A US judge on Tuesday blocked an executive order by US President Donald Trump that could deny billions of dollars to so-called sanctuary cities as punishment for harboring illegal immigrants.
Dealing a fresh setback to Trump’s pledged crackdown on undocumented residents, Judge William Orrick of San Francisco’s federal court issued a preliminary injunction barring any attempt to implement the Jan. 25 executive order.
“Federal funding that bears no meaningful relationship to immigration enforcement cannot be threatened merely because a jurisdiction chooses an immigration enforcement strategy of which the president disapproves,” Orrick said.
The decision — which could impact more than 300 cities and counties that have denounced the president’s order — is another blow to the White House following successful court challenges to its two travel bans targeting Muslim-majority countries.
Trump’s order threatened the transfer of about US$1.7 billion to Santa Clara County and US$1.2 billion for San Francisco.
The White House issued a scathing statement claiming that “the rule of law suffered another blow, as an unelected judge unilaterally rewrote immigration policy.”
The judge’s “erroneous ruling is a gift to the criminal gang and cartel element in our country,” and is “one more example of egregious overreach” by a single judge that “undermines faith in our legal system.”
Nevertheless “we are confident we will ultimately prevail in the Supreme Court,” the statement read.
Santa Clara counsel James Williams described it as “a historic affirmation” of the constitutional principle that Washington cannot “coerce local governments into becoming federal immigration enforcers.”
Orrick said that the government’s lawyers had sought to avoid arguing the issue of whether the Trump administration had the right to take such steps.
Instead, they weakly challenged the right of San Francisco and Santa Clara County to fight the order because neither had been formally declared “sanctuary jurisdictions” — a phrase that remains vague in the law.
The judge said the key issue remained Trump’s repeated statements that funding is a “weapon” to use against cities that resist his policies. That demonstrates the government’s intent, he said, and is unconstitutional.
“The constitution vests the spending powers in Congress, not the president, so the order cannot constitutionally place new conditions on federal funds,” he said.
Santa Clara County Board of Supervisors President Dave Cortes, said the decision had dealt a “major setback” to the politics of fear.
“Millions of people across the country can continue to receive essential medical care, go to school and remain active members of their communities without fear that their local governments are being forced to work against them, rather than for them,” he added.
The decision was being closely watched in Seattle, which filed its own lawsuit against the order last month.
Seattle Mayor Ed Murray issued a statement welcoming the ruling as “yet another rebuke” of Trump’s “dangerous overreach.”
New York City Mayor Bill de Blasio denounced Trump’s “illogical and unconstitutional desire to scapegoat immigrants.”
Chicago Mayor Rahm Emanuel said that his administration would not “sit idly by while President Trump threatens American cities because he doesn’t share our values.”
California Attorney General Xavier Becerra said the president was trying to “hijack crucial resources, sow fear among California families and make our communities less safe.”
However, Orrick’s ruling still allows the US Department of Justice to follow through with threats made to nine cities last week to cut specific program grants if the cities did not adequately cooperate with federal immigration officers.
The order “does not purport to enjoin the department’s independent legal authority to enforce the requirements of federal law applicable to communities that violate federal immigration law or federal grant conditions,” department spokesman Ian Prior said.
A meeting in Washington on Tuesday between a group of major-city mayors and US Attorney General Jeff Sessions demonstrated that the two sides remain at odds over Trump’s election promise to expel about 11.3 million immigrants without legal residency.
The mayors said federal policy remains unclear and inconsistent, and complained the government is telling them to deploy local law enforcement officers to enforce federal immigration laws.
The Philippines yesterday said its coast guard would acquire 40 fast patrol craft from France, with plans to deploy some of them in disputed areas of the South China Sea. The deal is the “largest so far single purchase” in Manila’s ongoing effort to modernize its coast guard, with deliveries set to start in four years, Philippine Coast Guard Commandant Admiral Ronnie Gil Gavan told a news conference. He declined to provide specifications for the vessels, which Manila said would cost 25.8 billion pesos (US$440 million), to be funded by development aid from the French government. He said some of the vessels would
BEYOND WASHINGTON: Although historically the US has been the partner of choice for military exercises, Jakarta has been trying to diversify its partners, an analyst said Indonesia’s first joint military drills with Russia this week signal that new Indonesian President Prabowo Subianto would seek a bigger role for Jakarta on the world stage as part of a significant foreign policy shift, analysts said. Indonesia has long maintained a neutral foreign policy and refuses to take sides in the Russia-Ukraine conflict or US-China rivalry, but Prabowo has called for stronger ties with Moscow despite Western pressure on Jakarta. “It is part of a broader agenda to elevate ties with whomever it may be, regardless of their geopolitical bloc, as long as there is a benefit for Indonesia,” said Pieter
US ELECTION: Polls show that the result is likely to be historically tight. However, a recent Iowa poll showed Harris winning the state that Trump won in 2016 and 2020 US Vice President and Democratic presidential candidate Kamala Harris courted voters angered by the Gaza war while former US President and Republican candidate Donald Trump doubled down on violent rhetoric with a comment about journalists being shot as the tense US election campaign entered its final hours. The Democratic vice president and the Republican former president frantically blitzed several swing states as they tried to win over the last holdouts with less than 36 hours left until polls open on election day today. Trump predicted a “landslide,” while Harris told a raucous rally in must-win Michigan that “we have momentum — it’s
CARGO PLANE VECTOR: Officials said they believe that attacks involving incendiary devices on planes was the work of Russia’s military intelligence agency the GRU Western security officials suspect Russian intelligence was behind a plot to put incendiary devices in packages on cargo planes headed to North America, including one that caught fire at a courier hub in Germany and another that ignited in a warehouse in England. Poland last month said that it had arrested four people suspected to be linked to a foreign intelligence operation that carried out sabotage and was searching for two others. Lithuania’s prosecutor general Nida Grunskiene on Tuesday said that there were an unspecified number of people detained in several countries, offering no elaboration. The events come as Western officials say