As many residents of Taipei are still putting their lives back together after the worst flooding the city has seen in many years, officials are already trying to pass the buck on to who, if anyone, should be responsible.
Last Tuesday and Wednesday, Typhoon Xangsane (
Facing public complaints and severe criticism from city councilors, the Taipei City Government has said that the flooding was solely caused by the torrential rains. Academics and city councilors, however, pointed fingers at the city government for having failed to draw up a comprehensive river dredging program. They also say that urban sprawl on hillsides and in low-lying areas has been allowed to grow out of control.
PHOTO: CHANG CHIA-MING, TAIPEI TIMES
It's the rain
On Nov. 1, Taipei Deputy Mayor Ou Chin-der (
The last time Taipei City had similar amounts of rainfall was in October 1977.
Director of the city's Bureau of Public Works (
"The rainfall was not only heavy but also highly concentrated in certain areas," he said. "Take the Nankang district, for example. The accumulated rainfall amounted to 473.5mm in the Chiuchuang area (舊庄). In the Wenshan district, 523mm of rain fell in Pochia borough (博嘉里)."
According to figures on the Web site of the Central Weather Bureau, the monthly mean precipitation for Taipei in November is 79.8mm.
A contributing factor of the flooding, according to Lee, is the over-development of upstream areas.
"The ability of the soil to retain water has been so weakened that when heavy rain falls, the soil which is already saturated with water cannot handle any more. The result is that the water remains on the surface and contributes to serious flooding."
In addition to ground saturation is the fact that a project to contain floodwaters along the rivers remains incomplete, increasing the risk of flooding, Lee said.
"Since the embankments constructed along the Keelung River and Chingmei Creek are not yet fully complete, the districts of Neihu, Nankang, and Wenshan are at risk," he said.
According to Lee, the levee built along the right side of the Keelung River off Nanhu Bridge (
Although the city plans to build a levee along Chingmei Creek off Wanshou Bridge (
Despite the claim made by the city government, city councilors expressed different views regarding the cause of the flooding.
Voices from the city council
Leading a group of reporters on an inspection tour of the MacArthur First Bridge (
The MacArthur First Bridge, which connects Neihu and Sungshan districts over the Keeling River and separates Neihu in the north and Nankang in the south, became operational recently.
"At the height of the typhoon, the water level upstream was 1m higher than downstream. If the water flow wasn't blocked by the bridge and ultimately caused the flooding, I don't know what else it was," he said.
Looking down from the temporary work station beneath the bridge, Chen pointed to the garbage scattered around the construction site and along the riverbank. Among the entangled branches and styrofoam products lay a 22.5-tonne oil tank and a barge.
"The city keeps saying that the flooding was caused by the heavy rainfall. If what it says is true, how come Shetzu Islet (
Shetzu Islet, a 300-hectare sandbar located at the junction of the Tamshui River and its tributary, the Keelung River, is normally flooded every year when typhoons strike.
Another city councilor of the same districts, Lee Yen-hsiu (
"First of all, the timing of the water released from the Feitsui Dam (
Different municipal agencies are also trying to shirk responsibility for dredging the rivers, she said.
Take Takeng Creek (大坑溪) in the Nankang district for example, she said. While the upstream area belongs to the city's Department of Public Housing (國宅處), the midstream section is under the jurisdiction of the Office of Market Supervision (市管處) under the city's Bureau of Reconstruction (建設局), while the downstream area is supervised by yet another department.
"Believe me, it's not easy to have them dredge the creek," she said.
New Party City Councilor Lee Ching-yuan (李慶元) of the Wenshan and Ta-an districts agreed.
"The city needs to review the overall anti-flooding program and to come up with a comprehensive and long-term plan instead of trivial short-term programs," he said.
Looking at Chingmei Creek -- which runs through the Wenshan district from east to west -- it's easy to see that some areas either don't have any levees or have levees that are poorly designed or constructed, and some areas either have no pumping stations or ones that are insufficient, he said.
Looking for a method
It is conceivable that the city's dredging program needs further review and improvement, but is building more levees the best and only way for flood prevention, or are there alternatives?
"It's not a good idea to keep raising the height of levees," said Hsia Chu-joe (
It's a better idea to strictly control urban development, especially along the river basin and low-lying areas, he said.
