Morgan Stanley led a three-year campaign to "blacken the image" of French luxury goods giant LVMH Moet Hennessy Louis Vuitton, while hiding its business relationship with rival Gucci, a Paris court was told on Monday.
The claims were made as lawyers for the US investment bank and LVMH faced off for the last time before a verdict is due on Jan. 12 in the French group's US$118 million lawsuit against Morgan Stanley.
Investment advice published over three years by Morgan Stanley luxury analyst Claire Kent "contained systematically erroneous and biased information" designed to denigrate the French group and boost Gucci's share price, LVMH's lead counsel Georges Terrier told the Paris Commercial Court.
Philippe Nouel, a lawyer for the bank, dismissed LVMH's six-point charge sheet as "a pure invention," motivated by lasting enmity over Morgan Stanley's 1999 role in helping Gucci evade a planned LVMH takeover.
The suit is the latest twist in a long-running global scandal over conflicts of interest between research and investment banking departments operating under one roof.
Wall Street's biggest brokerages including Morgan Stanley have already paid out US$1.4 billion in a related settlement with US state and federal regulators.
All are now closely watching the LVMH case for signs that more private suits could follow from disgruntled rivals of their investment banking clients.
"LVMH is the victim of the same practices seen in the United States," Terrier told the panel of three judges hearing the case.
"They tried to blacken the name of LVMH," he added.
Over two hours, Terrier catalogued some of the examples of Morgan Stanley investment advice included in 1,900 pages of evidence submitted to the court soon after the suit was filed last year.
Among these was an e-mail from July 17 last year, in which Morgan Stanley warned investors that LVMH's credit rating was likely to be downgraded in coming months, harming its share price.
Court documents say the e-mail was based on an April 26 decision by ratings agency Standard and Poor's to attach a negative outlook to its BBB+ credit rating for LVMH.
The French group says the bank ignored its positive indicators since the April ratings decision, instead taking advantage of the three-month-old information to stoke fears for the stock at a time when markets were already spooked by a string of more recent downgrades.
Two weeks later Morgan Stanley warned that core LVMH brand Louis Vuitton was approaching "maturity" and wiped 10 percent off its LVMH valuation without further explanation, according to the evidence submitted.
The French group also maintains that Morgan Stanley repeatedly lied to investors that LVMH was one of its clients, to lend credibility to its negative stance on its stock.
"However, during this period there was no mention of any relationship whatsoever with Gucci," Terrier said.
A Morgan Stanley official rejected the allegations.
PRECISION STRIKES: The most significant reason to deploy HIMARS to outlying islands is to establish a ‘dead zone’ that the PLA would not dare enter, a source said A High Mobility Artillery Rocket System (HIMARS) would be deployed to Penghu County and Dongyin Island (東引) in Lienchiang County (Matsu) to force the Chinese military to retreat at least 100km from the coastline, a military source said yesterday. Taiwan has been procuring HIMARS and Army Tactical Missile Systems (ATACMS) from the US in batches. Once all batches have been delivered, Taiwan would possess 111 HIMARS units and 504 ATACMS, which have a range of 300km. Considering that “offense is the best defense,” the military plans to forward-deploy the systems to outlying islands such as Penghu and Dongyin so that
WHAT WAS ALL THAT FOR? Jaw Shaw-kong said that Cheng Li-wen had pushed for more drastic cuts and attacked him, just for the outcome to be nearly identical to his bill The legislature yesterday passed a supplementary budget bill to fund the purchase of separate packages of US military equipment, with the combined amount of spending capped at NT$780 billion (US$24.8 billion). The Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) and Taiwan People’s Party (TPP) used their legislative majority to pass the bill, which runs until 2033 and has two main funding provisions. One was for NT$300 billion of arms sales already approved by the US for Taiwan on Dec. 17 last year, the other was for NT$480 billion for another arms package expected to be announced by Washington. The bill, which fell short of the NT$1.25
‘CLEAR MESSAGE’: The bill would set up an interagency ‘tiger team’ to review sanctions tools and other economic options to help deter any Chinese aggression toward Taiwan US Representative Young Kim has introduced a bill to deter Chinese aggression against Taiwan, calling for an interagency “tiger team” to preplan coordinated sanctions and economic measures in response to possible Chinese military or political action against Taiwan. “[Chinese President] Xi Jinping [習近平] has directed the People’s Liberation Army to be ready to invade Taiwan by 2027. China has a plan. America should have one too,” Kim said in a news release on Thursday last week. She introduced the “Deter PRC [People’s Republic of China] aggression against Taiwan act” to “ensure the US has a coordinated sanctions strategy ready should
A former television news host and six military personnel — active and retired — have been indicted on espionage charges, Kaohsiung prosecutors said yesterday. Lin Chen-you (林宸佑), a former CTi News host and YouTuber, last year allegedly made videos at the direction of a Chinese agent criticizing the Democratic Progressive Party’s recall campaign, the Ciaotou District Prosecutors’ Office told a news conference in Kaohsiung. He allegedly received 4,325 tether coins for the videos from an unidentified person surnamed Huang (黃), believed to be an agent of a hostile foreign power, they said. Lin, also known as Ma Te (馬德), has a show named
RSS