The plot of wasteland opposite Beijing's Kunlun Hotel looks like just another construction site.
But legal history is being made here.
China's Foreign Trade Ministry is being sued for the first time after a Chinese firm challenged a ministry edict that stopped its attempt to muscle a foreign partner out of a huge property venture on this piece of prime real estate.
The cast of characters is broad: an ambitious Beijing firm, a Hong Kong developer, a once-mighty Korean conglomerate and a government ministry in a country where money and personal connections have long held sway.
The plot is a cautionary tale for foreign investors rushing into the potentially vast but often fickle Chinese market.
And the conclusion could set an important legal precedent in China's debut year in the WTO.
"This is the first time the ministry has been a defendant in a civil lawsuit," a ministry official said.
Once upon a day
It all started in 1995.
Beijing Second Light Industrial Group and Hong Kong-based Galilee International Holdings agreed to set up a property venture, according to lawyers and court documents.
Galilee International poured US$12 million into the new company for a 60-percent stake.
The Beijing firm took a 32-percent stake representing its rights to the land. A third Chinese company took the remainder.
The idea was to build a vast complex of offices, hotels, apartments and retail outlets in one of Beijing's most prosperous quarters.
In 1996, Galilee helped land a deal with South Korea's Daewoo Corp to arrange US$235 million in loans for the project.
But after sinking in US$35 million, Daewoo was hit by the Asian financial crisis in 1997. It cut off funding and construction ground to a halt, lawyers said.
Then things got messy.
Galilee executives said that in 2000, after failing to restart the project, Beijing Second tried to force Galilee to sell its shares.
The Beijing firm complained to city authorities that the deal was invalid because nearly two-thirds of Galilee's investment was made illegally in Chinese yuan rather than in foreign currency.
Galilee lawyers admitted the firm violated China's foreign investment rules by routing those funds through a company based in the southern province of Guangdong that neighbors Hong Kong.
In August last year, the Beijing Bureau of Industry and Commerce ordered Galilee to "honor" its contractual pledge to invest US$12 million in US currency.
The Beijing Economic and Trade Commission, which had originally approved the venture, went a step further, authorizing the Beijing group to declare Galilee's investment void and wipe out Galilee's shares.
Galilee fought back by filing a slew of complaints to government and Communist Party officials, executives said.
The case caught the eye of the Foreign Trade Ministry, which overturned the Beijing city commission ruling in July, saying flaws in Galilee's investment were no grounds to deprive it of its stake.
Bullying
The ministry and Galilee executives also alleged that Beijing Second had bullied accountants into altering their certification of Galilee's investment in a bid to show they never approved it.
During a recent three-hour hearing in the Beijing Second Intermediate Court, the ministry and its lawyers defended its edict and criticized the Beijing commission's directive as "unfair" to Galilee.
The edict said the city Economic and Trade Commission's directive was "perfunctory and unserious." The ministry said it was based largely on a handwritten note from the Beijing Bureau of Industry and Commerce that claimed to negate Galilee's stake.
The Beijing firm did not take the decision by the powerful ministry, which oversees tens of billions of dollars in foreign investment a year, lying down.
The firm brought an unprecedented civil lawsuit against it, asking the court to stay the ministry's order on the grounds that Galilee had not stuck to its promises.
The court has yet to issue a notice on further hearings.
UPDATED (3:40pm): A suspected gas explosion at a shopping mall in Taichung this morning has killed four people and injured 20 others, as emergency responders continue to investigate. The explosion occurred on the 12th floor of the Shin Kong Mitsukoshi in Situn District (西屯) at 11:33am. One person was declared dead at the scene, while three people were declared deceased later after receiving emergency treatment. Another 20 people sustained major or minor injuries. The Taichung Fire Bureau said it received a report of the explosion at 11:33am and sent rescuers to respond. The cause of the explosion is still under investigation, it said. The National Fire
ALL-IN-ONE: A company in Tainan and another in New Taipei City offer tours to China during which Taiwanese can apply for a Chinese ID card, the source said The National Immigration Agency and national security authorities have identified at least five companies that help Taiwanese apply for Chinese identification cards while traveling in China, a source said yesterday. The issue has garnered attention in the past few months after YouTuber “Pa Chiung” (八炯) said that there are companies in Taiwan that help Taiwanese apply for Chinese documents. Minister of the Interior Liu Shyh-fang (劉世芳) last week said that three to five public relations firms in southern and northern Taiwan have allegedly assisted Taiwanese in applying for Chinese ID cards and were under investigation for potential contraventions of the Act Governing
‘INVESTMENT’: Rubio and Arevalo said they discussed the value of democracy, and Rubio thanked the president for Guatemala’s strong diplomatic relationship with Taiwan Guatemalan President Bernardo Arevalo met with US Secretary of State Marco Rubio in Guatemala City on Wednesday where they signed a deal for Guatemala to accept migrants deported from the US, while Rubio commended Guatemala for its support for Taiwan and said the US would do all it can to facilitate greater Taiwanese investment in Guatemala. Under the migrant agreement announced by Arevalo, the deportees would be returned to their home countries at US expense. It is the second deportation deal that Rubio has reached during a Central America trip that has been focused mainly on immigration. Arevalo said his
‘SOVEREIGN AI’: As of Nov. 19 last year, Taiwan was globally ranked No. 11 for having computing power of 103 petaflops. The governments wants to achieve 1,200 by 2029 The government would intensify efforts to bolster its “Sovereign Artificial Intelligence [AI]” program by setting a goal of elevating the nation’s collective computing power in the public and private sectors to 1,200 peta floating points per second (petaflops) by 2029, the Executive Yuan said yesterday. The goal was set to fulfill President William Lai’s (賴清德) vision of turning Taiwan into an “AI island.” Sovereign AI refers to a nation’s capabilities to produce AI using its own infrastructure, data, workforce and business networks. One petaflop allows 1 trillion calculations per second. As of Nov. 19 last year, Taiwan was globally ranked No. 11 for