The Changhua District Court ignored expert opinion when it acquitted former Ting Hsin International Group (頂新集團) executive Wei Ying-chun (魏應充) and other defendants in an adulterated cooking oil case, academics said yesterday at an inauguration ceremony for the “National Anti-Coprophagia Alliance” (全民拒吃大便聯盟).
Participants led by Taiwan Financial and Criminal Law Research Association president Chen Chih-lung (陳志龍) stood in solidarity, wearing badges featuring pictures of excrement and holding signs opposing Ting Hsin’s “shit oil” and telling the firm to “swallow your own shit.”
Wei and other company officials were acquitted of the charges of passing off imported adulterated animal-feed grade oil as fit for human consumption on the grounds that prosecutors failed to prove the existence of unsanitary manufacturing processes or that fat had been sourced from unhealthy animals.
Photo: Liao Chen-huei, Taipei Times
The Changhua County Prosecutors’ Office has stated that it would appeal the decision.
Chen — a professor of law at National Taiwan University — accused the court of playing logical “hide and seek,” failing to apply the required legal tests.
He said the court’s decision focused on the question of whether it could be demonstrated that the adulterated oils were inedible, rather than whether the corporation had demonstrated an intention to deceive consumers, as required by fraud charges.
The court’s decision also violated the Code of Criminal Procedure (刑事訴訟法) for weighing evidence by ignoring expert opinion and common sense, he said, adding that the complicated process by which Ting Hsin refined the imported oils was sufficient to demonstrate an intention to deceive.
“The defendants’ statement that all oils are refined is flat wrong. Good oils are not refined — only bad oils,” Chen said, adding that the court reached its conclusion that Ting Hsin’s oil “was not necessarily inedible” because it ignored expert opinion about oil processing.
“How can we tell the defendants knew that they were using cheap materials? All we have to do is look at their processing, because it is common knowledge that food oils are fresh oils and normal processing involves pressing the original product and then isolating it to prevent decay — it is a very simple process,” he said.
By contrast, Ting Hsin refined the oil using processes typical for non-food-grade industrial, diesel and feed oils, Chen said, adding the deodorization, deacidization, bleaching and recoloration of the oil demonstrated that the company had sought to “pass off” an inferior product to consumers.
Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Co (TSMC, 台積電), the world’s biggest contract chipmaker, yesterday held an equipment installation ceremony for its first 2-nanometer fab in Kaohsiung, six months ahead of schedule, Kaohsiung Mayor Chen Chi-mai (陳其邁) said. “To cope with the strong global demand for advanced chips, TSMC is to start moving in equipment for its first-ever 2-nanometer fab half a year earlier than scheduled,” Chen said at an question-and-answer session at the Kaohsiung City Council. TSMC’s 2-nanometer process technology would help accelerate the development of artificial intelligence (AI) applications as well as the transformation of local industries in Kaohsiung, Chen said in a
TEAM TAIWAN: While lawmakers proposed declaring Nov. 24 a national day, the CPBL commissioner urged the legislature to pass the budget for sports development Lawmakers yesterday proposed designating Nov. 24 as National Baseball Day and updating the design of the NT$500 bill to honor the national team’s victory in the World Baseball Softball Confederation’s Premier12 championship on Sunday, as thousands of fans came out to see the players parade down the streets of Taipei. Players, coaches and staff from the national team returned home on Monday night after achieving their best-ever performance in an international baseball tournament. After receiving a rapturous welcome at the airport, the players turned out yesterday for a street parade in front of thousands of adoring fans waving Taiwanese flags and
Taiwan moved clear of Mexico to be the only country at No. 2 in the World Baseball Softball Confederation (WBSC) Men’s Baseball World Rankings. Meanwhile, draft bills to set up a ministry of sports were approved at a joint session at the legislature in Taipei yesterday. After previously being tied with Mexico for second on 4,118 points, Taiwan moved clear on 5,498 points after they defeated Japan in the final of the WBSC Premier12 tournament on Sunday. Mexico (4,729) dropped to fourth, behind Venezuela (4,846), who finished fourth at the tournament. Taiwan narrowed the gap to first-placed Japan to 1,368 points from 1,638, WBSC
GLOBAL SUPPORT: The Ministry of Foreign Affairs said that the motion highlighted the improper exclusion of Taiwan from international discussion and cooperative mechanisms Taiwan yesterday thanked the British parliament for passing a motion stating that UN Resolution 2758 does not involve Taiwan, making it the latest body to reject China’s interpretation of the resolution. The House of Commons on Thursday debated the international status of Taiwan and unanimously passed a pro-Taiwan motion stating that the House “notes that UN Resolution 2758 does not address the political status of Taiwan or establish PRC [People’s Republic of China] sovereignty over Taiwan and is silent both on the status of Taiwan in the UN and on Taiwanese participation in UN agencies.” British Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Office Parliamentary
RSS