Israel's highest court yesterday upheld a much-criticized plea bargain that allowed former Israeli president Moshe Katsav to escape rape charges and a possible prison term.
A panel of five Supreme Court judges ruled that the deal was reasonable, rejecting claims that it went easy on Katsav because of his prominent position.
Katsav, who insists he was the victim of a witch hunt, left office in disgrace in June after four former female employees accused him of a series of sex crimes, including rape. Facing indictment, he agreed to a plea bargain that allowed him to avoid the gravest charges.
Attorney General Meni Mazuz, who initially had announced his intention to charge Katsav on all counts, later suggested the state was uncertain it could convict Katsav on the rape charges.
Under the deal, Katsav agreed to plead guilty to two counts of sexual harassment and resign just two weeks before his seven-year term was up.
Now that the plea bargain has been approved, Katsav will receive a suspended sentence with no jail time. The original charges could have carried a sentence of 20 years.
Good-governance and Women's rights groups, bolstered by a public outcry, had petitioned the Supreme Court to overturn the agreement shortly after it was announced eight months ago.
"This is a sad day," said Yifat Matzner, an attorney for a women's rights group that filed the appeal.
Kinneret Barashi, a lawyer for one of the women who accused Katsav of rape, said she was "very much infuriated" by the court's refusal to overturn the deal.
"If the attorney general's decision was wrong, deficient, riddled with shortcomings, distorts reality, causes many people emotional upheaval and leaves a woman's body defenseless, then I think it would have been proper to intervene in such a vile plea bargain," she said.
But Katzav's lawyers hailed the ruling.
"President Katzav was accused of the most serious crimes: two rapes here, another rape there, and was presented ... as a serial sexual offender," said Avigdor Feldman, his attorney, calling the final charges "a tiny, shriveled-up indictment."
"Someone owes the president a deep apology," Feldman said.
In announcing the plea bargain, Mazuz said one of his considerations was the reputation of the Israeli presidency and his desire to avoid a prolonged trial with painful headlines -- a point whose legal validity critics questioned.
Opponents of the deal had hoped the Supreme Court would take the rare step of declaring the plea bargain unacceptable and either overturn it or send it back to Mazuz for revision.
Katsav's accusers charged that he repeatedly fondled them, kissed them, exposed himself to them and -- in two cases -- raped them while he served as president and earlier, as tourism minister.
Although Israel's presidency is a largely ceremonial position, the allegations roiled the country by portraying the man who was supposed to be Israel's moral compass as a predatory boss.
Katsav suspended himself several months after the charges emerged in July 2006 in order to fight them, but refused to resign until the plea bargain forced him to do so. Israeli elder statesman and Nobel Peace Prize laureate Shimon Peres replaced him as Israel's ceremonial leader in July.
DEATH CONSTANTLY LOOMING: Decades of detention took a major toll on Iwao Hakamada’s mental health, his lawyers describing him as ‘living in a world of fantasy’ A Japanese man wrongly convicted of murder who was the world’s longest-serving death row inmate has been awarded US$1.44 million in compensation, an official said yesterday. The payout represents ￥12,500 (US$83) for each day of the more than four decades that Iwao Hakamada spent in detention, most of it on death row when each day could have been his last. It is a record for compensation of this kind, Japanese media said. The former boxer, now 89, was exonerated last year of a 1966 quadruple murder after a tireless campaign by his sister and others. The case sparked scrutiny of the justice system in
The head of Shin Bet, Israel’s domestic intelligence agency, was sacked yesterday, days after Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said he no longer trusts him, and fallout from a report on the Oct. 7, 2023, Hamas attack. “The Government unanimously approved Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s proposal to end ISA Director Ronen Bar’s term of office,” a statement said. He is to leave his post when his successor is appointed by April 10 at the latest, the statement said. Netanyahu on Sunday cited an “ongoing lack of trust” as the reason for moving to dismiss Bar, who joined the agency in 1993. Bar, meant to
Indonesia’s parliament yesterday amended a law to allow members of the military to hold more government roles, despite criticisms that it would expand the armed forces’ role in civilian affairs. The revision to the armed forces law, pushed mainly by Indonesian President Prabowo Subianto’s coalition, was aimed at expanding the military’s role beyond defense in a country long influenced by its armed forces. The amendment has sparked fears of a return to the era of former Indonesian president Suharto, who ex-general Prabowo once served and who used military figures to crack down on dissent. “Now it’s the time for us to ask the
The central Dutch city of Utrecht has installed a “fish doorbell” on a river lock that lets viewers of an online livestream alert authorities to fish being held up as they make their springtime migration to shallow spawning grounds. The idea is simple: An underwater camera at Utrecht’s Weerdsluis lock sends live footage to a Web site. When somebody watching the site sees a fish, they can click a button that sends a screenshot to organizers. When they see enough fish, they alert a water worker who opens the lock to let the fish swim through. Now in its fifth year, the
RSS