Sun, Dec 06, 2009 page2

• 2009 ELECTIONS: ANALYSIS: DPP performance must not be overestimated: experts

  TSAI PREVAILS Yilan, where both parties’ leaders spent a lot of time and energy stomping for their candidates, was a big win for the green camp and its chairperson

  • By Jenny W. hsu / STAFF REPORTER
  • • 
    • 
    • 

  The leaders of the Democratic Progressive Party (DPP) had a good night’s sleep last night after meeting expectations that the party would prevail in four counties up for grabs in local elections. Political observers, however, said that yesterday’s outcome was insufficient to pave the way for a pan-green comeback in the 2012 presidential election.

  The combined results of yesterday’s elections and next year’s special municipality races will provide a more accurate forecast on the DPP’s chances of re-­entering the Presidential Office, the analysts said.

  After the party comfortably secured the three counties of Yunlin, Pingtung and Chiayi, where it held power, Lin Tsung-hsien (林聰賢) did the party extremely proud by snatching Yilan County.

  Yilan, a DPP stronghold for more than two decades, suffered a surprise loss to the Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) in 2005. Lin beat incumbent KMT Commissioner Lu Guo-hua (呂國華) by more than 20,000 votes yesterday, with a 8.52 percent margin.

  The eastern county was considered the most important battleground, with both party leaders — the DPP’s Tsai Ing-wen (蔡英文) and President Ma Ying-jeou (馬英九) of the KMT — devoting a lot of time and energy in the past two weeks stumping for their candidates. Both parties said that real victory in the elections hinged on how they fared in Yilan.

  The DPP victory in Yilan highlighted the public’s negative perception of outgoing KMT Commissioner Lu Kuo-hua (呂國華) and the KMT, but it was not necessarily a sign of voters’ fondness for Lin, said Chen Chao-chien (陳朝建), an assistant professor of public affairs at Ming Chuan University.

  The result shows that Ma is no longer a “ballot guarantor” and confirms that his popularity is fading fast as public distrust in him and his party continues to rise, Chen said.

  “People still have fresh memories of the government’s shoddy response to Typhoon Morakot and subsequent rainstorms in Yilan. People are seriously questioning whether the KMT is capable of delivering on its promises of a better life,” he said. “It is clear that Ma has failed in this midterm election, while Tsai passed with a satisfactory grade.”

  One caveat for the DPP, however, is that its taking back Yilan does not necessarily mean that voters are eager for a return to pan-green governance, he said.

  “Voting against the KMT was voters’ way of preventing the KMT bad apple from becoming more rotten. It does not mean that they like the DPP. In spite of their dislike for the DPP, however, voters still don’t want to see the pan-blue camp have absolute power,” he said.

  Lin Chi-wen (林繼文), a professor of political science at National Chengchi University, was reluctant to use yesterday’s outcome as a gauge for the 2012 presidential election because the local elections involved less than half of the country’s population.

  The real clincher will be next year’s special municipality elections, which will involve 13 million voters, he said.

  “[Yesterday’s] elections should not be interpreted as the country’s collective view on the Ma administration because they were based on local issues, not national policies,” he said.

  He nevertheless agreed that the results in Yilan had elevated Tsai’s status within the DPP.

  Michael You (游盈隆), a professor at Soochow University and former vice chairman of the Strait Exchange Foundation, said the county chief election was comparable to the gubernatorial race in the US — a litmus test for the administration’s performance in the run-up to the battle for the presidency.

  Winning four of the 17 counties and cities yesterday was a “small win,” though not significant enough to secure Tsai’s place in the 2012 election or the DPP’s chance to regain power, he said.

  “The DPP should not be overjoyed. Taking four of the 17 seat is not a major breakthrough. It does, however, mean that Tsai’s status in the party will not be shaken,” he said.

  The results will boost morale within the DPP, but the party will have to work hard in preparation for next year’s races and hold on to that momentum all the way to 2012, Yu said.

  You attributed some DPP losses to vote-buying by the KMT and lamented the fact that Taiwan had yet to rid itself of this tactic.

  Observers were unanimous in saying that the DPP will have to work tirelessly for next year’s races and present pragmatic social welfare policies, merely opposing the policies of the pan-blue or government would not be sufficient to win the public’s confidence ahead of 2012.
• Most Popular

  • 1

    Sinner, Sabalenka reach Cincinnati quarter-finals

  • 2

    Lai urges people to vote ‘no’ in nuclear energy referendum

  • 3

    Ma pans Lai’s kowtowing to Japan

  • 4

    Taiwan bars officials from China military parade marking end of war with Japan

  • 5

    South Korea prosecutors raid party HQ