You may begin by picturing a spring day in Berlin, two months after the rise of Adolf Hitler. It is late March 1933, and a man has called upon an art transporter, Gustav Knauer, to hire him for a job.
His name is Paul von Mendelssohn-Bartholdy, a banker and scion of a wealthy Jewish family of philanthropists and financiers and patrons of the arts. At 58, and in failing health, Herr Mendelssohn-Bartholdy is known throughout Berlin - indeed throughout all Europe - for his luminous collection of Impressionist and early Modern paintings that hang at his town house in the Alsenstrasse and at the family villa outside town.
The matter at hand on this day, March 23, concerns five Picassos that Herr Mendelssohn-Bartholdy is sending to Switzerland. Knauer has arranged for them to be received by a Swiss dealer and placed in private storage. There they will remain for an entire year, safely stowed, until the banker in Berlin decides to sell them, a decision that sets in motion a lawsuit on another continent not to be filed for another 74 years.
That lawsuit, filed this month in Federal District Court in Manhattan, New York, now pits an heir of the Mendelssohn-Bartholdy family against the Solomon R. Guggenheim Foundation and the Museum of Modern Art. The heir, Julius Schoeps, a grandson of one of Paul von Mendelssohn-Bartholdy's sisters, has claimed that two of the Picassos - Le Moulin de la Galette, done in 1900, and Boy Leading a Horse, from 1906 - were sold under duress during the Nazi regime, and thus belong to him. The two museums, which have displayed the paintings for more than 40 years, claim they were never part of a forced sale and have asked a court to declare them the rightful owners.
The lawsuit is many things to many people: a footnote to the Picasso story, an historic art-world spat and the latest example of museums joining forces to win legal confirmation that they own disputed works. But because of the vast research performed by the museums to establish the provenance of the paintings, it is also a privileged and ornately detailed glimpse into the lives of an aristocratic Prussian-Jewish family at the moment of its demise.
Unlike much of European Jewry, the Mendelssohn-Bartholdys lived in luxury from as early as 1795 with the founding of Mendelssohn & Company, the family's private bank. There were thinkers and artists in the family - notably the philosopher Moses Mendelssohn and the composer known as Felix Mendelssohn. By the turn of the 20th century, they were better known for finance and philanthropy and for having been elevated to the aristocracy by Kaiser Wilhelm I.
Following tradition, Paul von Mendelssohn-Bartholdy became a co-owner of the bank in 1908 upon his father's death. An early marriage ended in divorce, and in 1927, he remarried - to the aristocratic and extravagantly named Elsa Lucy Emmy Lolo von Lavergue-Peguilhen, later the Countess Kesselstat.
In the way of wealthy men who marry younger second wives, he presented Elsa with a remarkable wedding gift: his art collection. In fact, he left it to her in a reconfigured will, making her master of all property in the marital homes, while providing income for his four sisters, one of them Schoeps' grandmother.
On May 10, 1935, Paul von Mendelssohn-Bartholdy died of a weak heart in a Berlin sanitarium. After the funeral, his widow and his sisters gathered in the country, with the family lawyer, whereupon the will was read and it was determined, to nobody's surprise, that the deceased had been a very wealthy man.
Beyond personal assets of US$684,000 today, there was the villa, Schloss Bornicke; the town house in Berlin; property on the grounds of a royal palace; and holdings in the Netherlands, Belgium and England. There was also the art, minus those Picassos, which at some point that year - no one knows precisely when - had been sold to a gallery in Munich. The gallery owner, Justin Thannhauser, displayed them briefly at a show in Buenos Aires, Argentina, then kept Le Moulin de la Galette for himself while selling Boy Leading a Horse to an American, William Paley, the founder of CBS.
The lawsuit does not say what either man paid for the paintings, though today it is likely that each would sell for millions of US dollars. A lawyer for Schoeps, who has laid claim to both, did not return a telephone call seeking comment.
By 1945, Thannhauser had fled Germany, taking Le Moulin de la Galette on an exile's tour. He went to Paris first, then Switzerland, then finally New York, where in 1963, he gave the painting to the Guggenheim. The very next year, Paley gave Boy Leading a Horse to the Museum of Modern Art.
According to the lawsuit, the family received nothing for the properties the Nazis stole, including Schloss Bornicke, which stands today in the countryside beyond Berlin, a concert hall and tourist site.
African-American entertainer Dooley appeared on local television show Super Entourage (小明星大跟班) a few weeks ago and was told by the crew that they wanted to do a skit in blackface. Dooley, whose real name is Matthew Candler, tells the Taipei Times that Super Entourage wanted to perform a rendition of the wildly popular “Ghana Coffin Dance,” a meme that has taken the world by storm. Instead, he showed them videos about the racist origins of blackface and slavery in America, and they agreed to drop the makeup. “[I told them] about the history [behind blackface] and [said] you decide
With listicles of local attractions including Costco and numerous children’s playgrounds, I was not expecting much. Opened on Jan. 31, the Taipei MRT’s Circular Line, or Yellow Line, made life in the nation’s capital even more convenient. But judging from Internet search results, it hasn’t opened up many new tourism opportunities, unsurprising as the route mostly crosses densely populated areas and industrial parks. Places like a sports stadium with rainbow colored bleachers perfect for Instagram selfies wouldn’t do it for me either, and it’s pointless to list attractions at the connecting stops that have existed for years. As a history nerd, there
The morning after the ride, my hands ached in a way I’d never before experienced, and my palms looked slightly bruised. Flexing my fingers as I waited for my coffee to cool down, I knew exactly which part of the previous day’s excursion had done this to me. As the go-to-work rush hour ebbed, I’d set off inland on my 125cc scooter. I took Provincial Highway 20 as far as Tainan City’s Yujing District (玉井). From there, I took Provincial Highway 3 into Nansi District (楠西). The route I’d planned would take me past the eastern side of Zengwen Reservoir (曾文水庫)
The recent death of Hana Kimura, a bubbly, pink-haired 22-year-old wrestler and reality TV show star, has spotlighted a rise in cyberbullying in Japan and prompted swift official pledges to do more to protect victims. Kimura, a cast member on the popular program Terrace House, was found dead at her home on May 23 from an apparent suicide after being deluged with negative comments on her social media feeds. Acutely aware of the public debate spurred by her death, Japan’s ruling party is holding hearings from this week to consider legal changes that will help cyberbullying victims seek justice. “People must understand where