Leon Fleisher was a 36-year-old pianist at the peak of his career when he first discovered a slight curling of the fourth and fifth fingers on his right hand. "Within 10 months my fingers had curved inwards until the tips pressed against the palms," he says. "I tried to play through the problem, which only made it worse." As frustrating as the strange spasm was the lack of understanding by the medical profession. Specialists told him it was a type of Parkinson's, it was a form of seizure, it was all in his head.
In fact, Fleisher was suffering from a chronic loss of muscle control known as focal dystonia, an incurable neurological condition — sometimes called musician's cramp or piper's palsy — that can end careers. Fleisher continued to perform by specializing in the piano repertoire written solely for the left hand. But in 2004 he astonished both the medical and musical worlds by making a recovery.
Fleisher's "miracle cure" was a pioneering course of treatment with botulinum toxin, or Botox. Long before Botox became common in beauty regimes, injections into Fleisher's fingers enabled the pianist to make Two Hands, his first conventional recording in more than 40 years.
PHOTO: EPA
Fleisher is far from alone. Research indicates that professional musicians are considerably more susceptible to back pain than the rest of the population, and that 52 percent of musicians who experience muscular discomfort will find the problem to be associated with intensive practice or the unusual posture of playing an instrument. Yet performance-related injury remains something of a taboo subject. Few musicians are prepared to admit that common aches and pains could become career-threatening; many orchestral players insure their instruments far more comprehensively than they insure themselves.
Musicians have always punished their bodies in pursuit of ever-higher technical standards. Perhaps the most notorious historical example of performance-related injury was the case of Robert Schumann, who sought to improve his piano technique with a device designed to separate the tendons of the third and fourth finger. Scholars have since doubted whether the "finger tormentor" was really attributable to Schumann's subsequent disability, yet throughout his career he attempted to resuscitate the use of his hand by soaking it in warm brandy, wrapping it in herbal compounds and even thrusting it into the carcasses of freshly slaughtered animals.
Schumann's determination to become a virtuoso may have been inspired by witnessing performances by Nicolo Paganini, whose extraordinary facility on the violin was possibly the result of a rare growth disorder. It has been suggested that Paganini, an uncommonly tall and sinuous man, suffered from Marfan's syndrome — a condition whose benefits (to violinists at least) include elongated fingers with hyper-elastic joints. If so, it would be a rare instance of a medical disorder actually enhancing performance.
The opposite might be the case of the Canadian pianist Glenn Gould, who grew up with a deformation of the spine exacerbated by his unusually hunched position over the keyboard. Experts also suggest that the pianist's famously eccentric behavior and uncanny focus on technical perfection may have been symptoms of Asperger's syndrome (a diagnosis that did not exist during Gould's lifetime); while film footage indicates that Gould's withdrawal from live performance may have been accelerated by a pronounced curling of the fourth and fifth fingers, similar to the dystonia that halted Fleisher's career.
It was not until the mid-1980s that another dystonia sufferer, the American pianist Gary Graffman, broke the silence surrounding performance-related injury. He published an article arguing that "instrumentalists' hand problems — somewhat like social diseases — are unmentionable. Understandably so: if a performer is still performing, or hopes to get back on the road soon, he'd be crazy to advertise his disabilities. Nobody wants a wounded pianist. There is an oversupply of healthy ones. Admitting difficulties is like jumping, bleeding, into piranha-filled waters."
Twenty years on, many orchestral players, particularly those on freelance contracts, are still reluctant to seek the help they need. Dr. Jonathan White, medical adviser to the City of Birmingham Orchestra, says: "There is a huge stigma attached to admitting one might have a problem. Music is a competitive industry, and few players are willing to divulge anything that might affect their employability."
White holds monthly clinics for CBSO players as part of an attachment scheme administered by the British Association for Performing Arts Medicine (BAPAM), a charity that runs clinics in London, Manchester and Glasgow. Since 1984, it has provided training courses for medical practitioners interested in the performing arts, and is seeking to recruit new associates, particularly outside London.
Many BAPAM doctors are instrumentalists themselves. White, a trained organist, contacted the organization after hearing an appeal on Classic FM. Like all medical advisers to British orchestras, he provides his services for free. "Performing arts medicine in this country is at roughly the stage sports medicine was 30 years ago," he says. "We are only just beginning to appreciate that orchestral players are athletes whose bodies cannot be abused."
