It was the World Cup goal seen around the world, but missed by the eyes that mattered most: England midfielder Frank Lampard’s shot that dropped cleanly past the German goal line, but was not given by the referee.
The avalanche of complaints about that missed call and others during the largest soccer tournament in the world raised the philosophical question of whether instant-replay technology improves games or turns them into soulless events run by a bank of blinking lights.
Scientists who study the human brain say it is surprising that bad calls do not happen more often.
PHOTO: REUTERS
“Despite all of the apparent surprise that the referees would be blowing calls, especially at crucial points, from a psychological standpoint, this is what we would expect,” said David Meyer, director of the University of Michigan’s Brain, Cognition and Action Laboratory.
“It’s like every once in a while you draw the ace of spades,” the psychology professor said. “It’s going to happen.”
Questions about the capacity of the human brain to judge action on the sports field are not limited to conversations at the local bar, but are examined by neurobiologists and psychologists using such measures as “relay latency,” “perceptual fluency” and “speed-accuracy trade-off curve.”
While it is easy for fans to throw up their hands in disgust at a missed call and curse the referee, they need to realize that officials are weighing up actions that happen in fractions of a second, experts say.
“Human beings are never going to be perfect at making calls,” said Gary Marcus, a professor of psychology at New York University. “Our memories just aren’t cut out to allow us to be perfect referees.”
“Our eyes work a lot like cameras, but our memories don’t work anything like an SD [secure digital] card,” Marcus said, referring to memory cards used in digital cameras. “We can’t literally play back what we just saw.”
Making it tougher was the fleeting nature of moves in sport, said Emilio Salinas, an assistant professor of neurobiology at Wake Forest University Baptist Medical Center, who helped to write a paper entitled “Perceptual decision making in less than 30 milliseconds.”
Salinas and fellow authors found that as little as 30 milliseconds of extra viewing time was the difference between a correct and an incorrect judgment about whether a flashed light had turned red or green.
“Thirty milliseconds is sort of an upper bound on how fast you can do that kind of discrimination,” he said.
Then there is the fact that referees simply cannot see everything.
University of Michigan’s Meyer said the maximum number of players any one person could carefully track was four, meaning something would be missed even with multiple referees watching.
When referees do miss a crucial piece of evidence, their brain will fill in the gaps using past experiences to help them make the call.
“Filling in is really a deeply embedded part of human consciousness,” Marcus said.
Just as a driver’s brain would tell him a car was in his blind spot even though he could not see it, referees’ brains would fill in what was missing, he said.
Obstructed views or bad angles are supplemented by the official’s past experiences, something that may have happened when a botched call in early June cost Detroit Tigers pitcher Armando Galarraga a perfect game in Major League Baseball (MLB).
Scientists and even referees understand that the accuracy of calls increases with experience. However, additional practice does not always make perfect.
“You can train your eyes all day long to see as quick as possible, but we’re talking about 300 milliseconds to see a 95-mile-an-hour [153kph] fastball coming from a professional pitcher’s rubber to home plate,” said Kevin Gee, director of the Sports Vision Performance Center at the University of Houston College of Optometry.
Given the challenges for the human brain, even some staunch critics of technology to aid referees have changed their minds.
“I don’t know if we can get any better at doing what we do,” said retired MLB umpire Don Denkinger, who is remembered for an incorrect call in the 1985 World Series. “There’s no super umpire sitting out there.”
“You have plays that are going to pop up that are called wrong, and if you don’t want to use instant replay, you just have to accept them,” said Denkinger, who no longer opposes the use of instant replays.
After Lampard’s no-goal in June, FIFA president Sepp Blatter apologized for refereeing mistakes at the World Cup and said soccer’s governing body would reopen the debate on goal-line technology.
Even the scientists, however, recognize the appeal of the drama offered by human error.
“In real life, most of the time we do not have the possibility of engaging in instant replay in order to correct mistakes,” Meyer said. “By keeping the technology out of play, we make the sport more traditionally lifelike and in some ways that can enhance the drama.”
OUT AGAINST INDONESIA: Taiwan reached the semi-finals at the tournament for the first time by defeating Denmark, with Chou Tien-chen beating Viktor Axelsen Taiwan yesterday crashed out of the Thomas Cup team competition in Chengdu, China, but achieved their best result at the top-tier badminton event by reaching the semi-finals. Indonesia were too good in the semis, winning 3-0 to advance to today’s final against China, who eliminated Malaysia 3-1. In the opening singles of the men’s team clash at the Hi-Tech Zone Sports Center Gymnasium 2, Anthony Ginting defeated Taiwan’s Chou Tien-chen 21-18, 21-19 in 51 minutes, which put a huge hole in Taiwan’s aspirations to perhaps even make the final. In the men’s doubles, Fajar Alfian and Muhammad Ardianto downed Lee Yang and Wang
NO DOUBT: Spurs star Wembanyama was unanimously selected as NBA Rookie of the Year, winning all 99 votes to become the first Frenchman to capture the honor The Minnesota Timberwolves on Monday night produced a dominant defensive display to seize a commanding 2-0 lead in their best-of-seven playoff series against the Denver Nuggets with a 106-80 road victory. The third-seeded Timberwolves harassed Denver relentlessly to claim a second straight win over the NBA champions as the series heads back to Minneapolis for Game 3 on Friday. Karl-Anthony Towns and Anthony Edwards scored 27 points apiece, but the star of the show was Minnesota’s suffocating defensive effort, which knocked Denver out of their stride almost from the tip-off. The Timberwolves finished with 11 steals and 12 blocks, in sharp contrast to
Top-ranked Iga Swiatek on Saturday came through “the most intense and crazy final” she has ever contested to avenge her loss to Aryna Sabalenka in last year’s Madrid Open final with a grueling three hour, 11 minute victory in the Spanish capital. Coming back from 1-3 down in the decider and saving three match points in total, Swiatek claimed a 7-5, 4-6, 7-6 (9/7) victory to secure the Madrid Open trophy for the first time. “Well, who is going to say now that women’s tennis is boring, right?” Swiatek said. Swiatek, who picked up the 20th title of her career, and ninth at
One of Malaysia’s top soccer clubs has pulled out of today’s season-opening Charity Shield after a spate of assaults, including an acid attack, on players in the country. It leaves the kickoff of Malaysia’s season this weekend under a cloud following the unprecedented acts of violence against players, which have left the country shocked and angry. Authorities said they have imposed tighter security, but Selangor said that they would not play in the showpiece curtain-raiser against Malaysian Super League champions Johor Darul Ta’zim (JDT) citing “a series of criminal incidents and recent threats.” Selangor and Malaysia winger Faisal Halim is in intensive care