The state that produced the US’ richest man has never taken a cut of its residents’ income.
Microsoft co-founder Bill Gates and his father would like to change that.
They are among the wealthy residents of this west coast state who have joined labor unions and other traditional Democratic allies to support a tax-the-rich ballot measure that is dividing the state’s business leaders. Executives at Microsoft, Amazon and other technology companies have come out against it.
The initiative will test whether voters are willing to buck economic jitters and drain money from their rich neighbors at a time when national Democrats and Republicans have been waging an intense election-year battle over the merits of taxing the wealthy.
Washington’s measure, known as Initiative 1098, would institute a new state tax on the top 1 percent of incomes to pay for education and health programs, while trimming state property and business taxes. The campaign follows January’s overwhelming decision by Oregon voters to increase taxes for corporations and wealthier households.
While his famous son’s public support has so far been quiet, Bill Gates Sr, a prominent Seattle lawyer, helped to draft Washington’s income tax initiative and is the public face of the campaign.
In a recent TV ad, the elder Gates is knocked into a dunk tank by softball-tossing children — a playful approach to the idea that the measure will “soak the rich.”
Gates counters by highlighting the billions of US dollars the income tax would generate for education and healthcare programs.
“It’s really about doing something for the next generation,” Gates says before taking the plunge.
The initiative sets out two tax brackets. The first rate is 5 percent on the portion of adjusted gross income higher than US$400,000 for couples or US$200,000 for individuals.
For joint incomes above US$1 million, the tax would be US$30,000 plus 9 percent on earnings over the threshold. Single earners above US$500,000 would pay US$15,000 plus 9 percent of income above the threshold.
State officials say the tax initiative would raise more than US$2 billion annually from fewer than 40,000 households, or 1.2 percent of Washingtonians filing US federal returns. At present, Washington is one of seven states in the US without a personal income tax.
The US$4.3 million “yes” campaign is bankrolled largely by labor unions, particularly those representing government employees — more than US$1.7 million has come from various arms of the Service Employees International Union. Individual donors include Gates Sr, who has given US$500,000, and venture capitalist Nick Hanauer, who has donated US$250,000.
However, plenty of big-name business leaders are unhappy with the idea.
Amazon founder Jeff Bezos and Microsoft chief executive officer Steve Ballmer have each donated US$100,000 to the US$4 million opposition campaign, which also has drawn contributions from Russell Investments, Paccar, software billionaire Charles Simonyi and members of the Nordstrom family.
Opponents stress that state lawmakers could lower the income thresholds with a simple majority vote two years after the initiative is enacted and point out that state officials routinely raid “dedicated” spending accounts in lean years.
They also add that, in a time of terribly slow job growth, taking more money from entrepreneurs and businesspeople could seriously crimp the state’s economic rebound.
The privacy of tax returns makes it impossible to say how much the state’s marquee business names might pay under the initiative, but the tax would apply to personal earnings from partnerships, shares in small corporations, capital gains and other non-salary sources of income.
Right now, Washington’s lack of income tax can be a major recruitment point for businesses and talent looking to relocate, said Joe Barer, president of management consulting firm Lake Partners.
“I don’t think people come here just for the weather,” said Barer, who has donated to the opposition campaign. “I’ve personally recruited people and part of the pitch is, ‘Yes it’s a great place to live — and we have no income tax.’”
Hanauer, one of the earliest Amazon investors and founder of the online ad company aQuantive, sees the economics differently. In his judgment, the kind of wealth at stake in the initiative could do far more good for the economy by bankrolling public school teachers and other vital services.
“If you look at the money that somebody like me — or Jeff Bezos or Steve Ballmer — where our cash flow goes, it’s crazy to assert that the highest and best use is in our bank accounts or in the hedge funds that we’ve parked it in or as jet fuel in our private planes,” Hanauer said. “It’s just nuts.”
Liberals have been hoping the measure’s populist appeal would help drive friendly turnout in a political year that could be brutal for Democrats. However, voters do not appear wildly enthusiastic.
A recent survey by independent Seattle pollster Stuart Elway pegged support for the income tax initiative essentially tied with the opposition, 44 percent to 42 percent. The poll of 500 likely voters had a margin of sampling error of about 4.5 percent.
High-profile politicians also have been reluctant to participate in the debate, probably because the public appears so uncertain. For instance, the initiative has not been an issue in the state’s top election contest, a heated race between Democratic US Senator Patty Murray and Republican challenger Dino Rossi.
Income tax measures have been attempted over the years in Washington with little success.
Voters have defeated attempts to amend the state constitution for a state income tax, most recently in 1973, and the topic has often been considered a political loser since then.
OFF BORDER ISLAND: The fisheries official disappeared from a patrol vessel wearing a life jacket and leaving behind his shoes, indicating an intentional move, Seoul said North Korean soldiers shot dead a suspected South Korean defector at sea and burned his body as a COVID-19 precaution after he was interrogated in the water over several hours, Seoul military officials said yesterday. It is the first killing of a South Korean citizen by North Korean forces for a decade, and comes with Pyongyang at high alert over the COVID-19 pandemic and inter-Korean relations at a standstill. The fisheries official disappeared from a patrol vessel near the western border island of Yeonpyeong on Monday, the official said. More than 24 hours later, North Korean forces located him in their waters and
ACADEMIC FREEDOM: One professor told her students to submit anonymized papers and not to record any online classes. Some US schools have announced similar steps Students at Oxford University specializing in the study of China are being asked to submit some papers anonymously to protect them from the possibility of retribution under the sweeping new security law introduced three months ago in Hong Kong. The anonymity ruling is to be applied in classes, and group tutorials are to be replaced by one-to-ones. Students are also to be warned that it will be viewed as a disciplinary offence if they tape classes or share them with outside groups. The Hong Kong National Security Law was imposed on June 30 by Beijing after more than a year of pro-democracy
Japan’s government yesterday urged people to seek help if they were struggling to cope, following Sunday’s death of the popular actress and Miss Sherlock star Yuko Takeuchi, 40. News of her death shocked the nation and follows other recent cases of Japanese celebrities taking their lives, with figures showing a recent rise in suicides. Takeuchi was a household name in Japan and had given birth to her second child in January. Japanese Chief Cabinet Secretary Katsunobu Kato did not mention a particular case, but said that some people were struggling to cope during the COVID-19 pandemic. “There has been an uptick in the number
China on Thursday lashed out at the US at a high-level UN meeting over its criticism on the COVID-19 pandemic, with its envoy declaring, “Enough is enough.” Two days after US President Donald Trump used his annual address to the General Assembly to attack China’s record, US Ambassador to the UN Kelly Craft, also took an outraged tone — after which her Chinese counterpart showed palpable anger. “I must say, enough is enough. You have created enough troubles for the world already,” Chinese Ambassador to the UN Zhang Jun (張軍) told a Security Council meeting on global governance attended through videoconference