The composition of the new legislature, with the opposition pan-blue camp seizing a three-quarter majority, is unlikely to result in the Democratic Progressive Party (DPP) government transferring the right to form a Cabinet to the Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT), political analysts said yesterday.
Premier Chang Chun-hsiung (
The Cabinet by tradition resigns after the election of a new legislature.
The practice is generally considered a formality as the Cabinet will be nothing more than a "caretaker Cabinet" prior to the May 20 inauguration of a new president following the presidential election in March.
A suggestion, however, had emerged that the power to form a Cabinet should be relinquished to the KMT, which won 81 of 113 seats in the new legislature.
Allen Houng (洪裕宏), convener of the Constitutional Reform Alliance, said that the majority party forming a Cabinet is not consistent with the principles of the Constitution.
Despite the ambiguity in defining whether the government system is of a presidential or parliamentary design, it is not formed under semi-presidential rules such as it is in France, in which the executive is split between an elected president and a premier contingent on a majority in the legislature, he said.
After the 1997 round of constitutional revisions, Taiwan adopted a semi-presidential system, and some argued that it mirrored the French framework.
But it is also flagged as a non-genuine semi-presidential system because of a lack of some mechanisms available in the French system.
As the president enjoys the power to appoint the premier directly without legislative authorization, it is more like the presidential system, Houng said.
If the majority in the legislature forms the Cabinet without simultaneously giving the president the power to dissolve the legislature, the president would become a titular head, incompatible with a quasi-presidential system and public expectations, he added.
The president is empowered by the Constitution to dissolve the legislature, but he can do so only after the legislature has passed a no-confidence vote against the premier.
"That is just power on paper because in reality the legislature, in fear of dissolution and the cost of re-election, is unlikely to initiate any vote of no-confidence in the premier," Houng said.
Fu Hung-der (
The Constitution per se is not based on a presidential system, where a majority-formed Cabinet should not be an issue of dispute, Fu said.
"Rather, the Constitution should be read as either a semi-presidential model or a parliamentary one, in a manner of speaking, or otherwise the president would not have to appoint a premier who is authorized to form a Cabinet," Fu said.
In view of the huge KMT legislative majority, it is just "a matter of time" until the DPP has to surrender the right to form a Cabinet, Fu said, adding: "If not now, the power must still be given to the KMT after May 20 even if DPP presidential candidate Frank Hsieh (
Looking at the issue in practice and not in line with constitutional theory, analysts said a majority-formed Cabinet would not result when the new legislature convenes on Feb.1.
Lee Yeau-tarn (
"The KMT would rather get itself through the presidential election just the way it is now than form a Cabinet in case that becomes an unpredictable factor influencing the election," Lee said.
KMT presidential candidate Ma Ying-jeou (馬英九) yesterday rejected the possibility of his party forming a Cabinet ahead of the presidential election, following his previous remarks that it would not recall the president, topple the Cabinet, or amend the Constitution.
Lee said it would be "irresponsible" for the DPP to relinquish the power to form a Cabinet prior to the March election because that would create political instability.
"If Hsieh were elected, he has no choice but to form a coalition Cabinet with the KMT. But if the DPP relinquished that power now, Hsieh has no chance of winning the election," Houng said.
After the KMT's victory, there could be a "pendulum effect" as the DPP hopes, with Hsieh urging the public to give the DPP another chance in the presidential election, as it is important to voters to have checks and balances of power, Houng said.
"How could Hsieh convince the public of his checks and balances argument if the DPP gave up the power to form a Cabinet. Once the power is given to the KMT, it would become a constitutional convention that is needed to be abided by after May 20. Voters would think they don't need to bother voting for Hsieh if the KMT would dominate the Cabinet anyway," Houng said.
An alleged US government plan to encourage Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Co (TSMC) to form a joint venture with Intel to boost US chipmaking would place the Taiwanese foundry giant in a more disadvantageous position than proposed tariffs on imported chips, a semiconductor expert said yesterday. If TSMC forms a joint venture with its US rival, it faces the risk of technology outflow, said Liu Pei-chen (劉佩真), a researcher at the Taiwan Industry Economics Database of the Taiwan Institute of Economic Research. A report by international financial services firm Baird said that Asia semiconductor supply chain talks suggest that the US government would
Starlux Airlines on Tuesday announced it is to launch new direct flights from Taiwan Taoyuan International Airport to Ontario, California, on June 2. The carrier said it plans to deploy the new-generation Airbus A350 on the Taipei-Ontario route. The Airbus A350 features a total of 306 seats, including four in first class, 26 in business class, 36 in premium economy and 240 in economy. According to Starlux’s initial schedule, four flights would run between Taoyuan and Ontario per week: Monday, Wednesday, Friday and Saturday. Flights are to depart from Taoyuan at 8:05pm and arrive in California at 5:05pm (local time), while return flights
WANG RELEASED: A police investigation showed that an organized crime group allegedly taught their clients how to pretend to be sick during medical exams Actor Darren Wang (王大陸) and 11 others were released on bail yesterday, after being questioned for allegedly dodging compulsory military service or forging documents to help others avoid serving. Wang, 33, was catapulted into stardom for his role in the coming-of-age film Our Times (我的少女時代). Lately, he has been focusing on developing his entertainment career in China. The New Taipei District Prosecutors’ Office last month began investigating an organized crime group that is allegedly helping men dodge compulsory military service using falsified documents. Police in New Taipei City Yonghe Precinct at the end of last month arrested the main suspect,
Nearly 800 Indian tourists are to arrive this week on an incentive tour organized by Indian company Asian Painted Ltd, making it the largest tour group from the South Asian nation to visit since the COVID-19 pandemic. The travelers are scheduled to arrive in six batches from Sunday to Feb. 25 for five-day tours, the Tourism Administration said yesterday. The tour would take the travelers, most of whom are visiting Taiwan for the first time, to several tourist sites in Taipei and Yilan County, including tea houses in Taipei’s Maokong (貓空), Dadaocheng (大稻埕) and Ximending (西門町) areas. They would also visit