The Taiwan Jury Association yesterday called for mechanisms to remove unsuitable judges and suggested that Taiwan emulate the US, where citizens elect some judges.
“Judicial elections” in the US, where voters decide, are a good way to eliminate corrupt judges and would complement the judiciary’s Judge Evaluation System, introduced in 2012 after the promulgation of the Judges Act (法官法), association chairman Chang Ching (張靜) said.
Putting the two systems into practice could oust justices that some have called “dinosaur judges,” who have issued rulings that did not meet the public’s expectations and have been perceived as handing out lenient sentences for murder and other serious crimes, Chang said.
Electing judges leads to term limits and allows the public to remove judges who have a record of misconduct, transgressions or dereliction of duty, said Chang, a former judge and former attorney.
“The problem is that since the Judges Act was promulgated, it has become more difficult punish or remove unsuitable judges,” he said.
“Since 2012, we have seen no reduction in the number of dinosaur judges, corrupt judges or justices who cater to the whims of the government and politicians,” Chang added.
He and other association members cited the recently upheld 16-year sentence for former Taiwan High Court judge Hu Ching-pin (胡景彬), who took NT$46 million (US$1.5 million at the current exchange rate) in bribes and was found to be living a lavish lifestyle, with three wives and owning numerous properties.
They also pointed to the recent impeachment of High Court judges Chu Liang (朱樑), who was allegedly found to have consorted with prostitutes, and Tseng Mou-kuei (曾謀貴), who accepted bribes in connection with a case that he was presiding over.
“The average age in the US for first-time judges is 45, and in the UK, it is 47. In Taiwan, the first-time judges are 25 to 27 years old,” Chang said. “So Taiwan’s younger judges lag behind the UK and US, lacking 20 years of work experience in society and experience dealing with people.”
Requirements in the US are different from those in Taiwan: Students in the US graduate from law school at age 25, then they need to pass the bar examination to practice law and only after working as lawyers for at least 10 years are they eligible to stand in elections to become a judge,” Chang said.
The US introduced judicial elections in the early 20th century as it saw a need to have truly independent judges, attorney Jerry Cheng (鄭文龍) said, adding that the system weeded out unsuitable or corrupt judges.
“Over more than 100 years of practice, the US has found that elected judges reflect the prevailing views and standards of the public much better,” Cheng said.
“A judge’s authority comes from the people, but in Taiwan, we see that some judges feel superior, behave arrogantly and show disdain for other people,” he added.
Thirty-five earthquakes have exceeded 5.5 on the Richter scale so far this year, the most in 14 years, the Central Weather Administration (CWA) said on Facebook on Thursday. A large earthquake in Hualien County on April 3 released five times as much the energy as the 921 Earthquake on Sept. 21, 1999, the agency said in its latest earthquake report for this year. Hualien County has had the most national earthquake alerts so far this year at 64, with Yilan County second with 23 and Changhua County third with nine, the agency said. The April 3 earthquake was what caused the increase in
INTIMIDATION: In addition to the likely military drills near Taiwan, China has also been waging a disinformation campaign to sow division between Taiwan and the US Beijing is poised to encircle Taiwan proper in military exercise “Joint Sword-2024C,” starting today or tomorrow, as President William Lai (賴清德) returns from his visit to diplomatic allies in the Pacific, a national security official said yesterday. Commenting on condition of anonymity, the official said that multiple intelligence sources showed that China is “highly likely” to launch new drills around Taiwan. Although the drills’ scale is unknown, there is little doubt that they are part of the military activities China initiated before Lai’s departure, they said. Beijing at the same time is conducting information warfare by fanning skepticism of the US and
DEFENSE: This month’s shipment of 38 modern M1A2T tanks would begin to replace the US-made M60A3 and indigenous CM11 tanks, whose designs date to the 1980s The M1A2T tanks that Taiwan expects to take delivery of later this month are to spark a “qualitative leap” in the operational capabilities of the nation’s armored forces, a retired general told the Liberty Times (sister paper of the Taipei Times) in an interview published yesterday. On Tuesday, the army in a statement said it anticipates receiving the first batch of 38 M1A2T Abrams main battle tanks from the US, out of 108 tanks ordered, in the coming weeks. The M1 Abrams main battle tank is a generation ahead of the Taiwanese army’s US-made M60A3 and indigenously developed CM11 tanks, which have
Chinese President Xi Jinping (習近平) is unlikely to attempt an invasion of Taiwan during US president-elect Donald Trump’s time in office, Taiwanese and foreign academics said on Friday. Trump is set to begin his second term early next year. Xi’s ambition to establish China as a “true world power” has intensified over the years, but he would not initiate an invasion of Taiwan “in the near future,” as his top priority is to maintain the regime and his power, not unification, Tokyo Woman’s Christian University distinguished visiting professor and contemporary Chinese politics expert Akio Takahara said. Takahara made the comment at a
RSS