Politics and money can determine sporting success at the Asian Games, and the world's other major sporting events, as much as athletic prowess.
Understanding this helps make sense of what appears to be odd results, allegedly unfair judging at events and purported corruption within the governing bodies of the world's sports federations.
The Olympic ideal of fair play is just that, an ideal. The reality is the Fairytale Theory of Sports.
This states that international sporting competitions are firstly an expression of sublimated territoriality and aggression, which means instead of fighting wars to prove dominance countries do battle on the playing field.
Athletes and fans are the foot soldiers of an invading army, dressed in their nation's colors, aiming to vanquish their rivals. Politicians will identify their administration with sporting success if they can and most people assume they too are superior if athletes of their race take home gold.
Secondly, sport is big business. In addition to income from gate receipts, there are TV rights to sell and spin-off merchandizing. Sports pays the wages of millions of athletes, officials and workers in peripheral industries -- such as sneaker manufacturers and the media.
Countries or cities no longer hold major sporting for prestige alone. Events such as the Olympic Games and World Cup are opportunities to print money. They also have "invisible" benefits in terms of advertising. Who knew where Busan was before it hosted the Asian Games?
All of which brings us to the fairytale. For sporting success is a dream come true, not just for an athlete but for those who support them.
To make it all work, sports events must have the edge of genuine competition. If there is no effort or we know the results are determined in advance, then there is no interest and the house of cards falls. For example, Taiwan's baseball industry collapsed because match fixing was exposed in the mid-1990s and is only now recovering.
If the major powers did not get their proportion of medals at the Games then we would suspect the competition was rigged because we assume the strong will beat the weak.
Hence, we are not surprised when the US tops the Olympic gold medal table or China heads the Asian Games standings. For these two powers this is a sign of their superiority that they do so. Equally, for a smaller country to beat the majors is proof of that nation's vigor and a source of pride.
If the same countries always won, then there would be no interest from the other participating nations and their sports industries would wane. Holding the World Cup in Asia and South Korea coming fourth has undoubtedly strengthened soccer in the region.
A delicate balance must be achieved. Encourage the weak to become strong, ensure the strong are not too dominant. Give a medal here to stimulate a nation's sporting industry, take one from there because it already has enough.
Taekwondo is an example of a sport that has been given International Olympic Committee (IOC) approval because it redresses the sporting imbalance that has favored the US and European countries. The draw and officiating in taekwondo and boxing undoubtedly favored the host country at this Asian Games.
A host country must be soothed with gold and perhaps this explains "home advantage."
It is hoped that wushu will become an Olympic event in time for the Beijing Games in 2006, so China will stand a chance of winning more gold medals than in Sydney or Athens. This may explain why China did not win as many medals in wushu at this Asian Games as it could have. By giving the medals to other, weaker countries, it makes its case for inclusion in the Olympics stronger.
Softball on the other hand, which is dominated by the US, may be scrapped. Though it would appear natural selection is at work, the IOC attempts to balance the number of medals won by countries round the world.
Somehow, the right result must be achieved and this is why the outcome of some events are fairytales: they are too good to be true.
In reality, video analysis could make all sports fair. But then there could be no tinkering with results. FIFA President Sepp Blatter famously said at the start of the recent World Cup that video replays would be shown at all matches because openness was next to Godliness. He then decided against showing them, saying it could cause trouble on the terraces.
Any bets on Qatar -- with a population of under 300,000 -- not winning a gold medal at the 2006 Asian Games in Doha? It would be a dream come true if it does.
ANFIELD BLUES: Kylian Mbappe arrived at Anfield on a run of 21 goals in 17 games, but he managed just three attempts in the match, none of them hitting the target Kylian Mbappe has been nearly unstoppable this season, but he hit a roadblock in their UEFA Champions League match at Anfield on Tuesday. For the second year running, the Real Madrid forward had a night to forget at Merseyside as Liverpool won 1-0. Mbappe looked a shadow of the player who has been tearing defenses apart all season. “We were lacking that threat in the final third,” said Madrid coach Xabi Alonso, without naming Mbappe individually. The FIFA World Cup winner for France rarely looked capable of finding a breakthrough against a Liverpool team who have been so defensively fragile for much of the
LOCAL SUCCESS: In the doubles, Taiwan’s Hsieh Su-wei and Jelena Ostapenko of Latvia defeated Italians Sara Errani and Jasmine Paolini in straight sets Elena Rybakina on Monday punched her ticket to the WTA Finals last four with an impressive 3-6, 6-1, 6-0 victory over second seed Iga Swiatek in round-robin play in Riyadh. After cruising past Amanda Anisimova in her opener on Saturday, Rybakina claimed her second win of the week to guarantee herself top spot in the Serena Williams Group. Anisimova on Monday rallied back from a set and a break down to triumph 4-6, 6-3, 6-2 in her all-American battle with seventh seed Madison Keys, who has been eliminated from the competition. “Madi was playing so well, it was quite a battle out there,”
Erling Haaland on Sunday scored twice to propel Manchester City up to second in the English Premier League with a 3-1 win over AFC Bournemouth. The Cherries started the day in second thanks to the longest unbeaten run in the English top flight, but Andoni Iraola’s side were undone by the scintillating form of the Norwegian striker, who took his tally to 13 Premier League goals in 10 games. Haaland’s relentless streak is maintaining City’s title challenge as they reduced the gap to leaders Arsenal back to six points and edged one point ahead of Liverpool, who they face at the weekend. “Important
For almost 30 minutes, Vitomir Maricic did not take a breath. Face down in a pool, surrounded by anxious onlookers, the Croatian freediver fought spasming pain to redefine what doctors thought was possible. When he finally surfaced, he had smashed the previous Guinness World Record for the longest breath-hold underwater by nearly five minutes. However, even with the help of pure oxygen before the attempt, it had pushed him to the limit. “Everything was difficult, just overwhelming,” Maricic, 40, told reporters, reflecting on the record-breaking day on June 14. “When I dive, I completely disconnect from everything, as if I’m not even there.
RSS