Perceptions are gradually beginning to change. This year the Association of British Orchestras made its first awards under the new Healthy Orchestra Charter, a joint initiative with the Musicians' Benevolent Fund that sets an official standard for the working conditions of orchestral players. But the UK is still some way behind the Netherlands and France, which make state provision for injured musicians; and there is as yet no recognized qualification in performing arts medicine in this country.
Patrice Berque, a physiotherapist who runs a BAPAM-affiliated clinic in Glasgow, understands musicians' injuries both as an instrumentalist and as a physician. He was a horn player with several European orchestras before focal dystonia of the lip muscles prematurely ended his career. "The problem is that medics and musicians rarely speak the same language," Berque says. "But there's absolute truth in the cliche that prevention is better than cure. The key is to make players aware that a well-regulated practice routine will prevent serious injuries developing later."
The recommendation of 30 minutes' practice followed by a 15-minute break is, however, rarely compatible with the rehearsal schedules of professional orchestras. Berque was on call throughout the BBC Scottish Symphony Orchestra's preparations for Wagner's Parsifal, during which 90 percent of the string players encountered neck or back pain and required massage or stretching exercises to complete the session. Nor is it only orchestral players who are at risk. Berque's research has unearthed a surprisingly high incidence of focal dystonia among bagpipe players.
"No one has yet proved that there is a definite link between rapid, repetitive muscular movement and dystonia," he says. "Yet bagpipe technique requires even greater malleability of the mouth and lips than say, a clarinet or horn. The research has some way to go; it will be very significant if there is a connection."
There is still much about musicians' maladies that remains imperfectly understood. The New Zealand pianist Michael Houstoun recently described his attempts to keep playing by using splints, rubber bands and even learning the Braille alphabet — remedies that seem no more sophisticated than Schumann's contraption.
As for Berque, his condition was misdiagnosed and untreated for so long that it ruled out any return to a playing career. His clinical work at least offers some compensation. "It keeps me in touch with other musicians, and I still feel part of the musical scene," he says. "Obviously, I wish I could still play. But helping others to keep playing is a fair reward."
The British Association for Performing Arts Medicine Web site is at www.bapam.org.uk
Climate change, political headwinds and diverging market dynamics around the world have pushed coffee prices to fresh records, jacking up the cost of your everyday brew or a barista’s signature macchiato. While the current hot streak may calm down in the coming months, experts and industry insiders expect volatility will remain the watchword, giving little visibility for producers — two-thirds of whom farm parcels of less than one hectare. METEORIC RISE The price of arabica beans listed in New York surged by 90 percent last year, smashing on Dec. 10 a record dating from 1977 — US$3.48 per pound. Robusta prices have
A dozen excited 10-year-olds are bouncing in their chairs. The small classroom’s walls are lined with racks of wetsuits and water equipment, and decorated with posters of turtles. But the students’ eyes are trained on their teacher, Tseng Ching-ming, describing the currents and sea conditions at nearby Banana Bay, where they’ll soon be going. “Today you have one mission: to take off your equipment and float in the water,” he says. Some of the kids grin, nervously. They don’t know it, but the students from Kenting-Eluan elementary school on Taiwan’s southernmost point, are rare among their peers and predecessors. Despite most of
The resignation of Taiwan People’s Party (TPP) co-founder Ko Wen-je (柯文哲) as party chair on Jan. 1 has led to an interesting battle between two leading party figures, Huang Kuo-chang (黃國昌) and Tsai Pi-ru (蔡壁如). For years the party has been a one-man show, but with Ko being held incommunicado while on trial for corruption, the new chair’s leadership could be make or break for the young party. Not only are the two very different in style, their backgrounds are very different. Tsai is a co-founder of the TPP and has been with Ko from the very beginning. Huang has
A few years ago, getting a visa to visit China was a “ball ache,” says Kate Murray. The Australian was going for a four-day trade show, but the visa required a formal invitation from the organizers and what felt like “a thousand forms.” “They wanted so many details about your life and personal life,” she tells the Guardian. “The paperwork was bonkers.” But were she to go back again now, Murray could just jump on the plane. Australians are among citizens of almost 40 countries for which China now waives visas for business, tourism or family visits for up to four weeks. It’s