Tue, Dec 13, 2011 - Page 3 News List

New study on 228 disputes mainstream history view

By Nadia Tsao  /  Staff Reporter in Washington

A new study on the 228 Incident that has yet to be made public provides alternative viewpoints on one of the defining moments in Taiwan’s history that are likely to attract harsh criticism from certain corners.

Chu Hung-yuan (朱浤源), a research fellow at Academia Sinica’s Institute of Modern History, said on Saturday that the latest research report on the 228 Incident discovered the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) had already penetrated all levels of the Republic of China government before 1945 and had been the main force behind attacks on the government during the 228 Incident.

Furthermore, George Kerr, the author of the book Formosa Betrayed and former US vice consul in Taiwan, and other officials in the US administration had interfered with politics in Taiwan, playing an important role in the 228 Incident, Chu said, adding that the Presbyterian Church in Taiwan had also participated in attacks during the incident.

Chu and his colleagues have received funding from the Taiwan Foundation for Democracy over the past eight years to research the 228 Incident. The final report, which runs to 700,000 Chinese characters, was handed to Legislative Speaker Wang Jin-pyng (王金平) — who doubles as foundation chairman — late last month and has not been made public or published so far.

Chu and his colleagues say that based on the name list published on the Internet by The Memorial Foundation of 228, the actual number of victims who died or went missing in the incident was only about 800, which differed radically from the 1,500 to 20,000 people estimated in previous study reports.

The report also says that at that time, Taiwan provincial chief executive Chen Yi (陳儀) had only 700 troops who were incapable of indiscriminately killing and firing guns at Taiwanese.

Chu described the 228 Incident as a small-scaled “peasants’ revolt.”

Within mainstream Taiwanese historiography, mostly influenced by the pan-green camp, Chu’s report is bound to evoke strong opposition.

Chu said he would also suggest the government amend school textbooks as per his report after he returns to Taiwan.

Chu briefed the media, researchers at the US Library of Congress and a few members of the overseas Chinese community at a Seven Seas Chinese Restaurant in Maryland, on Saturday. He said he had also been invited by overseas Chinese groups to discuss his report in New York, Washington and Florida.

He said the report made five main breakthroughs. The first is that the use of oral history by Hsu Hsueh-chi (許雪姬) and other researchers was likely to insert “unnecessary emotions.” The second is the key role of the underground CCP. The third is the intervention of US “hawkish” figures. The fourth is the exceptionally small number of people in the military stationed in Taiwan at the time and the fifth is the Presbyterian Church’s “wide participation in the attacks.”

Chu was critical of the book Formosa Betrayed, recognized as a classic by Taiwan independence supporters, saying Kerr had been gathering information for the US before World War II broke out.

Kerr actively advocated for Taiwan to come under a UN mandate after the war, Chu said, adding that Kerr also encouraged people to rebel against the government and abetted students attacking the Taiwan Railway Administration during the 228 Incident.

Chu said Kerr was the initiator of “the uncertain status of Taiwan” and also had a role in affecting key words in the Treaty of Peace with Japan (commonly known as the Treaty of San Francisco) that changed from Japan’s surrender of Taiwan to the Republic of China (ROC) government to a surrender to the Allies, leading to the continued challenge to the legal status of the ROC in Taiwan.

Comments will be moderated. Keep comments relevant to the article. Remarks containing abusive and obscene language, personal attacks of any kind or promotion will be removed and the user banned. Final decision will be at the discretion of the Taipei Times.

TOP top