Wed, Feb 13, 2008 - Page 8 News List

EDITORIAL: Red herring releases will not do

With just six months left before the Olympics, the outcry from activists and observers over China's abandoned human rights promises would at last seem to be making an impression on Beijing.

Over the past week, China has released two high-profile prisoners. Yu Huafeng (喻華峰) headed Guangzhou's Nanfang Dushi Bao, a publication that repeatedly rubbed corrupt officials the wrong way. Ching Cheong (程翔), a Hong Kong journalist and correspondent for Singapore's Straits Times, was arrested while collecting sensitive material about disgraced premier Zhao Ziyang (趙紫陽).

It is no coincidence that authorities would show a sudden change of heart in these two cases, reducing Yu and Ching's sentences by eight and two years respectively. China's failure to loosen the reins on the press, despite pledges to the International Olympic Committee in 2001, has received considerable attention from international media and drawn sharp criticism from governments and rights groups. The release of the two media workers at the Lunar New Year was a clear signal that the bad publicity is getting under Beijing's skin at a time when authorities are scrambling to perfect their veneer.

This is good news not only for Yu and Ching, but also for rights campaigners, as it confirms yet again that China is sensitive to how it is perceived abroad. While some countries with notorious human rights records -- such as Uzbekistan -- are unresponsive to pressure from foreign governments and organizations, Beijing is aching for worldwide admiration and recognition as a modern country and leader in the international community.

All the more reason to ratchet up the pressure.

Beijing generally responds to criticism by releasing a few well-known prisoners or announcing sweeping reforms that often do not materialize. With authorities more concerned than ever about meeting international expectations, voices abroad must make it clear that a few reduced sentences are minor improvements in the context of a nationwide crackdown on freedom of speech and increasing controls on the flow of information on the Internet. The international community must show Beijing it will not be distracted by these releases and they do not make up for broader injustices.

Last year, Reporters without Borders recorded 180 cases of foreign media workers being threatened or detained while covering sensitive subjects. In addition, over the past few months, authorities have repeatedly denied foreign journalists access to leading dissidents and their family members for interviews, despite claims that foreign journalists are now free to carry out work and research across the country without government interference. And the fact remains that the issues such dissidents represent are so strongly censored in China that most local reporters wouldn't dream of broaching them. For journalists interested in pushing the envelope, the more than 10-year prison terms given to Yu and his paper's managing editor, as well as the severity of the sentences handed down to dozens of other media workers, serve as a clear warning.

Beijing is perhaps just realizing that its broken pledges do not go unnoticed, but it has a long way to go before it fulfills them. The more than 80 Chinese cyber-dissidents and journalists in jail for their work eclipse the occasional high-profile release. Until Beijing respects the rights granted in its Constitution -- including freedom of speech and freedom of the press -- such improvements will remain token gestures in the face of its glaring insincerity.

This story has been viewed 3301 times.
TOP top