Several legal experts yesterday called on the Council of Agriculture (COA) to withdraw the proposed farming community recovery bill from legislative review, saying it may be unconstitutional and violates human rights.
The bill, submitted to the legislature last year by the Executive Yuan and passed during an initial review in December, aims to “revive and create prosperous farming communities.”
However, some lawyers have expressed doubt that the bill could accomplish its goals and consider some of its clauses unconstitutional.
“The farming community recovery bill has nothing to do with reviving farming communities — it’s purely a land development project,” said Lee Chung-hsi (李崇僖), law professor at Chungyuan Christian University.
“It also seeks legalization of acts befitting gangsters, such as taking farmland away from individual farmers for development,” Lee said, adding that it went against the right to property protected by the Constitution.
Lee said the bill deals with the redevelopment of farmland, the construction of recreational facilities, such as bicycle lanes, and beautifying farming villages. A clause in the bill states that a redevelopment project may be executed in an area as long 60 percent of people who own land in that area agree to it, even if the owners of the other 40 percent object to it. Another clause says that if the government finds a building in a farming village too ugly, it can order the owner to improve it. If the owner doesn’t follow the order within a specified time limit, the government can renovate the structure without the owner’s consent and then ask the owner to pay for it.
“Who is to define what’s ‘ugly’ and what’s ‘beautiful?’ How can the government ‘improve’ the appearance of a privately owned house and ask the owner to pay for it?” asked Tsai Ya-ying (蔡雅瑩), a lawyer affiliated with the Wild at Heart Legal Defense Association. “This is a violation of human rights.”
“Not everyone has the money to pay when the government demands it,” said Thomas Chan (詹順貴), another lawyer. “So I guess this is what would happen: People would have their houses repaired involuntarily by the government, they have no money to pay for it, so the government seizes the property and puts it up for auction.”
“How scandalous would it be if you lost your home because the government thinks it looks ugly?” Chan asked.
Chan went on to say that the bill provides neither a platform for farmers to voice their opinions before a development project starts, nor a channel to file their complaints.
“The COA should just take it [the bill] back,” Chan said.
When asked for comment, COA Minister Chen Wu-hsiung (陳武雄) did not address the questions raised by the legal experts, but stressed that the bill would benefit farmers and promised that the council would offer more in-depth elaboration on the bill at a legislative public hearing to be held today.
A total lunar eclipse coinciding with the Lantern Festival on March 3 would be Taiwan’s most notable celestial event this year, the Taipei Astronomical Museum said, urging skywatchers not to miss it. There would be four eclipses worldwide this year — two solar eclipses and two lunar eclipses — the museum’s Web site says. Taiwan would be able to observe one of the lunar eclipses in its entirety on March 3. The eclipse would be visible as the moon rises at 5:50pm, already partly shaded by the Earth’s shadow, the museum said. It would peak at about 7:30pm, when the moon would
Taiwan’s Li Yu-hsiang performs in the men’s singles figure skating short program at the Milano-Cortina Winter Olympics, in Milan, Italy, on Tuesday. Li finished 24th with a score of 72.41 to advance to Saturday’s free skate portion of the event. He is the first Taiwanese to qualify for the free skate of men’s singles figure skating at the Olympics since David Liu in 1992.
The Coast Guard Administration (CGA) yesterday held a ceremony marking the delivery of its 11th Anping-class offshore patrol vessel Lanyu (蘭嶼艦), saying it would boost Taiwan’s ability to respond to Beijing’s “gray zone” tactics. Ocean Affairs Council Deputy Minister Chang Chung-Lung (張忠龍) presided over the CGA event in the Port of Kaoshiung. Representatives of the National Security Council also attended the event. Designed for long-range and protracted patrol operations at sea, the Lanyu is a 65.4m-long and 14.8m-wide ship with a top speed of 44 knots (81.5kph) and a cruising range of 2,000 nautical miles (3704km). The vessel is equipped with a
A KFC branch in Kaohsiung may be fined between NT$60,000 and NT$200 million (US$1,907 and US$6.37 million), after a customer yesterday found an entire AAA battery inside an egg tart, the Kaohsiung Department of Health said today. The customer was about to microwave a box of egg tarts they had bought at the fast-food restaurant’s Nanzih (楠梓) branch when they checked the bottom and saw a dark shadow inside one of them, they said in a Threads post. The customer filmed themself taking the egg tart apart to reveal an entire AAA battery inside, which apparently showed signs of damage. Surveillance footage showed
RSS