Just when you thought their reputations could sink no lower, perfidious stock analysts roared back into the news last week. That's the trouble with these long-running corporate scandals: No matter how heartily investors long for good news, the bad just keeps on coming.
First we learned of the Merrill Lynch analyst who was bullish on Tyco International stock and exchanged gifts of expensive wine with L. Dennis Kozlowski, the former chief. This mutual admiration society emerged last week when Robert M. Morgenthau, the New York district attorney, brought a new indictment against Kozlowski, whose greed apparently knew no bounds.
Now comes a new spate of e-mail messages from last year between two former analysts at Credit Suisse First Boston, Jamie Kiggen, an Internet analyst, and Laura Martin, who covered entertainment.
The subject of the messages: the firm's coverage of AOL Time Warner in March 2001.
In mid-March of that year, just after AOL and Time Warner merged, investors were growing concerned that the company would not be able to meet its aggressive revenue estimates of more than US$40 billion for the year. An analyst at Merrill Lynch cut its revenue estimates, and Kiggen asked several associates, including Martin, to get together to discuss reducing Credit Suisse's estimates.
On March 29, Martin replied by e-mail: "This may be one that you and I disagree on. I would not lower numbers on AOL, even though they can't make them."
Martin goes on to suggest that the analysts focus instead on other aspects of the company's financial statements, like "options issuance value."
That way, "we leave the income statement intact," she said, and avoid enraging the company, "and we don't waste time and energy focusing on what everyone else is focusing on."
Kiggen apparently followed that advice. In May, he wrote of the firm's confidence in AOL's ability to deliver on its 2001 forecast. It wasn't until August that he lowered his estimates for the second half of last year.
Kiggen left Credit Suisse this year and could not be reached for comment. Martin, now executive vice president for investor relations at Vivendi Universal, said: "My focus was, let's do value-added work that no one else was doing, that doesn't require us to make that trade-off. I don't think you do investors a favor if you so irritate a company that they stop talking to you."
But William F. Galvin, secretary of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts, whose staff found the e-mail messages in investigating analyst practices at Credit Suisse, said: "It seems to me this is really a smoking gun. Because it is AOL it involves tens of thousands of investors. These analysts knew they were misleading investors and yet they gave bad advice. They felt their allegiance was to profits and AOL, not to investors."
A Credit Suisse spokeswoman said the firm was working closely with regulators on analyst issues.
In the mania for technology stocks, Kiggen wrote breathlessly of the potential of Internet shares. He was also a heavy user of unattainable price targets.
In May 2000, Kiggen, then at Donaldson, Lufkin & Jenrette, assigned a price target of US$160 to GoTo.com. The stock was trading at US$15.13 at the time. It never came close to the target.
Kiggen was also the subject of a complaint filed in July 2000 with the National Association of Securities Dealers and the Securities and Exchange Commission. Eric P. Von der Porten, portfolio manager at Leeward Investments in San Carlos, California, complained that Kiggen had advised investors to buy shares in Amazon.com based on unreasonable estimates of what a customer would spend at the Web site over a lifetime. No action was taken.
TYPHOON: The storm’s path indicates a high possibility of Krathon making landfall in Pingtung County, depending on when the storm turns north, the CWA said Typhoon Krathon is strengthening and is more likely to make landfall in Taiwan, the Central Weather Administration (CWA) said in a forecast released yesterday afternoon. As of 2pm yesterday, the CWA’s updated sea warning for Krathon showed that the storm was about 430km southeast of Oluanpi (鵝鑾鼻), Taiwan’s southernmost point. It was moving in west-northwest at 9kph, with maximum sustained winds of 119kph and gusts of up to 155kph, CWA data showed. Krathon is expected to move further west before turning north tomorrow, CWA forecaster Wu Wan-hua (伍婉華) said. The CWA’s latest forecast and other countries’ projections of the storm’s path indicate a higher
SLOW-MOVING STORM: The typhoon has started moving north, but at a very slow pace, adding uncertainty to the extent of its impact on the nation Work and classes have been canceled across the nation today because of Typhoon Krathon, with residents in the south advised to brace for winds that could reach force 17 on the Beaufort scale as the Central Weather Administration (CWA) forecast that the storm would make landfall there. Force 17 wind with speeds of 56.1 to 61.2 meters per second, the highest number on the Beaufort scale, rarely occur and could cause serious damage. Krathon could be the second typhoon to land in southwestern Taiwan, following typhoon Elsie in 1996, CWA records showed. As of 8pm yesterday, the typhoon’s center was 180km
TYPHOON DAY: Taitung, Pingtung, Tainan, Chiayi, Hualien and Kaohsiung canceled work and classes today. The storm is to start moving north this afternoon The outer rim of Typhoon Krathon made landfall in Taitung County and the Hengchun Peninsula (恆春半島) at about noon yesterday, the Central Weather Administration (CWA) said, adding that the eye of the storm was expected to hit land tomorrow. The CWA at 2:30pm yesterday issued a land alert for Krathon after issuing a sea alert on Sunday. It also expanded the scope of the sea alert to include waters north of Taiwan Strait, in addition to its south, from the Bashi Channel to the Pratas Islands (Dongsha Islands, 東沙群島). As of 6pm yesterday, the typhoon’s center was 160km south of
STILL DANGEROUS: The typhoon was expected to weaken, but it would still maintain its structure, with high winds and heavy rain, the weather agency said One person had died amid heavy winds and rain brought by Typhoon Krathon, while 70 were injured and two people were unaccounted for, the Central Emergency Operation Center said yesterday, while work and classes have been canceled nationwide today for the second day. The Hualien County Fire Department said that a man in his 70s had fallen to his death at about 11am on Tuesday while trimming a tree at his home in Shoufeng Township (壽豐). Meanwhile, the Yunlin County Fire Department received a report of a person falling into the sea at about 1pm on Tuesday, but had to suspend search-and-rescue
RSS