South Africa cricket coach Mickey Arthur has become the latest prominent figure in the sport to express reservations about the Hawk-Eye technology that is now being used to check leg-before-wicket decisions.
“I’m not 100 percent convinced about the predictive element of Hawk-Eye and I don’t think many players are either,” Arthur wrote in next month’s issue of Wisden Cricketer.
Hawk-Eye uses data produced by video cameras to predict whether a ball that has hit the batsman on the pads would have gone on to hit the stumps, the “lbw” decision that can be among the most contentious in cricket. The technology is used in tennis to decide disputed line calls.
Under the Umpire Decision Review System implemented in the recent four-match series between South Africa and England and in six Tests in Australia, a third umpire uses Hawk-Eye to help decide whether the on-field official has made a correct decision in the event of an appeal from either side.
The case against Hawk-Eye was put by former Australia fast bowler Dennis Lillee, who said: “There’s no way Hawk-Eye can tell if a delivery is going to skid a bit more than normal or hit a crack, or a damp or worn patch, or a bit of grass on the wicket.”
It is a case that is robustly rejected by Paul Hawkins, the inventor of Hawk-Eye and a former player with the English minor county Buckinghamshire who graduated from Durham University with a doctorate in artificial intelligence.
“Dennis Lillee’s accuracy as a bowler is far greater than the accuracy of his journalism,” Hawkins said in a telephone interview. “He has no understanding of the technology. He has got no idea what he is talking about.”
Hawkins said Hawk-Eye calculated the trajectory of a ball after it had bounced and hit the batsman’s pad, based purely on the behavior of that particular ball.
“You only need about a foot [30cm] to travel and you get an accurate prediction of the line, you need a little bit more to predict the height,” he said. “If there is very little distance between pitching point and hitting the batsman, that is the hardest time to make an accurate prediction. That’s exactly the same for an umpire. We don’t measure before the ball is bowled, we measure what has happened on that ball.”
Hawkins said the umpires in each of the 10 Tests in which Hawk-Eye had been used to help determine lbw decisions believed each decision had been correct.
“We have now 10 Test matches and most of the referrals have been lbws,” he said. “We have certainly got every single one right.”
ADVANTAGE ATLETICO: Well off the pace in La Liga, the Copa del Rey represents Atletico Madrid’s best chance of silverware this season Atletico Madrid on Thursday hammered Copa del Rey holders Barcelona 4-0 in the first leg of their semi-final. After an Eric Garcia own-goal sent Diego Simeone’s side ahead early on, Antoine Griezmann, Ademola Lookman and Julian Alvarez struck to give Atletico a landslide lead by halftime. Barca defender Garcia was sent off in the final stages, with Atletico maintaining their significant advantage on the record 32-time winners, which they take into the second leg at the Camp Nou on March 3. Both sides missed good chances in the second half, with Barca’s Pau Cubarsi having a goal disallowed before Garcia was sent off
‘EVERYONE SAW’: The visitors were left fuming after Jules Kounde was fouled by Claudio Echeverri in the buildup to the winning goal and it went unpunished Spanish champions Barcelona on Monday fell to a damaging 2-1 defeat at Girona to leave them trailing Real Madrid by two points at the top of La Liga. Los Blancos beat Real Sociedad on Saturday to overtake the Catalans and Hansi Flick’s side could not defeat Girona in an gripping derby clash to reclaim the lead. Teenage star Lamine Yamal missed a penalty for Barcelona, who took the lead through defender Pau Cubarsi just before the hour mark. However, goals from Thomas Lemar and Fran Beltran helped Girona, 12th, mount an impressive comeback. “In the end Girona deserved it, they had a lot of
Stade Rennais, four days after firing coach Habib Beye, stunned Paris Saint-Germain 3-1 on Friday, snapping the defending champions’ seven-match winning run in French Ligue 1. Second-placed RC Lens could leapfrog the champions and retake top spot last night after press time if they beat Paris FC in the capital. PSG started brightly, with Ousmane Dembele and Desire Doue carving openings to no avail. Rennes fired Beye on Monday and promoted his assistant Sebastien Tambouret, and the same players who had lost four games on the bounce seemed transformed. Jordanian forward Mousa al-Tamari bagged the opener, unleashing a fierce strike
Dasun Shanaka hammered the fastest half-century by a Sri Lankan in T20Is as the cohosts thrashed Oman by 105 runs at the World Cup yesterday in Pallekele, Sri Lanka, for their second win in Group B. The 2014 champions piled up 225-5, the highest total of the tournament, before restricting an outclassed Oman to 120-9. The 43-year-old Mohammad Nadeem waged a lone battle for Oman, compiling an unbeaten 53 to become the oldest player to score a 50 in T20 World Cups. Having promoted himself up the order and under pressure to deliver, Sri Lanka skipper Shanaka smashed a 19-ball half-century. It has been
RSS