"Some low-lying areas are simply not habitable, but what can you do if the government keeps issuing construction licenses, allowing more houses to be built and more people to take land away from the river?" he said.
"It may not be too late for the government to review what direction the city should take in future urban development," he said.
Hsia added that he disapproved of a recent dredging proposal made by the central government.
On Friday, Premier Chang Chun-hsiung (
The project would build a floodway starting in Juifang (
"Many scientific assessments -- such as soil analysis and environmental impact studies -- need to be made before the project begins," Hsia said. "If the assessment results show that the project is feasible, it doesn't necessarily mean, however, that it's all right to keep abusing hillsides and low-lying areas."
National Taiwan University civil engineering professor Kuo Jan-tai (
"I think it's a great idea," he said. "It's cheaper than the traditional methods of dredging."
According to Kuo, it may cost roughly NT$30 billion to build the floodway and the embankment and pumping stations, while it may cost over NT$100 billion to raise the height of existing levees, build more pumping stations, and relocate residents living in low-lying areas.
"To solve the flooding problem in Taipei once and for all, the `structural' and `non-structural' methods should be applied simultaneously," he said.
The so-called "structural" method refers to the construction of embankments, reservoirs and pumping stations. The "non-structural" method refers to urban planning and development in conjunction with an alarm system to alert residents of imminent flooding.
NO-LIMITS PARTNERSHIP: ‘The bottom line’ is that if the US were to have a conflict with China or Russia it would likely open up a second front with the other, a US senator said Beijing and Moscow could cooperate in a conflict over Taiwan, the top US intelligence chief told the US Senate this week. “We see China and Russia, for the first time, exercising together in relation to Taiwan and recognizing that this is a place where China definitely wants Russia to be working with them, and we see no reason why they wouldn’t,” US Director of National Intelligence Avril Haines told a US Senate Committee on Armed Services hearing on Thursday. US Senator Mike Rounds asked Haines about such a potential scenario. He also asked US Defense Intelligence Agency Director Lieutenant General Jeffrey Kruse
NOVEL METHODS: The PLA has adopted new approaches and recently conducted three combat readiness drills at night which included aircraft and ships, an official said Taiwan is monitoring China’s People’s Liberation Army (PLA) exercises for changes in their size or pattern as the nation prepares for president-elect William Lai’s (賴清德) inauguration on May 20, National Security Bureau (NSB) Director-General Tsai Ming-yen (蔡明彥) said yesterday. Tsai made the comment at a meeting of the Legislative Yuan’s Foreign Affairs and National Defense Committee, in response to Democratic Progressive Party (DPP) Legislator Wang Ting-yu’s (王定宇) questions. China continues to employ a carrot-and-stick approach, in which it applies pressure with “gray zone” tactics, while attempting to entice Taiwanese with perks, Tsai said. These actions aim to help Beijing look like it has
China’s intrusive and territorial claims in the Indo-Pacific region are “illegal, coercive, aggressive and deceptive,” new US Indo-Pacific Commander Admiral Samuel Paparo said on Friday, adding that he would continue working with allies and partners to keep the area free and open. Paparo made the remarks at a change-of-command ceremony at Joint Base Pearl Harbor-Hickam in Hawaii, where he took over the command from Admiral John Aquilino. “Our world faces a complex problem set in the troubling actions of the People’s Republic of China [PRC] and its rapid buildup of forces. We must be ready to answer the PRC’s increasingly intrusive and
UNWAVERING: Paraguay remains steadfast in its support of Taiwan, but is facing growing pressure at home and abroad to switch recognition to Beijing, Pena said Paraguayan President Santiago Pena has pledged to continue enhancing cooperation with Taiwan, as he and Japanese Prime Minister Fumio Kishida expressed opposition to any unilateral change to the “status quo” in the Taiwan Strait using force, Japanese media reported on Saturday. Kishida yesterday completed a trip to France, Brazil and Paraguay, his first visit to South America since taking office in 2021. After the Japanese leader and Pena spoke for more than an hour on Friday, exchanging views on the situation in East Asia in the face of China’s increasing military pressure on Taiwan, they affirmed that “unilateral attempts to change the