It was the most expensive real estate deal in US history. Now it’s poised to become one of the biggest flops.
At the height of the real estate bubble in 2006, an investment group led by New York City real estate firm Tishman Speyer Properties and BlackRock Realty Advisors paid US$5.4 billion for a pair of gigantic Manhattan apartment complexes known as Stuyvesant Town and Peter Cooper Village.
The price seemed outrageous to many, but the company believed it had a winning strategy: It would aggressively convert thousands of rent-regulated apartments occupied by middle-class families into luxury units that would fetch top dollar.
PHOTO: AFP
Three years later, to the glee of many New York renters, the tactic has been a bust.
Tenants fought back, conversions happened much slower than expected and a state court ruled on Thursday that about US$200 million in the company’s new rent increases were improper.
Real estate analysts say the ownership group is now just two to three months away from a likely default on the US$3 billion mortgage it used, along with a US$1.4 billion secondary loan, to buy the property.
Foreclosure looms as a strong possibility.
Even before the state Court of Appeals ruling on a lawsuit filed by the apartment complex tenants, ratings firms had estimated that the value of the 32 hectare property, home to 25,000 people, had fallen to as little as US$2 billion — far less than the outstanding loan balance.
Given the math involved, “I wouldn’t be surprised if they just want to walk on it,” said Steve Kiritz, a senior vice president at the credit ratings agency Realpoint LLC.
“The whole master plan with this project had been for Tishman to come in and ramp up the number of units that were paying market rent,” he said.
New York state’s rent regulation laws place restrictions on how much landlords can charge renters for many apartments.
Regular folks — especially those who have had home financing problems of their own — might laugh at the folly until they realize that some of their own money might be tied up in the deal.
Some of the biggest equity investors in the deal are public pension funds that manage retirement system benefits for millions of government employees.
Florida’s State Board of Administration had put US$250 million into the project. It has already written off the entire investment as a loss.
California’s two largest government pension funds, the California Public Employees’ Retirement System and the California State Teachers Retirement System (CALSTRS), invested a combined US$600 million.
CALSTRS has also already written off its US$100 million stake.
Tishman, by comparison, stands to lose much less. Its share was US$112 million, less than 2 percent of the purchase price.
A spokesman for the company declined to comment on Friday on the project’s future.
Tishman Speyer’s co-chief executive, Rob Speyer, told the New York Times in a recent interview that win or lose on the court case, “the asset is going to require a restructuring.”
“Once the court case is resolved,” he said, “we’ll speak to our debt holders as well as our fellow equity investors.”
Teams of lawyers will likely spend the next few months fighting over who gets control of the complex and which lenders are entitled to get some money back, said Dan Fasulo, a managing director of Real Capital Analytics.
How much they recover, and who is wiped out, may come down to how much appraisers decide the buildings are really worth, based on more realistic rent projections.
“I had a number, put together last week, that I thought was fair. I don’t think that number is fair anymore,” Fasulo said. “No one could give you an honest appraisal right now.”
Stuyvesant Town isn’t the only such project to run into trouble after plans to increase rents went poorly.
An investment group that purchased Riverton Houses, a big development in Harlem built around the same time as Stuyvesant Town, ran into financial problems after its bid to convert hundreds of rent-regulated units to market rates went slower than expected.
One analyst last month estimated the value of the complex at US$108 million, about half the value of the US$225 million mortgage on the property, which is currently in default.
Any debt restructuring process at Stuyvesant Town is likely to be complicated.
The mortgages that financed the deal were chopped up, repacked and sold as Commercial Mortgage Backed Securities to a variety of investors.
Fasulo said the complexity of the arrangement and the size of the property itself mean that a traditional liquidation still might not happen.
A sale, he said, “would be very disadvantageous at this time,” given the state of the real estate market.
“There would be tremendous demand,” he said, but at such a depressed price that the lenders might be better off holding on to the troubled property.
SECURITY: As China is ‘reshaping’ Hong Kong’s population, Taiwan must raise the eligibility threshold for applications from Hong Kongers, Chiu Chui-cheng said When Hong Kong and Macau citizens apply for residency in Taiwan, it would be under a new category that includes a “national security observation period,” Mainland Affairs Council (MAC) Minister Chiu Chui-cheng (邱垂正) said yesterday. President William Lai (賴清德) on March 13 announced 17 strategies to counter China’s aggression toward Taiwan, including incorporating national security considerations into the review process for residency applications from Hong Kong and Macau citizens. The situation in Hong Kong is constantly changing, Chiu said to media yesterday on the sidelines of the Taipei Technology Run hosted by the Taipei Neihu Technology Park Development Association. With
CARROT AND STICK: While unrelenting in its military threats, China attracted nearly 40,000 Taiwanese to over 400 business events last year Nearly 40,000 Taiwanese last year joined industry events in China, such as conferences and trade fairs, supported by the Chinese government, a study showed yesterday, as Beijing ramps up a charm offensive toward Taipei alongside military pressure. China has long taken a carrot-and-stick approach to Taiwan, threatening it with the prospect of military action while reaching out to those it believes are amenable to Beijing’s point of view. Taiwanese security officials are wary of what they see as Beijing’s influence campaigns to sway public opinion after Taipei and Beijing gradually resumed travel links halted by the COVID-19 pandemic, but the scale of
A US Marine Corps regiment equipped with Naval Strike Missiles (NSM) is set to participate in the upcoming Balikatan 25 exercise in the Luzon Strait, marking the system’s first-ever deployment in the Philippines. US and Philippine officials have separately confirmed that the Navy Marine Expeditionary Ship Interdiction System (NMESIS) — the mobile launch platform for the Naval Strike Missile — would take part in the joint exercise. The missiles are being deployed to “a strategic first island chain chokepoint” in the waters between Taiwan proper and the Philippines, US-based Naval News reported. “The Luzon Strait and Bashi Channel represent a critical access
Pope Francis is be laid to rest on Saturday after lying in state for three days in St Peter’s Basilica, where the faithful are expected to flock to pay their respects to history’s first Latin American pontiff. The cardinals met yesterday in the Vatican’s synod hall to chart the next steps before a conclave begins to choose Francis’ successor, as condolences poured in from around the world. According to current norms, the conclave must begin between May 5 and 10. The cardinals set the funeral for Saturday at 10am in St Peter’s Square, to be celebrated by the dean of the College
RSS