Asylum seekers flown from Nauru to Taiwan for medical treatment have complained to lawyers that language barriers meant they were unable to give informed consent even when the overall quality of care was good.
Australia last year signed a memorandum of understanding with Taiwan to provide medical treatment for asylum seekers detained on Nauru, in an effort to prevent people indefinitely detained on the island from applying for a medical transfer to Australia.
The agreement was last month disclosed by a Taiwanese lawmaker in a letter to the Guardian, following a report about an Iranian woman and her son who were transferred to Taiwan so she could undergo life-saving heart surgery, and confirmed by the Australian government overnight.
The woman, known only as Fatemah, had told reporters that her 17-year-old son also required medical treatment for severe mental illness caused by his time in detention, but did not receive treatment before the pair were returned to Nauru.
Taiwanese authorities said he was not listed as a patient on the medical transfer form.
Taiwan is not a signatory to the 1951 Refugee Convention, meaning that refugees cannot apply for asylum to prevent them from being returned to Nauru.
Human rights lawyer George Newhouse, from the National Justice Project, said that while Taiwan’s medical system is world-class, language barriers between detainees and medical staff, which often required the use of two interpreters, meant that some asylum seekers felt they had not been able to give informed consent.
An Australian federal court this month ruled that hospitals in Taiwan also did not have the expertise to perform an abortion on a woman held on Nauru who had undergone female genital mutilation, and ordered that she be brought to Australia for treatment at one of two specialist clinics at the Royal Women’s hospital in Melbourne or at Sydney’s Westmead Hospital.
“They are not equipped to deal with mental health issues, cases where female genital mutilation is involved, and the language difficulties make obtaining informed consent extremely difficult,” Newhouse told reporters.
“Many asylum seekers complain that they didn’t understand the procedures that are to take place and are frightened of what might happen to them. There’s also no proper medical follow-up when they return to Manus and Nauru,” he said.
At least 330 refugees and asylum seekers, including 36 children, remain in detention on Nauru and have been told by the Australian government that they would not have any opportunity to settle in Australia or New Zealand.
Australia has previously allowed seriously ill detainees to be brought to the country for medical treatment, often after being forced to do so by a court order.
Newhouse said the agreement with Taiwan aimed to circumvent that process.
“The primary objective is to avoid bringing the asylum seekers to Australia at all costs, even if it results in harm to the individual,” he said.
A spokeswoman for the Australian Department of Home Affairs said the agreement was part of Australian Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull’s administration’s commitment that asylum seekers held in offshore detention would not gain entry to Australia.
“The government has been clear that people subject to regional processing arrangements will not be settled in Australia,” she said. “Medical transfer is not a pathway to settlement in Australia.”
Taiwan has a global reputation for high-quality medical care and is consistently ranked as having some of the best hospitals and medical technology in the world, the department said.
TAIPEI REACTIONS: Joanne Ou decried China’s ‘gangster diplomacy,’ while MOFA said its Fiji counterpart dealt fairly with the incident and protected the trade office’s rights The world should denounce the actions of Chinese embassy staffers in Fiji against a Taiwanese diplomat during a National Day celebration in Suva, the Ministry of Foreign Affairs (MOFA) said yesterday as it thanked the Fijian government for its help after the Oct. 8 incident. Two Chinese diplomats tried to force their way into a celebration held by the Taipei Trade Office in Fiji at the Grand Pacific Hotel in Suva on Oct. 8, and a Taiwanese diplomat who tried to stop them taking photographs suffered a head injury. MOFA spokeswoman Joanne Ou (歐江安) told a news briefing that the ministry
The US, Japan and Australia conducted trilateral naval exercises in the South China Sea on Monday, the US Seventh Fleet announced yesterday. It was their fifth joint operations this year in the fleet’s area of operations, it said in a statement. The Arleigh Burke-class guided-missile destroyer USS John S. McCain joined the JS Kirisame of the Japan Maritime Self Defense Force and the Royal Australian Navy’s HMAS Arunta. The Arunta’s commanding officer, Commander Troy Duggan, said that Australia was continuing to build on its already close relationship with Japan and the US. “This activity is a valuable and important opportunity for all three nations,”
ONGOING PROBE: A former Military Intelligence Bureau colonel, major general and another colonel, as well as five other people, have been questioned by prosecutors The Taipei District Court yesterday ordered that a retired colonel from the Military Intelligence Bureau (MIB) calling himself Taiwan’s “first special agent” be detained and held incommunicado as part of an ongoing investigation into espionage allegations targeting at least three former bureau officials. The Taipei District Prosecutors’ Office was seeking to detain former MIB colonel Chang Chao-jan (張超然) over his alleged involvement in introducing retired agents to Chinese national security authorities and passing confidential documents to China. Chang’s actions, if proven, would contravene the National Security Act (國家安全法), which carries a prison term of three to 10 years, and the National Intelligence
Seabed waste off the west coast is 1.5 times higher than the global average, with the mouth of the Tamsui River (淡水河) nearly 90 times dirtier, the environmental consultancy IndigoWaters (澄洋環境顧問) said yesterday. The firm in September last year began collaborating with local oceanographers on Taiwan’s first survey of seabed waste off the west coast, collecting 6,000 samples from near the mouths of eight rivers and conducting 215 inspections. Of the samples, 83.3 percent were found to contain trash, the group said. Based on the survey, every square kilometer of seabed had about 121,074 pieces of trash weighing 102kg, IndigoWaters chief executive Yen