Tue, Mar 26, 2013 - Page 3 News List

Nationalization rules can be changed, minister says

TOO HARSH:The minister of the interior agreed with lawmakers that clauses requiring immigrants to ‘behave well’ and penalizing them for minor offenses should go

By Loa Lok-sin  /  Staff reporter

Despite the Executive Yuan’s preference to maintain current regulations regarding naturalization in the Nationality Act (國籍法), Minister of the Interior Lee Hong-yuan (李鴻源) yesterday said he supports amendments proposed by lawmakers across party lines to relax regulations to better protect immigrants’ rights.

At the moment, foreign residents seeking naturalization must provide documents proving that they have given up their native nationalities, they have no criminal records and “behave well.”

“How do you define ‘behave well?’” Democratic Progressive Party (DPP) Legislator Tuan Yi-kang (段宜康) asked Lee at the legislature’s Internal Administration Committee while reviewing proposed amendments to the Nationality Act.

“There’s a case I found on the official Web site of a household registration office in which a foreign resident’s application for naturalization was turned down because she was fined for an offense. In another case, a foreign resident was accused of gambling and the prosecutor decided to drop the charge after investigations, but her application for naturalization was rejected,” Tuan said. “Do you find such rejections reasonable?”

He added that he supports the requirement that applicants have no criminal record, but he thinks that the clauses requiring immigrants to “behave well” and rejecting their applications because of minor offenses should be deleted.

“If the judiciary finds someone not guilty of a crime, then the Ministry of the Interior should not act like a religious court and declare the person morally guilty,” Tuan said.

Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) Legislator Johnny Chiang (江啟臣) agreed with Tuan.

“The definition of ‘behaving well’ is rather vague and gives the government too much power to decide whether a person is ‘behaving well,’” Chiang said. “I think this requirement should be deleted.”

In addition, Chiang proposed that the rule that immigrants must renounce their original nationalities before becoming naturalized should be changed, too.

Chiang said that he received a petition from a stateless physician surnamed Gan (顏), originally from Malaysia, who had given up his Malaysian nationality, yet his application for Republic of China (ROC) citizenship was turned down and he is now without a nationality.

“Gan ran a clinic with a Taiwanese partner in a remote village in the mountains in Heping District [和平], Greater Taichung, serving communities where medical resources are scarce,” Chiang said. “Later, his Taiwanese partner left the clinic because life was too harsh there, but since our laws require foreign physicians to team up with Taiwanese physicians, Gan was fined NT$300,000 for running the clinic by himself and it was this violation that barred him from becoming a naturalized citizen.”

Chiang said that the case shows how unreasonable parts of the Nationality Act are, in requiring foreign immigrants to renounce their nationalities before obtaining ROC nationality, and considering a minor offense as serious as a crime.

DPP Legislator Hsiao Bi-khim (蕭美琴) also supported the proposal to void the requirement for immigrants to renounce their nationalities in advance.

“It’s a known fact that President Ma Ying-jeou’s [馬英九] daughters have dual nationality. If we think it’s okay for the president’s daughters to have dual citizenship, why do we try to stop immigrants from keeping their original nationality?” Hsiao said.

This story has been viewed 1749 times.
TOP top