A new 80-page report on US arms sales to Taiwan recommends a changed “status quo” with cutbacks on all sides.
Prepared by the EastWest Institute think tank, Threading the Needle is aimed at influencing the policies of both Washington and Beijing.
It has received early praise from such luminaries as former US secretary of state George Shultz and former US national security advisor General James Jones.
Shultz called the report “bold and pathbreaking,” while Jones said it advances the idea that it is possible to adhere to existing US law and policy, respect China’s legitimate concerns and “stand up appropriately for Taiwan — all at the same time.”
The major recommendation is that the US should calibrate arms deliveries to Taiwan in a way that the total dollar amount provided in any given year does not exceed the inflation-adjusted peak level of the 1979-to-1982 period.
This would mean unilaterally setting a voluntary annual cap on US arms deliveries to Taiwan of US$941 million in inflation-
adjusted 2012 dollars, the report says.
By way of return, the report recommends that China should “unilaterally, voluntarily and verifiably” cut its missile force facing Taiwan.
The report says Beijing should maintain all missiles in garrison, redeploy one of the current five short-range ballistic missile brigades under the People’s Liberation Army’s 52nd Base further inland and out of range of Taiwan, and dismantle the physical infrastructure of that brigade.
In addition, the report says that China should increase the transparency of its missile deployments facing Taiwan by periodically publishing key developments and numbers in authoritative government white papers.
“The US should continue to sell defensive arms to Taiwan for the foreseeable future, within the constraints of existing US law and policy,” the report says.
It also recommends that the US should unbundle future Taiwan arms sales notifications to Congress and instead submit notifications on a “regular, predictable and normalized schedule.”
“The US should signal its continued unwavering commitment to preserving and promoting
extensive, close and friendly commercial, cultural and other relations with Taiwan, including by enhancing senior-level exchanges with Taiwan,” the report says.
Written by the EastWest Institute’s China, East Asia and US Program director Piin-Fen Kok and institute vice president David Firestein, the report says that the next two-and-a-half years present a “unique but small” political window for relations between the US and China.
“The timing is ripe for a renewed discussion on how the US and China can manage their differences over this historically contentious issue,” the report says. “The Taiwan arms sales issue is fundamentally a political issue rather than a military, diplomatic, foreign-policy or economic one.”
A better “status quo” is achievable, the report says, adding: “As long as mainland China’s political and social systems differ from Taiwan’s to the stark degree they currently do, US arms sales to Taiwan will continue.”
“Though there are ways to decrease tensions associated with arms sales there is no ultimate ‘solution’ that is independent of a resolution of the core issue of differing political and social systems,” it says.
SELF-RELIANCE: Taiwan would struggle to receive aid in the event of an invasion, so it must prepare to ‘hold its own’ for the first 70 days of a war, a defense expert said Taiwan should strengthen infrastructure, stock up on reserves and step up efforts to encourage Taiwanese to fight against an enemy, legislators and experts said on Tuesday last week. The comments sought to summarize what the nation should learn from the Russian invasion of Ukraine, which has exceeded 300 days, since Feb. 24 last year. Institute of National Defense and Security Research fellow Su Tzu-yun (蘇紫雲) said that the war in Ukraine highlighted the importance of being ready for war. Taiwan’s development of an “asymmetrical warfare” doctrine and extending mandatory conscription to one year is a good start to preparation of defense against a
The Tourism Bureau plans to offer incentives to attract international tourists as the nation plans to gradually lift all travel restrictions to contain COVID-19, Minister of Transportation and Communications Wang Kwo-tsai (王國材) said yesterday. The incentives would be funded by surplus national tax revenue from last year, Wang said. The funding could be appropriated after the legislature passes draft special statutes governing the use of the surplus tax revenue in the upcoming legislative session, he said. Of the NT$450 billion (US$14.97 billion) in surplus tax revenue, the government plans to spend NT$100 billion on seven categories of projects to bolster Taiwan’s
The Central Epidemic Command Center yesterday said it would delay the lifting of the indoor mask mandate, citing public health considerations and ongoing discussions on how the policy should be implemented. Earlier this week, Centers for Disease Control Deputy Director-General Chuang Jen-hsiang (莊人祥), who is the CECC’s spokesman, said officials from several ministries were working on the policy and an announcement would be made yesterday. However, Deputy Minister of Health and Welfare Victor Wang (王必勝), who heads the CECC, yesterday said that the policy was still under review. Wang said its implementation would be “delayed slightly” due to three main factors. First, the center
Retired US admiral Philip Davidson, who in 2021 warned of a potential Chinese conflict with Taiwan by 2027, is in Taiwan to discuss regional security-related issues. He was the head of the US Indo-Pacific Command at the time. Davidson is part of a six-member delegation from US-based think tank the National Bureau of Asian Research that arrived in Taiwan on Monday, the Ministry of Foreign Affairs (MOFA) said yesterday. The group is scheduled to meet with President Tsai Ing-wen (蔡英文), and visit two government-funded non-governmental organizations — the Institute for National Defense and Security Research and Taiwan Foundation for Democracy — to exchange