Taiwan's music industry suffered a setback yesterday when the Shihlin District Court found a local peer-to-peer (P2P) file-sharing operator not guilty of infringing intellectual property rights.
In the nation's first ruling on file-sharing cases, the court found that Weber Wu (吳怡達), president of Ezpeer -- which provides a for-fee platform for subscribers to swap files -- did not engage in reproducing or publicly distributing works of copyright holders.
The court also said that current laws and regulations do not specifically ban or limit file-sharing activities.
"We will keep negotiating with record labels to find a way that would create benefits for us, the copyright holders and consumers," Wu said at a press conference yesterday after the verdict was announced.
The plaintiff, the International Federation of the Phonographic Industry (IFPI) in Taiwan, which represents major record labels, said it would appeal the verdict.
"This is the darkest day for the music industry," said Robin Lee (
Lee said the association would also target individual file-sharers for further legal action.
The association has been waging a legal war on P2P operators for three years. A similar lawsuit against kuro.com.tw, Taiwan's largest file-sharing site, has yet to be decided.
Lee said yesterday's verdict would batter the already sagging music industry, citing the failure of the nation's first legal online music distributor, iBIZ Entertainment Technology Corp, which was launched in November 2003, but shut down after 15 months.
The verdict is also a slap in the face to Taiwan's national image, as many countries have found P2P operators liable for infringing copyrights, Lee said.
Taiwan has been trying to improve its intellectual property rights (IPR) protection for several years. In January, the nation was finally taken off the US Trade Representative's "Priority Watch List" and put on the less severe "Watch List" of IPR violators under the US' Special 301 Law. One of the major reasons the US continues to list Taiwan as an IPR violator is rampant file-sharing activities.
Two IPR experts criticized yesterday's ruling.
Taiwan should match the US Supreme Court's ruling on Monday that found file-sharing companies liable for encouraging third parties to use their products to infringe copyrights, said Paul Liu (
Liu said unauthorized use of file-sharing software only serves to discourage song writers or movie producers from creating original works.
John Eastwood, a lawyer with Wenger & Vieli and co-chairman of the Intellectual Property Committee of the European Chamber of Commerce Taipei, said public awareness of IPR protection in Taiwan should also be enhanced to block file-sharing operators.
"The business model of Apple Computer Inc's iTune music store apparently is not viable here, as consumers have long enjoyed free downloading from the Internet," Eastwood said. "I think consumer education is going to be one of the next big battles."
Entertainer Mickey Huang (黃子佼) could be investigated by the judiciary after being implicated in an accusation of sexual harassment and taking nude photographs of a minor, the Taichung District Prosecutors’ Office said yesterday. The office made the remarks after YouTuber “Zofia” in a Facebook post yesterday said that a man groped and kissed her against her will more than a decade ago, and later got her to undress and took nude photographs which he called “artistic portraits” when she was 17 and trying to break into showbusiness. Although the post did not mention the entertainer by name, Huang later released a
Navy Commander Admiral Tang Hua (唐華) yesterday morning presided over the commissioning of a new domestically developed landing platform dock, the Yushan. The Yushan, which would be used to transport amphibious vehicles and other landing craft, is replacing the Hsu Hai dock landing ship, which entered service in 1999. Unlike during past commissioning ceremonies, yesterday’s was closed to the public and was only covered by the Military News Agency, which issued a news release afterward. Tang handed over the national flag and the ship’s seal to its first captain at the ceremony at Kaohsiung’s Zuoying (左營) naval base. He said the Yushan was a
INTIMIDATION: A Chinese invasion of Taiwan is not a forgone conclusion, and the nation and its partners are trying to prevent such an outcome, Joseph Wu said Taiwan wants to secure peace and stability by maintaining the “status quo” across the Taiwan Strait, which it shares with China, and needs the support of European states to do so, Minister of Foreign Affairs Joseph Wu (吳釗燮) said yesterday. “In order for Taiwan to stay strong and resilient and to have the courage to continue the policy of maintaining the status quo, we do need support from European friends,” Wu said in a speech at a conference in the Czech capital, Prague. Wu said Taiwan was drawing lessons from Russia’s invasion of Ukraine to strengthen its resilience against China, which he
‘GUARDIAN OF DEMOCRACY’: Taiwan can find inspiration in Ukraine and Israel, which has deterred an invasion for 50 years, former US security adviser Matt Pottinger said Taiwan can look to Ukraine and Israel to learn about deterrence, which is a better option than war, former US deputy national security adviser Matt Pottinger said during a meeting with President Tsai Ing-wen (蔡英文) yesterday. Pottinger, chairman of the China Program at the Foundation for Defense of Democracies, is visiting Taiwan at the head of delegation of US and Israeli security experts who are also members of the foundation. The group is scheduled to depart today. Russia’s invasion of Ukraine provided a vital insight to Taiwan: “Deterrence is far preferable to war,” Pottinger said. The formula of effective deterrence and safeguarding Taiwan’s peace