The low turnouts for the two referendums yesterday suggested that a majority of Taiwanese still lack autonomy in terms of political participation, a political commentator said.
Neither the Democratic Progressive Party's (DPP) referendum on recovering the Chinese Nationalist Party's (KMT) stolen assets nor the KMT-proposed referendum on giving the legislature investigative power met with success yesterday as both proposals suffered the same fate as their predecessor in 2004.
The total number of registered voters was 17,277,720, according to the Central Election Commission yesterday.
PHOTO: GEORGE TSORNG, TAIPEI TIMES
Votes in both referendums failed to pass the legal threshold -- 50 percent of the nation's total eligible voters, or 8.63 million voters --- for their outcome to be considered valid.
Compared to President Chen Shui-bian's (陳水扁) referendum in 2004 on increasing the nation's purchase of anti-missile weaponry in the face of China's ballistic missile threat and another referendum on negotiations with China on the establishment of a peace and stability framework, there was a sharp decrease in the turnout for the referendums yesterday.
The nation's first two referendums back in 2004 attracted 45.17 percent and 45.11 percent of the total electorate of 16,507,179 while the DPP's KMT assets plebiscite yesterday only managed to engage 26.34 percent of the electorate in the poll.
Only 26.08 percent of voters chose to take part in the KMT's referendum -- the first one it had ever initiated.
This means only 4,550,881 voters cast their ballots in the DPP's poll, while 4,505,927 voters cast ballots for the KMT's proposal.
However, both referendums garnered a significant number of affirmative votes, with 3,891,170 voters supporting the DPP's proposal while 2,304,136 voted in favor of the KMT's proposal.
According to the Referendum Law (公投法), no similar proposals to the two referendums can be initiated within three years given their failure to pass the legal turnout threshold.
Political analysts said several factors may have contributed to the failure of the two referendums.
"The outcome of the referendums is not important. It is the turnout's impact on Taiwan's democracy that really matters," said political analyst Allen Houng (洪裕宏).
"In terms of [Taiwan's] democratic growth, it matters whether over half of the eligible voters collected their referendum ballots," he said.
Voters had failed to understand their ability to exercise their rights directly through referendums, he said.
The low turnout sent a message to the international community that "Taiwanese democracy remains in its infancy," he said.
"International observers may think that Taiwanese people do not regard the KMT's stolen assets as a problem and they may be very confused as to why people would not treat anti-corruption as an important issue," he said.
There was much work to do to ensure that people were independent of the influence of party politics, he said.
"We have the form of democracy but we do not have enough quality," Houng said.
Raymond Wu (吳瑞國), an associate professor at the College of Law at Fu-jen Catholic University, said that the turnout showed the KMT's boycott campaign of the referendums had been effective.
He was referring to the call issued by KMT Chairman Wu Poh-hsiung (
Lo Chih-cheng (羅致政), a political science professor at Soochow University, held similar views, saying that the the KMT's boycott and a similar campaign by six minor parties scuppered the chances of the two referendums.
Houng attributed the low participation in the DPP-initiated referendum to voter apathy.
"Voters generally had a lukewarm response to the issue [KMT's stolen assets]. Over the years, voters have tended to regard the issue as [DPP] campaign talk. Plus, the DPP has made no breakthrough on the recovery of the assets over the past eight years," he said.
He added that the low turnout suggested some voters do not think the recovery of the KMT's stolen assets directly influences their livelihood.
As for the low participation in the KMT's referendum, Houng said it was because the party had not whole-heartedly pushed it to begin with.
The low participation in the two referendums also signified a certain number of independent voters who were discouraged by the perennial wrangling between the pan-blue and the pan-green camps, he said.
Lo told the Taipei Times that although the DPP-proposed referendum had failed, the number of affirmative votes the proposal received should serve as a warning to the KMT ahead of the upcoming presidential election in March.
"In a competitive race, any vote can make a difference. The KMT can choose to ignore these [affirmative] ballots, but the DPP will certainly not let go of the issue," Lo said.
Twenty-four Republican members of the US House of Representatives yesterday introduced a concurrent resolution calling on the US government to abolish the “one China” policy and restore formal diplomatic relations with Taiwan. Led by US representatives Tom Tiffany and Scott Perry, the resolution calls for not only re-establishing formal relations, but also urges the US Trade Representative to negotiate a free-trade agreement (FTA) with Taiwan and for US officials to advocate for Taiwan’s full membership in the UN and other international organizations. In a news release announcing the resolution, Tiffany, who represents a Wisconsin district, called the “one China” policy “outdated, counterproductive
Actress Barbie Hsu (徐熙媛) has “returned home” to Taiwan, and there are no plans to hold a funeral for the TV star who died in Japan from influenza- induced pneumonia, her family said in a statement Wednesday night. The statement was released after local media outlets reported that Barbie Hsu’s ashes were brought back Taiwan on board a private jet, which arrived at Taipei Songshan Airport around 3 p.m. on Wednesday. To the reporters waiting at the airport, the statement issued by the family read “[we] appreciate friends working in the media for waiting in the cold weather.” “She has safely returned home.
ON PAROLE: The 73-year-old suspect has a criminal record of rape committed when he was serving in the military, as well as robbery and theft, police said The Kaohsiung District Court yesterday approved the detention of a 73-year-old man for allegedly murdering three women. The suspect, surnamed Chang (張), was arrested on Wednesday evening in connection with the death of a 71-year-old woman surnamed Chao (趙). The Kaohsiung City Police Department yesterday also unveiled the identities of two other possible victims in the serial killing case, a 75-year-old woman surnamed Huang (黃), the suspect’s sister-in-law, and a 75-year-old woman surnamed Chang (張), who is not related to the suspect. The case came to light when Chao disappeared after taking the suspect back to his residence on Sunday. Police, upon reviewing CCTV
Johanne Liou (劉喬安), a Taiwanese woman who shot to unwanted fame during the Sunflower movement protests in 2014, was arrested in Boston last month amid US President Donald Trump’s crackdown on illegal immigrants, the Criminal Investigation Bureau (CIB) said yesterday. The arrest of Liou was first made public on the official Web site of US Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) on Tuesday. ICE said Liou was apprehended for overstaying her visa. The Boston Field Office’s Enforcement and Removal Operations (ERO) had arrested Liou, a “fugitive, criminal alien wanted for embezzlement, fraud and drug crimes in Taiwan,” ICE said. Liou was taken into custody