The US Supreme Court ruled on Monday it was unconstitutional to sentence juveniles to life in prison without parole for crimes other than murder.
The nation’s highest court ruled that life imprisonment without parole in such cases violated the Constitution’s ban on cruel and unusual punishment under the Eighth Amendment.
The US has been the only nation in the world that sentences juveniles to life in prison without the possibility of release for crimes other than murder, Justice Anthony Kennedy said in writing the court’s majority opinion.
He said 129 offenders were under the age of 18 when they committed their crimes and are serving such life sentences. Of the total, 77 are in Florida. Their violent crimes typically include rape, kidnapping and armed burglary and assault.
The ruling in a case from Florida was a victory for Terrance Graham, who was 16 when he committed armed burglary and another crime. He then committed an armed home-invasion robbery at age 17 and was sentenced to life in prison.
Six of the nine justices voted that Graham’s sentence was unconstitutional. But only five of the justices held that the new rule applied to all other cases.
Kennedy said 37 of the 50 states, Washington and the federal government all allowed sentences of life without parole for a juvenile non-homicide offender in some circumstances.
“The Supreme Court today has handed down its biggest and potentially most consequential Eighth Amendment ruling for non-death penalty cases in its history,” Ohio State University law professor Douglas Berman said.
Kennedy said a state was not required to eventually release a juvenile offender. But it must give a meaningful opportunity for the offender to obtain possible release from prison, based on demonstrated maturity and rehabilitation.
Kennedy agreed with the argument made by opponents of such sentences that they unfairly condemned adolescents to die in prison and rejected any hope the juveniles could change and be rehabilitated.
Human rights groups applauded the ruling.
“The United States is the world’s worst human rights violator in terms of sentencing young offenders to life without parole,” Alison Parker, US director for Human Rights Watch, said after the ruling.
Nationwide juvenile sentencing trends in recent years have reflected get-tough efforts by states, which have abolished parole and prosecuted juveniles as adults in the regular criminal justice system for especially heinous crimes.
Attorneys for Graham partly based their arguments on the Supreme Court’s ruling in 2005 that abolished the death penalty for juveniles on the grounds they are less responsible for their crimes than adults due to their emotional immaturity.
In Monday’s ruling, the Supreme Court adopted the same reasoning. Kennedy cited scientific studies showing that the same immaturity that makes teenagers more susceptible to peer pressure and external influences also make them strong candidates for rehabilitation.
“Life without parole is an especially harsh punishment for a juvenile. Under this sentence, a juvenile offender will on average serve more years and a greater percentage of his life in prison than an adult offender,” he wrote.
Bryan Stevenson of the Equal Justice Initiative, who had challenged such sentences, said, “It is an important win not only for kids who have been condemned to die in prison, but for all children who need additional protection and recognition in the criminal justice system.”
The ruling drew a strongly worded dissent from conservative Justice Clarence Thomas.
“For the first time in its history, the court declares an entire class of offenders immune from a noncapital sentence using the categorical approach it previously reserved for death penalty cases alone,” he wrote.
THE ‘MONSTER’: The Philippines on Saturday sent a vessel to confront a 12,000-tonne Chinese ship that had entered its exclusive economic zone The Philippines yesterday said it deployed a coast guard ship to challenge Chinese patrol boats attempting to “alter the existing status quo” of the disputed South China Sea. Philippine Coast Guard spokesman Commodore Jay Tarriela said Chinese patrol ships had this year come as close as 60 nautical miles (111km) west of the main Philippine island of Luzon. “Their goal is to normalize such deployments, and if these actions go unnoticed and unchallenged, it will enable them to alter the existing status quo,” he said in a statement. He later told reporters that Manila had deployed a coast guard ship to the area
A group of Uyghur men who were detained in Thailand more than one decade ago said that the Thai government is preparing to deport them to China, alarming activists and family members who say the men are at risk of abuse and torture if they are sent back. Forty-three Uyghur men held in Bangkok made a public appeal to halt what they called an imminent threat of deportation. “We could be imprisoned and we might even lose our lives,” the letter said. “We urgently appeal to all international organizations and countries concerned with human rights to intervene immediately to save us from
RISING TENSIONS: The nations’ three leaders discussed China’s ‘dangerous and unlawful behavior in the South China Sea,’ and agreed on the importance of continued coordination Japan, the Philippines and the US vowed to further deepen cooperation under a trilateral arrangement in the face of rising tensions in Asia’s waters, the three nations said following a call among their leaders. Japanese Prime Minister Shigeru Ishiba, Philippine President Ferdinand Marcos Jr and outgoing US President Joe Biden met via videoconference on Monday morning. Marcos’ communications office said the leaders “agreed to enhance and deepen economic, maritime and technology cooperation.” The call followed a first-of-its-kind summit meeting of Marcos, Biden and then-Japanese prime minister Fumio Kishida in Washington in April last year that led to a vow to uphold international
US president-elect Donald Trump is not typically known for his calm or reserve, but in a craftsman’s workshop in rural China he sits in divine contemplation. Cross-legged with his eyes half-closed in a pose evoking the Buddha, this porcelain version of the divisive US leader-in-waiting is the work of designer and sculptor Hong Jinshi (洪金世). The Zen-like figures — which Hong sells for between 999 and 20,000 yuan (US$136 to US$2,728) depending on their size — first went viral in 2021 on the e-commerce platform Taobao, attracting national headlines. Ahead of the real-estate magnate’s inauguration for a second term on Monday next week,
RSS