A US court on Monday halted the military trial of Osama bin Laden's personal driver, ruling it illegal in a major blow to the government's controversial handling of hundreds of war on terror detainees.
The US District Court in Washington DC suspended the military commission case against Salim Ahmed Hamdan, a 34-year-old Yemeni, being held at the US detention camp at Guantanamo Bay in Cuba.
PHOTO: AP
While rights groups celebrated, the stunned US government scrambled to prepare an emergency appeal after Judge James Robertson said Hamdan, an alleged al-Qaeda member, should be given prisoner-of-war status until a "competent tribunal" can rule on his case.
A review tribunal at Guantanamo has already declared that Hamdan was properly declared an "enemy combatant" and so ineligible for most protection under the Geneva Convention. But the judge rejected this.
"Unless and until a competent tribunal determines that Hamdan is not entitled to prisoner-of-war status, he may be tried with the offenses for which he is charged only by court-martial," Robertson said.
The judge also said rules that restrict defendants' access to classified evidence against them also had to be rewritten.
The Hamdan decision will also apply to the approximately 550 other inmates at Guantanamo and government lawyers were quick to vow an appeal saying the ruling put terrorism on the same level as a legitimate war.
"We vigorously disagree with the court's decision, and will seek an emergency stay of the ruling and immediately appeal," Justice Department spokesman Mark Corallo said in a statement.
"By conferring protected legal status under the Geneva Conventions on members of al-Qaeda, the judge has put terrorism on the same legal footing as legitimate methods of waging war," Corallo said.
The ruling came as a preliminary hearing against Hamdan went ahead at Guantanamo and officials said it and other cases had been immediately suspended.
Hamdan was captured in Afghanistan in late 2001, in the military operation launched after the Sept. 11, 2001 attacks. He has been held at Guantanamo since early 2002, for much of that time without access to a lawyer.
Hamdan's lawyers have sought to have the hearings ruled illegal in US courts, parallel to their defence before the commission.
The US military has said Hamdi is a member of al-Qaeda who was bin Laden's personal driver in Afghanistan. The Yemeni has denied being an al-Qaeda member.
He faces charges, including conspiracy to attack civilians and civilian targets and conspiracy to commit murder and terrorist acts.
Civil rights groups have condemned the military commissions because the panels are made up of military officers, many of whom have no judicial experience, and because defendants are excluded from hearings where classified evidence against them is raised.
"This is a clean victory," said Eugene Fidell, president of the National Institute of Military Justice, a non-government group. "He [Hamdan] is entitled to a full trial in a proper military court and it doesn't get any better than that."
"This ruling rightly demolishes the Bush Administration's argument that the Geneva Conventions did not universally apply to prisoners detained in Afghanistan," Amnesty International said in a statement.
"This ruling should put the final nail into the coffin of the military commissions," said Jamie Fellner, director of the US program at Human Rights Watch. "They should never have been created in the first place, and their implementation has been a disaster."
Military lawyers have argued that Guantanamo detainees should not get prisoner-of-war status under the Geneva Conventions because they are not fighting for a state but al-Qaeda.
"That argument is rejected," the judge said.
Hamdan has appeared before a Combatant Status Review Tribunal at Guantanamo, which ruled that he was an "enemy combatant". But the judge said the review tribunals were not valid because they were not established to assess a detainee's rights under the Geneva Conventions.
PHISHING: The con might appear convincing, as the scam e-mails can coincide with genuine messages from Apple saying you have run out of storage For a while you have been getting messages from Apple saying “your iCloud storage is full.” They say you have exceeded your storage plan, so documents are no longer being backed up, and photos you take are not being uploaded. You have been resisting Apple’s efforts to get you to pay a minimum of ￡0.99 (US$1.33) a month for more storage, but it seems that you cannot keep putting off the inevitable: You have received an e-mail which says your iCloud account has been blocked, and your photos and videos would be deleted very soon. To keep them you need
The Israeli military has demolished entire villages as part of its invasion of south Lebanon, rigging homes with explosives and razing them to the ground in massive remote detonations. The Guardian reviewed three videos posted by the Israeli military and on social media, which showed Israel carrying out mass detonations in the villages of Taybeh, Naqoura and Deir Seryan along the Israel-Lebanon border. Lebanese media has reported more mass detonations in other border villages, but satellite imagery was not readily available to verify these claims. The demolitions came after Israeli Minister of Defense Israel Katz called for the destruction of
A US YouTuber who caused outrage for filming himself kissing a statue commemorating Korean wartime sex slaves has been sentenced to six months in prison, a court in Seoul said yesterday. Johnny Somali, 25, gained notoriety several years ago for recording himself doing a series of provocative stunts in South Korea and Japan, and streaming them on platforms such as YouTube and Twitch. South Korean authorities indicted Somali — whose real name is Ramsey Khalid Ismael — in 2024 on public order violations and obstruction of business, and banned him from leaving the country. “The court has sentenced him to six months in
The death toll from a shooting in western Afghanistan rose to 11 on Saturday, after gunmen targeted civilians at a picnic spot in Herat, the provincial authority said. Bullet marks were visible on a wall of the Sayed Mohammad Agha Shia shrine, while bloodstains marked a blanket abandoned at the scene. “Eleven people have been recorded dead and eight others wounded from Friday’s incident, with the condition of two of the wounded reported as critical,” Herat’s information office said in a statement. The update raises a toll of seven killed provided on Friday by the Afghan Ministry of Interior Affairs
RSS