A US judge invalidated certain patents for machines that scan products for information including pricing codes. The patents have already cost companies that operate in the US more than US$1 billion in licensing fees.
US District Judge Philip Pro in Las Vegas said that the late Jerome Lemelson took too long to obtain his patents, sometimes as much as 39 years. The court's action is a victory for Cognex Corp, Symbol Technologies Inc and other scanner makers that sought to invalidate the Lemelson patents because their clients were being sued.
The for-profit Lemelson Medical, Education & Research Foundation has successfully sued more than 800 businesses and has pending lawsuits against hundreds of other companies, including Intel Corp and Wal-Mart Stores Inc, that use machines made by Symbol, Cognex and others to scan products for pricing codes, defects or other information.
The delay in obtaining the patents was "unreasonable and unjustifiable," Pro said on Friday. "At a minimum, Lemelson's delay in securing the asserted claims amounts to culpable neglect as he ignored the duty to claim his invention promptly."
Symbol lawyer Jesse Jenner of Fish & Neave argued that Lemelson wrote descriptions for his inventions in the 1950s and 1960s and later amended them to cover emerging technology.
Lemelson's lawyer, Gerald Hosier, maintained that the inventor followed the rules that were in place before the US Patent and Trademark Office laws were changed.
Under old law, patents were valid for 17 years after they were issued, no matter how long the application process took. In part because of the controversy over the Lemelson patents, the law was changed in 1995 so patents are valid for 20 years from the date of application. Applications filed before 1995 are given the benefit of whichever term is longer.
The 14 patents involved in the dispute were issued to Lemelson between 1978 and 1994, from applications dating back to the mid-1950s. Lemelson died in 1997.
Of the 5 million US patents issued from 1914 to 2001, 13 of Lemelson's patents lead in length of time it took for an application to get through the system. At least one of the patents will expire in 2011, 55 years after the original application, Pro said.
"The evidence [cited] at trial is abundant that, during that period, machine vision and bar-code technology was developed by many who had never heard of the Lemelson patents," Pro wrote.
Pro said that, even if the patents were valid, Cognex and Symbol don't use the technology covered by the patents.
UPDATED (3:40pm): A suspected gas explosion at a shopping mall in Taichung this morning has killed four people and injured 20 others, as emergency responders continue to investigate. The explosion occurred on the 12th floor of the Shin Kong Mitsukoshi in Situn District (西屯) at 11:33am. One person was declared dead at the scene, while three people were declared deceased later after receiving emergency treatment. Another 20 people sustained major or minor injuries. The Taichung Fire Bureau said it received a report of the explosion at 11:33am and sent rescuers to respond. The cause of the explosion is still under investigation, it said. The National Fire
ACCOUNTABILITY: The incident, which occured at a Shin Kong Mitsukoshi Department Store in Taichung, was allegedly caused by a gas explosion on the 12th floor Shin Kong Group (新光集團) president Richard Wu (吳昕陽) yesterday said the company would take responsibility for an apparent gas explosion that resulted in four deaths and 26 injuries at Shin Kong Mitsukoshi Zhonggang Store in Taichung yesterday. The Taichung Fire Bureau at 11:33am yesterday received a report saying that people were injured after an explosion at the department store on Section 3 of Taiwan Boulevard in Taichung’s Situn District (西屯). It sent 56 ambulances and 136 paramedics to the site, with the people injured sent to Cheng Ching Hospital’s Chung Kang Branch, Wuri Lin Shin Hospital, Taichung Veterans General Hospital or Chung
ALL-IN-ONE: A company in Tainan and another in New Taipei City offer tours to China during which Taiwanese can apply for a Chinese ID card, the source said The National Immigration Agency and national security authorities have identified at least five companies that help Taiwanese apply for Chinese identification cards while traveling in China, a source said yesterday. The issue has garnered attention in the past few months after YouTuber “Pa Chiung” (八炯) said that there are companies in Taiwan that help Taiwanese apply for Chinese documents. Minister of the Interior Liu Shyh-fang (劉世芳) last week said that three to five public relations firms in southern and northern Taiwan have allegedly assisted Taiwanese in applying for Chinese ID cards and were under investigation for potential contraventions of the Act Governing
‘LAWFUL USE’: The last time a US warship transited the Taiwan Strait was on Oct. 20 last year, and this week’s transit is the first of US President Donald Trump’s second term Two US military vessels transited the Taiwan Strait from Sunday through early yesterday, the Ministry of National Defense said in a statement, the first such mission since US President Donald Trump took office last month. The two vessels sailed south through the Strait, the ministry said, adding that it closely monitored nearby airspace and waters at the time and observed nothing unusual. The ministry did not name the two vessels, but the US Navy identified them as the Arleigh Burke-class guided-missile destroyer USS Ralph Johnson and the Pathfinder-class survey ship USNS Bowditch. The ships carried out a north-to-south transit from