Mon, Aug 22, 2005 page3

• Hair flies in debate over ban on schools' regulations

  LET IT GROW The Ministry of Education recently banned schools' restrictions on hairstyles and dress codes, giving students the basic right to choose how they want to look

  • By MO YAN-CHIH / STAFF REPORTER
  • • 
    • 
    • 

  The Ministry of Education's (MOE) decision this month to first ban public-school restrictions on permissible hairstyles and later lift those on shoes and socks for secondary-school students, sparked debate on whether students should be given total freedom over their appearance.

  While many schools hesitated to carry out the new policy, the lifting of the hair and dress regulations has officially put an end to an outdated era and granted students the right to determine their own hairstyles and appearance.

  Looking back at the history of the country's hair and dress regulations, the ban on students' hairstyles and dress was first introduced in 1969 by the ministry, and is now considered to be a relic of authoritarianism. According to hair-regulation criteria between 1969 and 1978, as provided by the MOE, secondary-school boys were required to sport crew cuts, there had to be no hair on their temples and strange hairstyles were not allowed. Girls' hair, on the other hand, had to be ear-length and neither dyed nor permed.

  

  A few Kuanghwa Elementary School students, accompanied by their teacher, pose for a photograph several decades ago. This type of ``watermelon-shaped hairstyle'' was mandated by almost all schools in Taiwan at the time -- hair was not permitted to grow to a length below the ears.

  TAIPEI TIMES FILE PHOTO BY CHEN CHING-MIN

  The ministry in 1984 issued an official dress code for secondary-school students. While there was no detailed requirements, the ministry requested that students' clothes be "neat," "simple" and "graceful."

  Six months before the then-ruling Chinese Nationalist Party lifted martial law in 1987, the MOE banned hair regulations at secondary schools. The announcement stated that secondary-school students' hairstyles should be "simple, neat and easy to freshen up." But "schools can draw up their own regulations based on the above principles and opinions from teachers, students and parent representatives."

  Schools continued to enforce strict rules, and rushing to get haircuts or preparing white shoes and socks the night before their schools' appearance-checkup day has remained a school memory for most Taiwanese people.

  "Our director of student affairs once cut a student's hair during a hair checkup in front of everybody, because he used styling gel on his hair. My teacher even asked a barber to come to school and give each of us a haircut to make sure our hairstyles conformed to school rules," said Jimmy Chuang (莊明勳), a Taipei Times reporter who was in junior-high school when the MOE banned hair regulations in 1987.

  Jimmy said that while the school informed them about the MOE's policy, hair regulations continued to be enforced even though students were allowed to sport their hair a little longer. Every month at schools' morning rally, the director of student affairs or instructors would do a routine hair and dress checkup. Students who failed the checkup would be punished with points deducted from their grades.

  "Having to get a haircut at least once a month was a hassle. But I think most of my male classmates felt OK with the crew-cut hairstyle," Chuang said.

  "Girls hated the hair regulations more because their prescribed hairstyle gave them `watermelon heads,' and it was not pretty," he said. Years after the ministry's first official ban on hair regulations, secondary-school boys no longer need to sport the crew-cut hairstyle and girls can wear their hair to at least shoulder-length.

  But most schools never gave up the authority to exercise proper discipline regarding students' appearance. It seems that most of the schools decided to stick to their guns when education officials this time around chose to stand firmly on the side of students' hairstyle rights when the legitimacy of the regulations was questioned by students in a protest last month.

  Many secondary-school principals were surprised at Education Minister Tu Cheng-sheng's (杜正勝) positive response to a students' petition. Tu not only agreed to accept the students' petition in person, but promised them hair regulations would be banned. The MOE later issued a bulletin to officially announce the new policy, which will start with the new semester next month.

  Some schools' principals called the changes a "travesty of education in the guise of democracy." A number of them vowed to maintain existing regulations.

  Tan Guang-ding (譚光鼎), principal of the Affiliated Senior High School of National Taiwan Normal University, said that the school respected students' rights to choose their own hairstyles, as long as they did not get their hair dyed or permed.

  "But I do not agree that hair regulations are a violation of students' human rights. Students come to school to receive an education and proper discipline. Schools' authority over students' hairstyles should not be denied," Tan said.

  Facing a cool response from school principals, Vice Minister of Education Fan Sun-lu (范巽綠) cited statistics released by the MOE after contacting local education heads, and said that 19 of 25 cities and counties were in favor of the abolition of the regulations. She admitted, however, that school principals were key to the success of the ministry's policy change.

  Fan called on schools to give students the right to choose their own hairstyles, given that this is a democratic society.

  "This was consistent with the idea that schools aim at teaching students to be responsible members of society by making decisions for themselves and thinking on their own," she said.

  As many school principals hesitated to give up their authority over students' hair, however, hairstyle rights advocates may need to continue their fight until students can express themselves through various hairstyles without any restraints.
• Most Popular

  • 1

    Fertility rate falls to lowest globally

  • 2

    Taiwan conflict ‘catastrophic’ for China: US report

  • 3

    ’Up to Xi’ on Taiwan, but would be ’very unhappy’ with a change in ’status quo’: Trump

  • 4

    China widens attack on Japan’s ‘nuclear threat’

  • 5

    Military have plan to protect Lai: Hsu