When local nongovernmental organizations teamed up to create an alliance against capital punishment five years ago, the implementation of the death penalty in Taiwan was still very secretive.
“At the beginning, it was very difficult for us even to find out how many people were on death row,” Taiwan Alliance to End the Death Penalty (TAEDP) director Lin Hsin-yi (林欣怡) said in an interview with the Taipei Times.
“The little information we were able to obtain came from our own efforts. We found information from newspapers and made a list,” Lin said.
PHOTO COURTESY OF TAEDP
This method of gathering statistics is more reminiscent of authoritarian countries that do not release such information — not democracies — Lin said.
It took a few years, but eventually “the government became willing [to confirm our figures],” Lin said.
The alliance is celebrating five years of campaigning and research that has paid off in this and other ways. Today, it will hold a vigil in Taipei to mark the progress made — and the work that still has to be done to reach its ultimate goal.
But when Jinan Church lights up on Zhongshan S Road tonight, it will also be one of hundreds of buildings worldwide to honor Tuscany on Cities for Life Day, 222 years after the Italian region became the first in Europe to abolish capital punishment.
In Taiwan, which may seem like it is on the road to scrapping the death penalty, abolition is still a far way off, said the TAEDP, which sees Cities for Life Day as an opportunity to raise public awareness.
The government first spoke out against the death penalty in 2000, when former president Chen Shui-bian (陳水扁) took office.
Eight years later, legislators are no closer to removing capital punishment from the books.
But things aren’t as bleak as they appear, Lin said.
From another perspective, the death penalty is in a state of limbo, with no executions having taken place in the past three years — despite the fact that 31 prisoners are awaiting execution, while an estimated 100 ongoing court cases could result in such rulings.
The TAEDP and its member organizations — including the Legal Aid Foundation and the Judicial Reform Foundation — have pieced together a picture of the death penalty system in Taiwan, examining court cases and unearthing problems with the judicial process.
But there are still many blanks to fill, many questions left unanswered, Lin said.
The TAEDP wants the government to release demographic statistics, for example, that would help determine whether the death penalty is used disproportionately against the poor and uneducated, as has been observed in other countries.
“The Ministry of Justice must show enough information to the public — not only how many people or who they are. Maybe they should tell us more: We want to know what kind of people are more frequently sentenced to death,” Lin said.
The vigil scheduled for tonight follows upon a series of activities organized by civic groups and the representative offices of three European countries to discuss obstacles to abolishing the death penalty.
Earlier this month, the French Institute in Taipei, the German Institute in Taipei and the British Trade and Cultural Office organized forums that brought together legal experts from their countries and Taiwan.
“If a person condemned to death is innocent, all of society ... is collectively guilty,” French Institute in Taipei Director Patrick Bonneville told a seminar on Nov. 3 organized by the Taiwan Law Society, National Taipei University and the European Economic and Trade Office.
As the current president of the EU Council, France hopes to encourage discussion in countries that retain the death penalty about the punishment’s incompatibility with human rights.
On Nov. 6 and Nov. 7, German experts and the TAEDP organized a forum on victims’ rights and public safety.
The following week, British and local specialists met to discuss human rights education for legal workers.
Part of the goal was to examine the hurdles to winning over public opinion.
“When we lobby, before we used to just say: ‘Abolish the death penalty,’” Lin said.
“Now we believe, if we really want to open a dialogue with society, we must understand their viewpoint. Of course they are concerned about public safety. We want to talk about these points and show them our alternative can be acceptable too,” Lin said.
“That’s why our topic at the forum was public safety and victims’ rights,” Lin said.
Since Tuscany’s pioneering decision in 1786, most countries have abolished the death penalty in law or in practice and only a handful of governments are responsible for the vast majority of executions each year.
Secretary-general of the French National Consultative Commission for Human Rights Michel Forst believes that trend will continue and total abolition will be achieved.
Anti-death penalty activists “are confident,” Forst said in an interview, “that this century will be the century of abolition.”
The TAEDP hopes so, but Lin knows it will take a lot more work.
To that end, the alliance will continue researching the death penalty system and educating legal workers, the public and legislators.
The latter is of particular importance, because only the legislature can make capital punishment a thing of the past.
“We need time to educate lawmakers,” Lin said. “In the end, they decide. [But many] do not have correct information about the death penalty, so there is a lot to do.”
Johanne Liou (劉喬安), a Taiwanese woman who shot to unwanted fame during the Sunflower movement protests in 2014, was arrested in Boston last month amid US President Donald Trump’s crackdown on illegal immigrants, the Criminal Investigation Bureau (CIB) said yesterday. The arrest of Liou was first made public on the official Web site of US Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) on Tuesday. ICE said Liou was apprehended for overstaying her visa. The Boston Field Office’s Enforcement and Removal Operations (ERO) had arrested Liou, a “fugitive, criminal alien wanted for embezzlement, fraud and drug crimes in Taiwan,” ICE said. Liou was taken into custody
The US-Japan joint statement released on Friday not mentioning the “one China” policy might be a sign that US President Donald Trump intends to decouple US-China relations from Taiwan, a Taiwanese academic said. Following Trump’s meeting with Japanese Prime Minister Shigeru Ishiba on Friday, the US and Japan issued a joint statement where they reaffirmed the importance of peace and stability in the Taiwan Strait and support for Taiwan’s meaningful participation in international organizations. Trump has not personally brought up the “one China” policy in more than a year, National Taiwan University Department of Political Science Associate Professor Chen Shih-min (陳世民)
‘NEVER!’ Taiwan FactCheck Center said it had only received donations from the Open Society Foundations, which supports nonprofits that promote democratic values Taiwan FactCheck Center (TFC) has never received any donation from the US Agency for International Development (USAID), a cofounder of the organization wrote on his Facebook page on Sunday. The Taipei-based organization was established in 2018 by Taiwan Media Watch Foundation and the Association of Quality Journalism to monitor and verify news and information accuracy. It was officially registered as a foundation in 2021. National Chung Cheng University communications professor Lo Shih-hung (羅世宏), a cofounder and chairman of TFC, was responding to online rumors that the TFC receives funding from the US government’s humanitarian assistance agency via the Open Society Foundations (OSF),
ANNUAL LIGHT SHOW: The lanterns are exhibited near Taoyuan’s high-speed rail station and around the Taoyuan Sports Park Station of the airport MRT line More than 400 lanterns are to be on display at the annual Taiwan Lantern Festival, which officially starts in Taoyuan today. The city is hosting the festival for the second time — the first time was in 2016. The Tourism Administration held a rehearsal of the festival last night. Chunghwa Telecom donated the main lantern of the festival to the Taoyuan City Government. The lanterns are exhibited in two main areas: near the high-speed rail (HSR) station in Taoyuan, which is at the A18 station of the Taoyuan Airport MRT, and around the Taoyuan Sports Park Station of the MRT