New guidelines in a US military war manual might change the rules for reporters covering conflicts, but it remains to be seen how the Pentagon is to implement the new policy.
Media watchdog organizations have expressed shock and concern that reporters could be treated as “unprivileged belligerents” under the US Department of Defense’s new Law of War Manual, which provides guidance for US commanders and others.
The Pentagon has insisted it “supports and respects the vital work that journalists perform,” but some media advocates see too much room for maneuver in the guidelines.
Reporters Without Borders (RSF) joined other organizations this past week in expressing concern, sending a letter to US Secretary of Defense Ashton Carter, urging consultations on the issue.
In the letter to Carter, the Paris-based group said it was concerned that journalists could lose “privileged” status in combat areas merely by “the relaying of information,” which, according to the guidelines, “could constitute taking a direct part in hostilities.”
“This terminology leaves too much room for interpretation, putting journalists in a dangerous situation,” RSF secretary-general Christophe Deloire said in the letter.
Deloire said governments “have a duty to protect journalists covering armed conflicts” under a UN resolution and that his group was “disappointed that this manual takes a step in the wrong direction.”
The New York-based Committee to Protect Journalists last month expressed similar concerns, saying the Pentagon “has produced a self-serving document that is unfortunately helping to lower the bar” for press freedom.
The New York Times, in an editorial this month, called for the repeal of provisions affecting media, warning they would make the work of journalists covering armed conflict “more dangerous, cumbersome and subject to censorship.”
The newspaper said the rules could put reporters in the same category assigned to guerrillas or members of al-Qaeda.
Treating journalists as potential spies, the newspaper argued, feeds into the propaganda of authoritarian governments that attempt to discredit Western journalists by falsely accusing them of espionage.
Heidi Kitrosser, a professor of constitutional law at the University of Minnesota, who follows issues of free speech and government secrecy, agreed on the potential for curbing press freedoms.
“The breadth of the manual’s language and its potential applications is alarming,” she said.
She added that the shift “is troubling for its conflict with US constitutional principles and also for its potential invoking by authoritarian regimes to support their own suppression of journalists.”
Steven Aftergood, who monitors US government secrecy at the Federation of American Scientists, said implementation of the policy would be critical, adding that it merely codifies existing practices and laws.
“A lot depends on how those laws are interpreted in practice,” Aftergood said. “What seems clear is that extreme positions on either side of the issue are mistaken. In other words, total suppression of news coverage of war is obviously unacceptable, but so is the notion of absolute press freedom.”
“There are likely to be legitimate battlefield secrets that the military is within its rights to protect, but how to navigate between those extreme positions is less clear and is hard to state in the abstract,” he added.
“In the US, at least, constitutional values should lead us to favor freedom of the press,” he said.
The Pentagon said some elements of the manual might have been misconstrued, but that it was willing to work to allay any concerns.
The pledge by Japanese Prime Minister Sanae Takaichi to “work, work, work, work and work” for her country has been named the catchphrase of the year, recognizing the effort Japan’s first female leader had to make to reach the top. Takaichi uttered the phrase in October when she was elected as head of the ruling Liberal Democratic Party (LDP). Many were initially as worried about her work ethic as supportive of her enthusiasm. In a country notorious for long working hours, especially for working women who are also burdened with homemaking and caregiving, overwork is a sensitive topic. The recognition triggered a
Tropical Storm Koto killed three people and left another missing as it approached Vietnam, authorities said yesterday, as strong winds and high seas buffeted vessels off the country’s flood-hit central coast. Heavy rains have lashed Vietnam’s middle belt in recent weeks, flooding historic sites and popular holiday destinations, and causing hundreds of millions of dollars in damage. Authorities ordered boats to shore and diverted dozens of flights as Koto whipped up huge waves and dangerous winds, state media reported. Two vessels sank in the rough seas, a fishing boat in Khanh Hoa province and a smaller raft in Lam Dong, according to the
‘HEART IS ACHING’: Lee appeared to baffle many when he said he had never heard of six South Koreans being held in North Korea, drawing criticism from the families South Korean President Lee Jae-myung yesterday said he was weighing a possible apology to North Korea over suspicions that his ousted conservative predecessor intentionally sought to raise military tensions between the war-divided rivals in the buildup to his brief martial law declaration in December last year. Speaking to reporters on the first anniversary of imprisoned former South Korean president Yoon Suk-yeol’s ill-fated power grab, Lee — a liberal who won a snap presidential election following Yoon’s removal from office in April — stressed his desire to repair ties with Pyongyang. A special prosecutor last month indicted Yoon and two of his top
The Philippines deferred the awarding of a project that is part of a plan to build one of the world’s longest marine bridges after local opposition over the potential involvement of a Chinese company due to national security fears. The proposals are “undergoing thorough review” by the Asian Development Bank (ADB), which acts as a lender and an overseer of the project to ensure it meets international environmental and governance standards, the Philippine Department of Public Works and Highways said in a statement on Monday in response to queries from Bloomberg. The agency said it would announce the winning bidder once ADB
RSS