Over the next month, thousands of high school and college football teams will get ready for fall by practicing in torrid conditions where heatstroke is a constant danger.
That has some trainers and doctors worried about increasingly popular thermometers that, in their view, sacrifice accuracy for convenience.
The devices use infrared light to scan heat radiation in the ear or on the forehead.
The infrared thermometers have produced lower readings in athletic settings -- or in lab tests meant to simulate them -- than rectal thermometers or other devices.
Forehead scanner
After testing a forehead scanner that is made by Exergen, researchers with the Institute for Exercise and Environmental Medicine at Presbyterian Hospital in Dallas, Texas, warned that low readings from the device could deprive patients of critical, perhaps lifesaving medical care.
In the test in the journal Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise, the infrared thermometer gave readings below 37.8oC when rectal thermometers topped 40oC, a temperature at which some patients begin to become vulnerable to heatstroke.
Douglas Casa, the director of athletic training education at the University of Connecticut who completed a study of 10 types of thermometers used in intense training situations, said the infrared forehead and ear scanners were among those producing misleadingly low readings in his test.
Similar conclusions
And William Roberts, a University of Minnesota researcher and former president of the American College of Sports Medicine, said his tests of the forehead device on runners in the Medtronic Twin Cities Marathon led him to similar conclusions.
Both have submitted their results to peer-reviewed journals.
Exergen said that it was apparent from the report on the Texas test, which used healthy subjects in heated wet suits, that the researchers did not duplicate realistic conditions for athletes.
Exergen also said that the thermometer, the Temporal Scanner, was not marketed for use in athletic settings and came with instructions specifically stating that it was not for outdoor use.
That goes for both the consumer version, which costs US$30 to US$50 at drugstores and other chains, and a more durable model sold for about US$350 to doctors' offices and hospitals, it said.
Boston Marathon
The company Web site includes a 2005 news release noting that its thermometers had been used for 17 years at the Boston Marathon.
But Francesco Pompei, the company president, said the release made it clear that the device had required special handling at the marathon.
The changes, including use of a piece of film to deal with perspiration, have been shared with a small number of trainers who sought more information for their own studies, Pompei said.
"We use sports medicine for research," he said. "But we are not selling into the athletic market."
He added that the association with the Boston Marathon, which began in 1989, ended last year with the retirement of Marvin Adler, longtime medical director of the race.
Something simpler
Critics said the device might attract coaches looking for something simpler than rectal thermometers and less costly than the most accurate devices available outside of hospitals -- radio-transmitting temperature-sensing pills that athletes swallow.
Pompei said his company would be glad to work with critics to discourage using the Temporal Scanner in athletic settings.
But a broader battle may loom.
Benjamin Levine, a physician who took part in the Dallas test, said the scanner should not be used in any setting, even though 30 percent of Texas hospitals now use it or a similar device.
Novation, a hospital purchasing group, said its members bought more than US$1 million worth of them last year and had not heard any complaints.
Santiago Castro on Tuesday had an immediate impact off the bench as he scored the goal to send Bologna into the Coppa Italia semi-finals for the first time in 26 years. Bologna won 1-0 against last year’s runners-up, Atalanta BC, and are to play either holders Juventus or Empoli in the final four. Juventus are to host Empoli in their quarter-final on Feb. 26. The last time Bologna reached the semi-finals was in 1999, when they lost 4-2 to ACF Fiorentina. There were chances for both sides in a high-tempo match in Bergamo, but it was Bologna who broke the deadlock 10 minutes from
The former interpreter for baseball star Shohei Ohtani on Thursday was sentenced to nearly five years in prison for bank and tax fraud after he stole nearly US$17 million from the Los Angeles Dodgers player’s bank account. Ippei Mizuhara, who was supposed to bridge the gap between the Japanese athlete and his English-speaking teammates and fans, was sentenced in federal court in Santa Ana to four years and nine months after pleading guilty last year. He was ordered to pay US$18 million in restitution, with nearly US$17 million going to Ohtani and the remainder to the US Internal Revenue Service. He was
The 40-year-old LeBron James on Thursday became the oldest player to score 40 points in an NBA game, putting up a season-high 42 in the Los Angeles Lakers’ 120-112 victory over the Golden State Warriors. James passed the record held by Michael Jordan, his idol and the only other NBA player to score 40 after his 40th birthday. “I’m old, that’s my take,” James said when asked about his latest achievement. “I need a glass of wine and some sleep, that’s what I think.” Jordan did it for the Washington Wizards just three days after turning 40 in February 2003. James is 38
SPEEDSKATER: Her bronze medal ended Taiwan’s run at the Asian Winter Games without a medal since the nation first participated in the second iteration in 1990 Speedskater Chen Ying-chu yesterday made history as the first athlete representing Taiwan to secure a medal at the Asian Winter Games. Competing at the HIC Speedskating Oval in Harbin, China, Chen clocked 10.510 seconds in the women’s 100m event, finishing third behind South Koreans Lee Na-hyum and Kim Min-sun, who posted times of 10.501 and 10.505 seconds respectively. Her bronze medal ended Taiwan’s drought at the Asian Winter Games since the nation first participated in the second iteration in 1990. This year’s Games mark Chen’s debut at the event. Previously excelling in roller speedskating, she won six medals at world championships before transitioning