Over the objections of the US government, a federal appeals court on Friday reinstated some of the class-action claims of millions of people who accused roughly 50 American, Canadian and European companies of supporting apartheid in South Africa.
The US government has said the litigation would interfere with South Africa's reconciliation and redress efforts and would cause "significant tension between the US and South Africa." The South African government had said the cases interfered with its right to litigate such claims itself.
"Today's appeals court decision is a major victory," said Michael Hausfeld, a lawyer for the plaintiffs. "It enables victims of terrible human rights abuses to hold those who aided and abetted those abuses accountable."
Other lawyers on both sides of the dispute did not immediately return telephone messages for comment.
A lower court had tossed out the case, in part because of the vigorous objections by the US and its allies.
In its ruling Friday, the 2nd US Circuit Court of Appeals in Manhattan urged US District Judge John Sprizzo, who threw out the case in 2004, to consider prior rulings in deciding how much to let the US government's view of the case affect his decisions.
It directed him to note one case in particular. It said judges should not automatically dismiss every case that might negatively affect foreign relations "to avoid difficult and somewhat sensitive decisions in the context of human rights."
In a footnote, it added: "Indeed, to give dispositive weight to the executive branch's views would likely raise serious separation-of-powers concerns."
The claimants, people who have lived in South African after 1948, originally filed 10 separate actions in multiple federal courts. The cases were combined in New York.
The appeals court had heard arguments in January of last year. It reinstated claims brought under the Alien Tort Claims Act, an obscure 1789 law originally enacted to prosecute pirates.
The law has been used since 1980 by Holocaust survivors and relatives of people tortured or killed under despotic foreign regimes. Sprizzo had dismissed those claims, saying he did not have jurisdiction. The appeals court said he must analyze the subject further.
Sprizzo had said he must be "extremely cautious in permitting suits here based upon a corporation's doing business in countries with less than stellar human rights records, especially since the consequences of such an approach could have significant, if not disastrous, effects on international commerce."
Asian perspectives of the US have shifted from a country once perceived as a force of “moral legitimacy” to something akin to “a landlord seeking rent,” Singaporean Minister for Defence Ng Eng Hen (黃永宏) said on the sidelines of an international security meeting. Ng said in a round-table discussion at the Munich Security Conference in Germany that assumptions undertaken in the years after the end of World War II have fundamentally changed. One example is that from the time of former US president John F. Kennedy’s inaugural address more than 60 years ago, the image of the US was of a country
BLIND COST CUTTING: A DOGE push to lay off 2,000 energy department workers resulted in hundreds of staff at a nuclear security agency being fired — then ‘unfired’ US President Donald Trump’s administration has halted the firings of hundreds of federal employees who were tasked with working on the nation’s nuclear weapons programs, in an about-face that has left workers confused and experts cautioning that the Department of Government Efficiency’s (DOGE’s) blind cost cutting would put communities at risk. Three US officials who spoke to The Associated Press said up to 350 employees at the National Nuclear Security Administration (NNSA) were abruptly laid off late on Thursday, with some losing access to e-mail before they’d learned they were fired, only to try to enter their offices on Friday morning
Cook Islands officials yesterday said they had discussed seabed minerals research with China as the small Pacific island mulls deep-sea mining of its waters. The self-governing country of 17,000 people — a former colony of close partner New Zealand — has licensed three companies to explore the seabed for nodules rich in metals such as nickel and cobalt, which are used in electric vehicle (EV) batteries. Despite issuing the five-year exploration licenses in 2022, the Cook Islands government said it would not decide whether to harvest the potato-sized nodules until it has assessed environmental and other impacts. Cook Islands Prime Minister Mark Brown
STEADFAST DART: The six-week exercise, which involves about 10,000 troops from nine nations, focuses on rapid deployment scenarios and multidomain operations NATO is testing its ability to rapidly deploy across eastern Europe — without direct US assistance — as Washington shifts its approach toward European defense and the war in Ukraine. The six-week Steadfast Dart 2025 exercises across Bulgaria, Romania and Greece are taking place as Russia’s invasion of Ukraine approaches the three-year mark. They involve about 10,000 troops from nine nations and represent the largest NATO operation planned this year. The US absence from the exercises comes as European nations scramble to build greater military self-sufficiency over their concerns about the commitment of US President Donald Trump’s administration to common defense and