A US academic has warned the administration of US President Barack Obama not to sell F-16C/D aircraft to Taiwan, in case China reacts in an unpredictable and extraordinary way.
“Don’t sell F-16s to Taiwan — not now, anyway,” George Washington University professor Robert Sutter said.
“This is not a good time. If you push you might get an extraordinary reaction not bound by international norms,” he told the 41st Taiwan-US Conference on Contemporary China in Washington.
Asked later by the Taipei Times just how he thought China might react to a sale of the fighters — Taipei has been trying to buy 66 of them for many years now — Sutter said he did not know and could not speculate about it.
“That’s the thing — we don’t know,” he said.
Sutter caused something of a flap at the Carnegie Endowment conference with his controversial paper and statement over the fighter jets.
Senior associate in the Carnegie Asia program Michael Swaine — acting as moderator of the panel on which Sutter spoke — went out of his way to disagree with Sutter’s conclusions about Chinese foreign policy.
Swaine said he did not share Sutter’s sentiments and that China’s recent behavior was understandable.
Sutter argued that Beijing’s reaction to the Philippines and developments around the Scarborough Shoal (Huangyan Island, 黃岩島), and to Japan over the Diaoyutai Islands (釣魚台), was unexpected and unpredictable.
However, Swaine said the Chinese would argue that both the Philippines and Japan had changed the rules governing the contested areas and that Beijing thought these changes were “unjust and unfair.”
He said China did not like the changes and was determined to show that it was not going to accept them.
“The context makes a difference,” he said.
Sutter said he found the mix of assertiveness and peace and development in Chinese foreign policy to be “perplexing.”
“Looking at the past and what they actually do, can be more helpful than interpreting their statements of what they might do,” Sutter said.
“This makes me cautious right now because I am a little concerned about the rounds of assertiveness,” he said.
Sutter said the goals of Chinese foreign relations were clear, but that they conflicted with each other.
The strategy on one hand is peace and development, but at the same time they have “core interests that conflict with this peace and development.”
“The result is that you have constant tension in Chinese foreign policy. In the past this tension has been pretty well managed, but over the last four or five years, with the ascendance of assertiveness, you have an era of uncertainty. What will the Chinese do?” he said.
Sutter said that China was using extralegal measures to “intimidate and enforce” its position with the Philippines and Japan, while still talking about peace and development.
“Countries in the region are intimidated, they are not going to take chances,” he said.
Sutter then raised the potential sale of F-16C/Ds to Taiwan — a sale that China strongly protests and objects to.
“I would tell the Americans to be careful in this part of the world, because if you do something, you might just set the Chinese off,” he said.
“The implications of this are that we cannot really assume that the peaceful approach is going to continue,” Sutter said.
The professor concluded that recent Chinese behavior showed that the direction of Chinese foreign policy on sensitive issues and security could change sharply toward assertiveness.
He said the circumstances causing the change were hard to predict and could involve “widespread violence well beyond the scope of accepted international behavior.”
Sutter said those most at risk were the countries in nearby Asia with salient differences with China over sovereignty and security issues.
“The absence of strong adverse foreign reactions to China’s assertiveness and the presence of broad domestic Chinese support for such actions strongly suggests more assertive Chinese approaches regarding security and sovereignty issues in the future,” he said.
The Taipei City Government yesterday officially launched the “YouBike 2.0” system, an upgraded version of the bicycle rental service, saying that it aims to expand the service to more than 1,200 stations throughout the city. The system yesterday activated 160 new stations, in addition to 103 stations in the Gongguan (公館) shopping area near the National Taiwan University campus. A trial run of YouBike2.0 was launched there in January last year. The Taipei Department of Transportation said that bicycles of the upgraded system feature solar panels and card censors, which allow users to rent them by swiping their EasyCard or scanning a QR
‘COLD ATTITUDE’: The man claimed that his wife of nearly 50 years had not cooked or done any laundry for 40 years and that she refused to bathe A court last month rejected a man’s application for a divorce over lack of evidence that his wife “would rather feed stray dogs” than her husband. The 90-year-old man, surnamed Chao (趙), filed for divorce from his wife of nearly 50 years, surnamed Tung (董), saying that she had not cooked or done any laundry for 40 years. “Every morning my wife goes to Gaoping Bridge to feed stray dogs and does not come home until late,” Chao said. “I am 90 and I need to be taken care of,” he said, complaining of his wife’s “cold attitude” toward him. Chao also complained in
QUARANTINE BLUNDER: The government should be responsible for a cluster infection at a hotel, as the cases have caused panic, DPP Legislator Chen Ming-wen said The Ministry of Transportation and Communications should make it mandatory for pilots and flight attendants, as well as their family members, to be vaccinated in view of a cluster of COVID-19 cases at the Novotel Taipei Taoyuan International Airport hotel, lawmakers said at a meeting of the legislature’s Transportation Committee yesterday. The cluster infection at the hotel had led to 28 confirmed COVID-19 cases as of Tuesday, including hotel workers, as well as China Airlines flight and cabin crew, and their family members. The Central Epidemic Command Center (CECC) yesterday tightened quarantine requirements for pilots and flight attendants, who must quarantine
DATA-DRIVEN: The dedicated department used big data to find sexual harassment hot spots on the Mass Rapid Transit system to take measures against perpetrators Most incidents of sexual harassment and secret photography in Taipei’s MRT metropolitan railway system over the past five years occurred at three stations, the Rapid Transit Division of the Taipei City Police Department said in a statement yesterday. Most incidents were recorded at Zhongxiao-Fuxing MRT Station, followed by Taipei Main and Zhongxiao-Dunhua MRT stations, the department said, adding that the results were obtained through big data analysis. The system, which serves Taipei and New Taipei City, handles about 2.2 million passengers per day, and most cases of secret photography and sexual harassment — usually involving touching a victims buttocks or chest