Bad attitude, rashness, bias and incompetence are the main issues with Taiwan’s so-called “dinosaur judges,” a nickname bestowed for their being out of touch with society, Judicial Reform Foundation chairman Lin Yung-sung (林永頌) said.
The most common problem with “dinosaur judges” is their attitude, Lin said, citing his years of observing court proceedings and dealing with appeals.
Some judges speak loudly or harshly, while others mock or make fun of trial participants, or fail to give them a chance to speak, he said.
Photo: Chang Jui-chen, Taipei Times
A judge in Taoyuan told a defendant, on penalty of jail time, not to speak unless giving a confession, he said.
Next is rashness, Lin said.
Rash judges are overconfident and believe that reading the case before court begins is unnecessary, he said, adding that people can tell that the judge did not prepare and has no knowledge of the case.
These judges delay the trial by not asking crucial questions, he added.
Another common problem is judicial bias, Lin said.
Judges should be objective, gradually forming an inner conviction about the case as each court session leads up to their deliberation, but some have preconceptions due to their environment, personal or religious beliefs, or external pressures, he said.
Biased judges often interrupt litigants after one or two sessions in court, or even refute their claims, he said, adding that these judges have already made up their minds before hearing the case.
Some judges are incompetent — they are simply incapable of reviewing cases, Lin said.
Incompetent judges are usually not harsh, rash, or biased, rather they tend to be hardworking, but misinterpret cases and are unable to render judgements, he said.
They cannot provide a clear rationale for decisions and are clearly unqualified, he added.
Judges mostly learn from more experienced colleagues or other members on their panel, he said, adding that they have few opportunities to observe other courts or broaden their horizons.
The Judicial Yuan, to identify and get rid of so-called “dinosaur judges,” should study the complaints filed by litigants, he added.
‘EFFECTIVE DETERRENCE’: If the Biden administration suspends arms sales to Taiwan, the military could still ready a nimble fighting force for defense, an analyst said The “US Strategic Framework for the Indo-Pacific” last week sparked debate among analysts after US President Donald Trump declassified the document 20 years ahead of schedule. Trump on Tuesday last week released the document that had governed US strategic action in the region since the US leader approved its use in 2018. The document, which outlines US priorities in the region, emphasizes the importance of defending Taiwan against military aggression and facilitating the country’s development of asymmetric strategies and capabilities. The overall directive of the document is for the US to prevent China from establishing sustained air and sea dominance inside the first
ALLEVIATING FEARS: The CECC would only announce public places where it is difficult to identify everyone there at the same time as the couple, minister Chen said The Central Epidemic Command Center (CECC) yesterday announced six places where two locally infected COVID-19 cases had visited between Thursday last week and Sunday, urging people who had been at the places at the same time to monitor their health. The couple, cases 838, a doctor, and 839, his nurse girlfriend, were reported by the center on Tuesday. The doctor had treated a patient with COVID-19 last week before he began suffering symptoms on Friday, while the nurse began suffering symptoms on Saturday. They work in the same hospital in northern Taiwan, but the nurse had not worked with COVID-19 patients, so
SECOND RULING: Israeli-American Oren Shlomo Mayer refused to sign a court transcript, complained about the court translator and said the trial had been unfair The High Court yesterday upheld New Taipei City District Court’s verdicts on four men convicted last year in connection with the 2018 murder and dismemberment of a Canadian citizen on the banks of the Sindian River (新店溪). It found American-Israeli Oren Shlomo Mayer and American Ewart Odane Bent guilty of homicide and the abandonment and destruction of a corpse, with Mayer sentenced to life in prison and Bent given a term of 12 years and six months, for the death of Sanjay Ryan Ramgahan, whose body parts were found in a riverside park under Zhongzheng Bridge in New Taipei’s Yonghe
A lawyer and a prosecutor yesterday castigated what they called a lenient ruling by the High Court on Luo Wen-shan (羅文山), whose prison sentence was reduced to two years, which he does not need to serve, after he was convicted for receiving illegal political donations from China to meddle in Taiwan’s elections. Investigators found that Luo, who retired from the army with the rank of lieutenant general, had accepted NT$8.38 million (US$294,604 at the current exchange rate) under the guise of political contributions from Chinese People’s Political Consultative Conference member Xu Zhiming (許智明) and people in Hong Kong from 2008 to
RSS