Labor rights activists and business leaders with experience working in China agree that signing a trade agreement between Taiwan and China would speed up capital outflow from the nation, but their opinions differ on solving Taiwan’s unemployment problem.
A proposed economic cooperation framework agreement (ECFA) with China “would speed up outflow of domestic capital and the exodus of businesses and it will not solve the unemployment problem,” Victims of Investment in China Association (VICA) president William Kao (高為邦) said.
The core problem of the nation’s shrinking economy is that Taiwanese businesses have lost their competitive edge on the global stage and that will not be solved by signing an ECFA, Kao argued, saying that Taiwanese business leaders had no choice but to move to China or other countries with cheaper labor.
Moreover, Kao said, China is not trustworthy and many Taiwanese have been stripped of their property and assets in China by the Chinese government, which has used “every method imaginable.”
Kao himself is an example.
A group of unidentified men looted his Chinese factory in 1999. After asking the Chinese government for help to no avail for two years, he left China in 2001.
The government claims signing an ECFA will create 260,000 jobs, although the opposition says there could be as many as 890,000 jobs lost after it is signed, he said.
“The real answer is probably something in between,” Kao said.
With 600,000 people out of work, unemployment is the most serious issue in the nation, he said. Unless the government removes the minimum wage requirement for foreign workers, there will not be a solution to the unemployment problem, Kao said.
“A problematic foreign labor policy enacted in 1992 is the root cause of all these problems,” he said.
If the minimum wage of foreign workers was lowered and businesses were allowed to hire as many as 60 percent foreign workers, companies would be willing to move back to Taiwan, given China’s inconsistent policies, investment environment and worsening social order, Kao said.
“That would create more jobs for local workers,” he said.
“I agree that the ECFA will not solve the unemployment problem, but I find it hard to agree with Kao’s theory,” Taiwan Labor Front secretary-general Sun Yu-lien (孫友聯) said.
An ECFA is basically a free-trade agreement that would only benefit specific sectors or companies, while most small and medium-sized businesses would suffer, Sun said.
“The only thing left in Taiwan would be lower-level service sector companies operating solely for domestic demand, just like what happened in Hong Kong after it signed its Closer Economic Partnership Arrangement [CEPA] with China,” he said.
Sun said Kao’s theory has been brought up by legislators previously, but it had not been implemented by the previous administration or the KMT government.
“It’s obviously not in line with mainstream opinion,” he said.
Sun expressed opposition to the theory because it does not respect labor rights, a universal value, and is against Taiwan’s labor policy that regards foreign labor as a “supplementary” workforce.
“If we agree with the principle of ‘equal pay for equal work’ ... if we agree that men and women should receive the same pay for the same work, then why should foreign workers be different?” Sun asked.
If the minimum wage for foreign workers was lower than that for domestic workers, Sun said it would lead to lower overall payment levels eventually because employers would rather hire cheaper foreign workers than domestic workers.
‘JOINT SWORD’: Whatever President Lai says in his Double Ten speech, China would use it as a pretext to launch ‘punishment’ drills for his ‘separatist’ views, an official said China is likely to launch military drills this week near Taiwan, using President William Lai’s (賴清德) upcoming national day speech as a pretext to pressure the nation to accept its sovereignty claims, Taiwanese officials said. China in May launched “punishment” drills around Taiwan shortly after Lai’s inauguration, in what Beijing said was a response to “separatist acts,” sending heavily armed warplanes and staging mock attacks as state media denounced newly inaugurated Lai. The May drills were dubbed “Joint Sword — 2024A” and drew concerns from capitals, including Washington. Lai is to deliver a key speech on Thursday in front of the Presidential Office
An aviation jacket patch showing a Formosan black bear punching Winnie the Pooh has become popular overseas, including at an aviation festival held by the Japan Air Self-Defense Force at the Ashiya Airbase yesterday. The patch was designed last year by Taiwanese designer Hsu Fu-yu (徐福佑), who said that it was inspired by Taiwan’s countermeasures against frequent Chinese military aircraft incursions. The badge shows a Formosan black bear holding a Republic of China flag as it punches Winnie the Pooh — a reference to Chinese President Xi Jinping (習近平) — who is dressed in red and is holding a honey pot with
Taiwan was listed in 14th place among the world's wealthiest country in terms of GDP per capita, in the latest rankings released on Monday by Forbes magazine. Taiwan's GDP per capita was US$76,860, which put it at No. 14 on the list of the World's 100 Richest Countries this year, one spot above Hong Kong with US$75,130. The magazine's list of the richest countries in the world is compiled based on GDP per capita data, as estimated by the IMF. However, for a more precise measure of a nation's wealth, the magazine also considers purchasing power parity, which is a metric used to
NINTH MONTH: There were 11,792 births in Taiwan last month and 15,563 deaths, or a mortality rate of 8.11 per 1,000 people, household registration data showed Taiwan’s population was 23,404,138 as of last month, down 2,470 from August, the ninth consecutive month this year that the nation has reported a drop, the Ministry of the Interior said on Wednesday. The population last month was 162 fewer than the same month last year, a decline of 0.44 per day, the ministry said, citing household registration data. Taiwan reported 11,792 births last month, or 3.7 births per day, up 149 from August, it said, adding that the monthly birthrate was 6.15 per 1,000 people. The jurisdictions with the highest birthrates were Yunlin County at 14.62 per 1,000 people, Penghu County (8.61
RSS