China’s vast censorship machine does its utmost to wipe the slightest reference to the Tiananmen crackdown from books, television and the Internet, scrubbing the issue from public discussion and even from the minds of its younger generation.
In an example of George Orwell’s 1984 dictum that “who controls the present controls the past,” it reflects both the Chinese Communist Party’s (CCP) immense power and its enduring sensitivity about its actions on June 3 and June 4, 1989.
The overnight clearing of the square at the heart of Beijing, where student-led protesters had demanded reforms for seven weeks left hundreds dead — by some estimates more than 1,000 — and the CCP isolated from its people and the world.
Photo: AFP
A third of China’s population today was born afterward, while many of those alive at the time hesitate to broach the topic — leaving a huge swathe of those under 25 ignorant of the event.
“I don’t know what you are talking about,” a 20-year-old student at Peking University, one of China’s most prestigious, told reporters when asked about the protests.
Television, film and print media have always been under strict official control in China. Online, hundreds of millions of Chinese now have unprecedented access to information — but only that which has been approved by the authorities.
An army of censors deletes topics deemed sensitive, including the most oblique references to the crackdown. A Chinese equivalent of Wikipedia maintained by domestic Internet giant Baidu has no entry for the year 1989. On microblogging site Weibo, a long list of terms related to the June 4 crackdown are prohibited, including the characters for 6 and 4 strung together.
“The education system and the vast apparatus that censors the Chinese media and Internet have done such a formidable job at eliminating references to the events of 1989 that many young people are unaware of what happened, or have only a faint notion of what happened,” said Jeremy Goldkorn, the founder of Danwei, a Beijing-based firm that tracks Chinese media and Internet.
“The result is that many young people who do not remember 1989 themselves would need an unusual degree of curiosity to look for information about what happened,” he said.
For censors, no reference is too vague. When the Shanghai stock market closed down 64.89 points on the 2012 anniversary — an eerie echo of June 4, 1989 — they blocked the term “Shanghai index” on social networks. Last year they eliminated “big yellow duck,” after an image circulated online parodying what is known as the “Tank Man” photograph, with giant toy ducks standing in for the military vehicles blocked by a protester.
Web users find workarounds such as “May 35,” “63 plus 1” or homonyms of barred words, though they too are blacklisted.
“They are basically a mark of commemoration, like lighting up a candle somewhere, even if no one understands what the reference is,” said Jason Ng, a University of Toronto research fellow and author of Blocked on Weibo. “That means that you’re still aware, you still want to remember.”
Chinese writer Ma Jian (馬建), who now lives in London, evoked the nation’s collective silence in his 2008 novel Beijing Coma, centered on the memories of a young Tiananmen demonstrator shot and left paralyzed, mute and blind — but aware. The book is banned in China.
Director Lou Ye’s (婁燁) 2006 movie Summer Palace (頤和園), which depicts relationships against a backdrop of the protests, was shown at Cannes, but has never been released in China.
Censors told him the sound and picture quality were not good enough for screening, he has said. He was barred from directing for five years.
The Tiananmen Mothers, who lost children in the incident, call on authorities every year to give an account of what happened. Yet Zhang Xianling (張先玲), whose 19-year-old son was killed, sympathizes with Chinese who do not learn more.
“A lot of people do not have time to know about it, or do not want to know about it, because they are busy, or want to make a living, or have to work — this is understandable,” she told reporters. “But I believe that such a huge incident, such a huge tragedy, where so many innocent people were massacred... The truth cannot be covered up with lies forever.”
Nonetheless Cui Weiping (崔衛平), an outspoken professor at Beijing Film Academy, says there is a duty to speak out.
If silence continues, she has written, “June 4 will no longer be a crime that was committed by a small group of people, but one that we all participated in. It will become a shame on all of us”.
Many of the participants at a private seminar she attended on Tiananmen three weeks ago have been detained, and she said: “The situation is getting worse and worse.
“Of course, to remember is a moral obligation,” she said. “Anything else is a betrayal of the people who were killed.”
Heavy rain and strong winds yesterday disrupted flights, trains and ferries, forcing the closure of roads across large parts of New Zealand’s North Island, while snapping power links to tens of thousands. Domestic media reported a few flights had resumed operating by afternoon from the airport in Wellington, the capital, although cancelations were still widespread after airport authorities said most morning flights were disrupted. Air New Zealand said it hoped to resume services when conditions ease later yesterday, after it paused operations at Wellington, Napier and Palmerston North airports. Online images showed flooded semi-rural neighborhoods, inundated homes, trees fallen on vehicles and collapsed
POST-UPRISING: Bangladesh Nationalist Party lawmakers were yesterday expected to formally elect Tarique Rahman as their leader and new head of government Bangladesh’s prime minister-to-be Tarique Rahman and lawmakers were yesterday sworn into parliament, becoming the first elected representatives since a deadly 2024 uprising. Rahman is set to take over from an interim government that has steered the country of 170 million people for 18 months since the autocratic government of Sheikh Hasina was overthrown. The lawmakers, who promised loyalty to Bangladesh, were sworn in by Chief Election Commissioner AMM Nasir Uddin. Bangladesh Nationalist Party (BNP) lawmakers are expected to formally elect Rahman as their leader, with President Mohammed Shahabuddin then to administer the oath of office to the prime minister and his ministers
FRAYED: Strains between the US-European ties have ruptured allies’ trust in Washington, but with time, that could be rebuilt, the Michigan governor said China is providing crucial support for Russia’s aggression in Ukraine and could end the war with a phone call, US Ambassador to NATO Matthew Whitaker said. “China could call [Russian President] Vladimir Putin and end this war tomorrow and cut off his dual-purpose technologies that they’re selling,” Whitaker said during a Friday panel at the Munich Security Conference. “China could stop buying Russian oil and gas.” “You know, this war is being completely enabled by China,” the US envoy added. Beijing and Moscow have forged an even tighter partnership since the start of the war, and Russia relies on China for critical parts
In a softly lit Shanghai bar, graduate student Helen Zhao stretched out both wrists to have her pulse taken — the first step to ordering the house special, a bespoke “health” cocktail based on traditional Chinese medicine (TCM). “TCM bars” have popped up in several cities across China, epitomizing what the country’s stressed-out, time-poor youth refer to as “punk wellness,” or “wrecking yourself while saving yourself.” At Shanghai’s Niang Qing, a TCM doctor in a white coat diagnoses customers’ physical conditions based on the pulse readings, before a mixologist crafts custom drinks incorporating the herbs and roots prescribed for their ailments.
RSS