Some local governments are lobbying for subsidies for oocyte cryopreservation — extracting and freezing eggs from women, with legislators asking the Ministry of Health and Welfare to consider the proposal. Egg freezing seems to have become a silver bullet to solve the problem of delayed marriage and childbearing, but is it?
What would the benefits be of subsidizing the process? What would be the purpose of government subsidies in the national budget? Would it increase the birthrate?
Research in many nations has shown that the main reason women have their eggs frozen is not career or study considerations, but the lack of a partner. What about women in Taiwan? What do they say they need the process for? There is a lack of information to refer to, so implementing subsidies to raise the birthrate without relevant data might be a lot of expense in vain — like hunting for teacups at a hardware store.
International studies show that less than 20 percent of people actually use eggs they have had frozen to undergo in vitro fertilization (IVF), while the success rate of IVF is 30 to 40 percent.
Long-term tracking data in research published last year by National Taiwan University Hospital’s Obstetrics and Gynecology Department showed that over the 18 years of the study, fewer than 10 percent of 645 women who had their eggs frozen had them thawed, with 17 of those who did giving birth. That is a success rate of only 2.6 percent.
Is it reasonable or necessary to use government funds to subsidize egg freezing when the usage and the live birth rates are so low? Why not use these funds to improve support for parents or other things?
Another issue is that the regulatory mechanism for egg freezing is lacking. The focus is on the state of the eggs when they are thawed and used, and avoiding situations in which eggs become unusable after being stored for many years.
Moreover, there were cases of equipment malfunctions at reproduction institutions in the US resulting in the loss of eggs and even embryos. There needs to be careful study of the management of egg freezing institutions in Taiwan so that the rights of prospective parents are protected.
There is no specific law regulating egg freezing in Taiwan, with the preservation of reproductive cells falling under the Assisted Reproduction Act (人工生殖法), which only applies to women who donate eggs. It does not cover the preservation of eggs for use by the prospective mother.
Moreover, there are no regulations or a supervisory system for institutions that provide egg freezing services. Should there be cases of frozen eggs not being properly preserved, it would become a dispute between the consumer and the institution.
Before it even thinks about subsidizing egg freezing, the government should first improve the supervisory system, including monitoring and management of equipment, tracking data such as the freeze and thaw success rates, health assessments and regulating advertising.
Subsidies should only be implemented after these issues are tackled, otherwise it would be like throwing money in the trash.
The attention on egg freezing might be masking a problem with society. Women are freezing their eggs to preserve their fertility as delayed marriage and childbirth become more common. If the government wants to promote subsidies, it needs to do more assessment and planning instead of throwing money at the issue. It must deal with it substantially.
However, the social impact could be complicated if it acts prudently. The underlying problems of delayed marriage and childbearing should be the focus, not the stop-gap measure of subsidies.
Chen Su-fang is secretary-general of the Taiwan Women’s Link.
Translated by Lin Lee-kai
US President Donald Trump last week told reporters that he had signed about 12 letters to US trading partners, which were set to be sent out yesterday, levying unilateral tariff rates of up to 70 percent from Aug. 1. However, Trump did not say which countries the letters would be sent to, nor did he discuss the specific tariff rates, reports said. The news of the tariff letters came as Washington and Hanoi reached a trade deal earlier last week to cut tariffs on Vietnamese exports to the US to 20 percent from 46 percent, making it the first Asian country
In a meeting with Haitian Minister of Foreign Affairs Jean-Victor Harvel Jean-Baptiste on Tuesday, President William Lai (賴清德) vowed to continue providing aid to Haiti. Taiwan supports Haiti with development in areas such as agriculture, healthcare and education through initiatives run by the Taiwan International Cooperation and Development Fund (ICDF). The nation it has established itself as a responsible, peaceful and innovative actor committed to global cooperation, Jean-Baptiste said. Testimonies such as this give Taiwan a voice in the global community, where it often goes unheard. Taiwan’s reception in Haiti also contrasts with how China has been perceived in countries in the region
On Monday, Minister of Foreign Affairs Lin Chia-lung (林佳龍) delivered a welcome speech at the ILA-ASIL Asia-Pacific Research Forum, addressing more than 50 international law experts from more than 20 countries. With an aim to refute the People’s Republic of China’s (PRC) claim to be the successor to the 1945 Chinese government and its assertion that China acquired sovereignty over Taiwan, Lin articulated three key legal positions in his speech: First, the Cairo Declaration and Potsdam Declaration were not legally binding instruments and thus had no legal effect for territorial disposition. All determinations must be based on the San Francisco Peace
As things heated up in the Middle East in early June, some in the Pentagon resisted American involvement in the Israel-Iran war because it would divert American attention and resources from the real challenge: China. This was exactly wrong. Rather, bombing Iran was the best thing that could have happened for America’s Asia policy. When it came to dealing with the Iranian nuclear program, “all options are on the table” had become an American mantra over the past two decades. But the more often US administration officials insisted that military force was in the cards, the less anyone believed it. After
RSS