The hoodie-wearing billionaires who connected the world through Internet likes and vacation photos are getting the same rewards as the oil and steel moguls of yore: large buildings with their names on them.
Witness the newly rechristened Priscilla and Mark Zuckerberg San Francisco General Hospital and Trauma Center, or the Benioff Children’s Hospital at the University of California at San Francisco, which opened last month. That’s in the same building as the Betty Irene Moore Women’s Hospital, named for the wife of Gordon Moore, the semiconductor industry pioneer who predicted the ever-increasing computer speeds that fostered the rise of tech-era titans.
The largesse comes amid a widening wage gap and soaring housing costs propelled by an influx of generously paid tech workers. San Francisco has seen protests of private luxury buses that whisk them to Silicon Valley company compounds each day. Unions have demonstrated against the city’s payroll-tax break for Twitter and other tech companies.
Photo: REUTERS/Robert Galbraith
In the face of the opprobrium, the executives are taking a page from their Gilded Age forebears.
“The tech industry has created tremendous value through our products, but we need to do a better job of giving back and supporting our communities,” Marc Benioff, 50, chief executive officer of Salesforce.com, said in a statement.
The gap between San Francisco’s wealthiest and poorest workers was exceeded only by that of Atlanta among the 50 largest US metro areas, according to a Brookings Institution report.
“The people at the top are doing very, very well,” said Alan Berube, the report’s co-author. “Top income is placing big cost-of-living pressures on other households in the city.”
While the tech wunderkinds ushered in an economy based on virtual goods, their donations to hospitals, universities and public schools are reminiscent of gifts by industrial tycoons John Rockefeller and Andrew Carnegie, who made fortunes from sweat and steel.
“I’m proud to be part of the long history of tech leaders giving back to their communities, which is really nothing new,” said Ron Conway, an early investor in Twitter and Google, who in January gave US$40 million to an outpatient building at UCSF.
Zuckerberg, the 30-year-old CEO of Facebook, gave SF General US$75 million last month. Benioff donated US$100 million in 2010 to build the children’s hospital that bears his name and an additional US$100 million last year.
Zuckerberg’s wife, Priscilla Chan, a pediatric resident at SF General, helped spur the couple’s donation, likely the largest private-individual gift to a US public hospital, said Sue Currin, its CEO.
“Everyone deserves access to high-quality health care,” Zuckerberg said last month in a post. “We are so fortunate that our work in connecting the world through Facebook has given us the ability to give back to our local community.”
Alysabeth Alexander, vice president of politics for Service Employees International Union Local 1021, which represents teachers and nurses in San Francisco, said the tax break the city approved after Twitter threatened to move reduced funding for services.
“Corporations and CEOs who use strong-arm tactics to avoid paying taxes that fund our schools and roads should not be rewarded for occasional philanthropy,” she said.
Benioff has pressed industry peers to step up their charitable giving, including urging Conway to donate to UCSF, Conway said.
The children’s hospital is among three institutions at a new US$1.5 billion UCSF medical center that opened last month sporting the name of tech executives or, in one case, a technology spouse. The women’s hospital was named after Betty Moore, whose husband co-founded what became Intel, following a US$50 million donation last year.
About 48km south at Stanford University, Sean Parker, the billionaire former president of Facebook and a chronic allergy sufferer, pledged US$24 million in December to create the Sean Parker Center for Allergy Research.
“Rising health-care costs will lead to a system of health-care ‘haves’ and ‘have nots,’ which threatens to engender social instability,” Parker said in a statement.
One reason the industry is funding hospitals is to help the widest swath of residents, Conway said.
“Every single person needs health care,” he said.
The medical-center gifts help the industry address the income inequality, said Mark Laret, CEO of the UCSF Medical Center.
“We should be celebrating the generosity of these people,” Laret said.
Technology executives stepped up giving in the area during the past three years, said Alexa Cortes Culwell, managing director at Philanthropy Futures, a Burlingame, California-based firm that advises on giving.
“So much of this wealth is new, and people have needed some time to understand their options,” Culwell said. “These tech leaders understand that there’s a portion of their giving that should go locally.”
The Industrial Revolution tycoons also felt compelled to give back, having been excoriated as robber barons after accumulating enormous wealth with little regard for the public good.
Rockefeller, founder of the Standard Oil Company, funded the creation of the University of Chicago. Carnegie steered US$350 million of his steel and railroad fortune to causes including the founding of 1,679 US libraries.
Conway said he hopes the new gifts from technology innovators will encourage others to follow suit.
“I’m not sure what else you do with the money,” he said. “When you give it away while you’re alive, the sense of satisfaction is awesome, because we get to see the results.”
With most of his village preferring to converse in Mandarin, opportunities are scant for 81-year-old Kacaw to use his mother language of Amis. But things are changing in his household — one day the family was having an animated discussion when his plucky four-year-old granddaughter Nikal bursts into the room: “You should talk in the mother tongue,” she tells them loudly in Amis. Another time, Nikal’s uncle Yosifu, a well-known artist, overheard her arguing with her grandmother over rights to the television remote — “in our mother tongue,” he tells me excitedly. “With such visible change, I can see hope
British-Indian artist Anish Kapoor , 66, is mounting his largest-ever UK exhibition of outdoor sculpture at Houghton Hall in Norfolk from late this month, including his famous Sky Mirror, a five-meter stainless steel disc that turns the world around it upside down. Sarah Crompton: What kind of things did you want to show at Houghton Hall? Anish Kapoor: It’s one of the great houses of England, with a great history, and extensive grounds. I decided the stone works that I’ve made over the past 25 years, and I’ve never shown in the UK before, would sit quite well there. Then it
Deaths, economic meltdown and a planet on lockdown: the coronavirus pandemic has brought us waves of bad news, but squint and you might just see a few bright spots. From better hygiene that has reduced other infectious diseases to people reaching out as they self-isolate, here are some slivers of silver linings during a bleak moment. WASH YOUR HANDS! The message from health professionals has been clear from the start of the outbreak: wash your hands. Everyone from celebrities to politicians has had a go at demonstrating correct technique — including singing Happy Birthday twice through to make sure you scrub long enough, and
Within 10 minutes of the train pulling into Chaojhou (潮州) in Pingtung County, I’d retrieved my bike from a paid-parking compound and initiated the fitness tracking app on my phone. Just one thing bothered me: The color of the sky. I cycled southeast, passing the shuttered Dashun General Hospital (大順醫院). Given everything that’s going on in the world, I couldn’t help but think: If the government needs extra facilities to handle the COVID-19 epidemic, this sizable building could perhaps be brought back into service. After crossing Highway 1 (台1線), I skirted a settlement established after 2009’s Typhoon Morakot disaster, during which