Faced with allegations of grave violations in China and Russia, the UN body created to address rights abuses seems paralyzed by uncertainty on how to respond.
The UN Human Rights Council, which is to host a month-long session in Geneva from tomorrow, frequently acts to investigate and rein in abuses inside countries.
That task is trickier and more fraught when the countries involved are among the world’s most powerful, and permanent members of the UN Security Council.
Photo: AP
Human rights council members have long shied away from taking on the two heavyweights directly, but a damning UN report on abuses in China’s Xinjiang region and concerns over an intensifying crackdown inside Russia have spurred calls for action.
Yet fears abound that a failed attempt to hold either country accountable would signal a shifting power balance and weaken the council.
“The way the council builds its response will influence its capacity to address the most serious situations in the years to come,” a European diplomat said. “What is at stake is the vision of the universality of human rights, the vision of the role of the human rights council.”
China is facing intense scrutiny after former UN high commissioner for human rights Michelle Bachelet released her long-delayed Xinjiang report last week, warning of possible crimes against humanity.
The report brought the UN seal to allegations by campaigners and others of a litany of abuses in Xinjiang, where they say more than 1 million Uighurs and other Muslims have been detained.
Beijing has vehemently rejected such charges and criticized the report, accusing the UN of becoming a “thug and accomplice of the US and the West.”
Bachelet’s newly appointed successor, Volker Turk of Austria, would face the tricky follow-up job, but the report also hints that the rights council should address the issue.
Amid frenzied diplomatic consultations, there appears to be agreement that doing nothing is not an option.
“If a majority of countries on the Human Rights Council decide not to take action in a situation as serious as the one described in Mrs Bachelet’s report, that would mean that we are in another world order,” the European diplomat said.
There have been calls for an urgent council debate on Xinjiang, or a resolution denouncing the abuses or even requesting the appointment of an expert to probe the situation.
“Governments should waste no time establishing an independent investigation,” John Fisher of Human Rights Watch said.
At the same time, Western countries and their allies are wary of the effects if they fail to garner enough votes to pass a resolution in the 47-member-council.
“There is a cost of inaction, and a cost of a failed attempt to act,” a Western diplomat said.
China has been energetically lobbying countries behind the scenes to “pre-emptively” counter any moves, observers say.
“We are strongly opposed to any politically-motivated exercise,” Chinese Ambassador to the UN Office at Geneva Chen Xu (陳旭) told reporters on Friday. “We are ready to conduct business in a constructive way, but if anybody launches joint actions against us, we have to be fully prepared.”
It remains unclear how the votes would land, and observers say Western countries might postpone presenting a resolution until they know the support is there.
“We need to look very closely at whether we have a majority or not,” the European diplomat said.
The same goes for Russia.
Despite being kicked off the council earlier this year over its war in Ukraine, “Russia does not lack support,” the European diplomat said. “One has to keep that in mind... The impact of a defeated resolution would be felt for a long time.”
The military is to begin conscripting civilians next year, Cambodian Prime Minister Hun Manet said yesterday, citing rising tensions with Thailand as the reason for activating a long-dormant mandatory enlistment law. The Cambodian parliament in 2006 approved a law that would require all Cambodians aged 18 to 30 to serve in the military for 18 months, although it has never been enforced. Relations with Thailand have been tense since May, when a long-standing territorial dispute boiled over into cross-border clashes, killing one Cambodian soldier. “This episode of confrontation is a lesson for us and is an opportunity for us to review, assess and
The Russian minister of foreign affairs warned the US, South Korea and Japan against forming a security partnership targeting North Korea as he visited the ally country for talks on further solidifying their booming military and other cooperation. Russian Minister of Foreign Affairs Sergei Lavrov spoke on Saturday in Wonsan City, North Korea, where he met North Korean Leader Kim Jong-un and conveyed greetings from Russian President Vladimir Putin. Kim during the meeting reaffirmed his government’s commitment to “unconditionally support and encourage all measures” taken by Russia in its conflict with Ukraine. Pyongyang and Moscow share identical views on “all strategic issues in
IDENTITY: A sex extortion scandal involving Thai monks has deeply shaken public trust in the clergy, with 11 monks implicated in financial misconduct Reverence for the saffron-robed Buddhist monkhood is deeply woven into Thai society, but a sex extortion scandal has besmirched the clergy and left the devout questioning their faith. Thai police this week arrested a woman accused of bedding at least 11 monks in breach of their vows of celibacy, before blackmailing them with thousands of secretly taken photos of their trysts. The monks are said to have paid nearly US$12 million, funneled out of their monasteries, funded by donations from laypeople hoping to increase their merit and prospects for reincarnation. The scandal provoked outrage over hypocrisy in the monkhood, concern that their status
‘FALSE NARRATIVE’: China and the Solomon Islands inked a secretive security pact in 2022, which is believed to be a prelude to building a Chinese base, which Beijing denied The Australian government yesterday said it expects China to spy on major military drills it is conducting with the US and other allies. It also renewed a charge — denounced by Beijing as a “false narrative” — that China wants to establish a military base in the South Pacific. The comments by a government minister came as Australian Prime Minister Anthony Albanese made a six-day visit to China to bolster recently repaired trade ties. More than 30,000 military personnel from 19 nations are set to join in the annual Talisman Sabre exercises from yesterday across Australia and Papua New Guinea. “The Chinese military have
RSS