Former minister of transportation and communications Kuo Yao-chi’s (郭瑤琪) conviction on corruption charges epitomized the judicial system’s “decadent, primitive and barbaric” nature, academics told a symposium in Taipei yesterday.
Kuo’s conviction on Dec. 5 was a perfect example of how helpless Taiwanese are before the law and illustrated how every encounter citizens have with the judiciary is similar to a game of Russian roulette because their fate is determined by pure luck, the academics said at the forum on Taiwan’s judiciary, which was organized by the Taiwan Association of University Professors.
The Supreme Court sentenced Kuo to eight years in prison after the Taiwan High Court overturned previous acquittals to find her guilty of receiving a US$20,000 bribe from service industry conglomerate the Nan Ren Hu Group in 2006, while she was supervising a development project as transportation minister.
The sentence violates the rules of evidence and of experience with insufficient investigation, said Hsu Hui-feng (許惠峰), a law professor at the Chinese Culture University.
Not only was the alleged US$20,000 in bribery money never found, but the conglomerate did not end up tendering a bid, Hsu said, adding that there was also perjury in the case.
“I have no idea how the court could determine it was a corruption with so many flaws in the case,” the professor said.
Hsu said that the validity of convictions in Taiwan — in particular in corruption cases — has always been questioned since 34 of the 56 appealed corruption cases handled by the Taiwan High Court last year ended up with reduced penalties.
The figure means that 64 percent of the rulings handed down by the High Court and district courts were inconsistent, Hsu added.
Lin Iong-sheng (林雍昇), a researcher at the Taiwan Brain Trust thinktank, said that — along with a slew of other cases involving pan-green camp politicians, including that of former president Chen Shui-bian (陳水扁) — Kuo’s trial showed that prosecutors and judges “still employ illegal and dirty tricks, among them pretrial detention and subornation of perjury, to do whatever they want.”
It is ironic that the nation’s television viewers are obsessed with the US crime drama series CSI and amazed by the scientific criminal investigations it portrays, yet have to endure so many unjust trials in real life, Lin said.
With countries like Japan beginning to work on reforming their judiciaries toward a jury system, Wu Ching-chin (吳景欽), an associate law professor at Aletheia University, urged Taiwan to immediately engage in a similar reforms.
“The judicial system in Taiwan is now on the edge of a cliff. It is a do-or-die situation for us. After all, people’s lives, freedom and integrity are at stake,” Wu said.
CLEAR BEFORE LEAVING: Two baby boys and a woman in her 30s tested negative before departing for Japan, but tests taken after their arrival came back postive Three Taiwanese tested positive for COVID-19 when they arrived in Japan earlier this month, the Central Epidemic Command Center (CECC) said yesterday as it reported a new imported case. Minister of Health and Welfare Chen Shih-chung (陳時中), head of the center, said that one of the three cases in Japan is a Taiwanese baby under the age of one, whose parents work in Japan. The infant came to Taiwan with his parents in January, and the parents paid for the family’s COVID-19 tests on Oct. 10 ahead of their planned return to Japan on Monday last week, he said. The boy and his
‘BACKED BY ENEMY’: CTi News is one of the few channels promoting unification, the New Party chairman said, while pro-Taiwan groups called it a propaganda outlet Pan-blue camp supporters yesterday lodged a protest at the National Communications Commission (NCC) against what they say is a possible move by the government to shut down CTi News, adding that politics should not interfere with freedom of the press. Protesters included representatives from the New Party, the Blue Sky Action Alliance, the 333 Political Party Alliance and other pan-blue groups. “We stand here today because CTi News is one of the few media outlets in Taiwan that is still willing to give groups supporting unification with China a voice. If the news channel is gone, there would only be
NEW YEAR’S EVE: Examples from South Korea and Japan show that 15 local COVID-19 infections could emerge in a short period if measures are not taken The Taipei City Government would cancel its New Year’s Eve Party and all large events if 15 or more confirmed cases of COVID-19 are reported in the city within a week, Taipei Mayor Ko Wen-je (柯文哲) said yesterday. Addressing the Taipei Cross Border E-Commerce Annual Convention, Ko said the COVID-19 pandemic has brought many uncertainties to society, and that e-commerce is on a path of no return and would continue to grow. Many countries have not effectively controlled their COVID-19 outbreaks, and although Taiwan implements strict border controls and there have been few inbound passengers, the pandemic is unlikely to end soon,
The Democratic Progressive Party (DPP) yesterday accused CTi News of trying to mislead the public by publishing a half-page advert claiming that the party interfered in the National Communications Commission’s (NCC) review of its application for a license renewal. CTi News is distorting the commission’s review process by painting it as a political conflict and turning it into a smear campaign against the DPP, party spokeswoman Yen Juo-fang (顏若芳) said. “The NCC is an independent body, which carries out reviews and makes decisions based on its members’ professional expertise, as well as regulations and legal requirements governing media operations,” Yen said. “We condemn