area of runway L5 at Taiwan Taoyuan International Airport, about 21m before the head of the runway, an investigation report said. The hard landing damaged three runway lights, but none of the personnel on board sustained any injuries, the report said. When approaching the runway, the copilot failed to maintain